Making low CR monsters more threatening.
Posted: Sun Dec 06, 2009 9:28 am
A lvl 8 fighter/warblade with 12 dex could easily afford to have:Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I'm interested to hear details on this point. It's something I've struggled with.alhoon wrote:- I figured ways to make monsters of lower CR threatening to a degree. Because in the past (3rd edition) I have found out that many 4 CR 2 monsters just aren't the same with a CR 6 monster.
A large shield+2, Full plate armor +2. Then his buddy the cleric uses protection from evil, +2 deflection.
So that's 27 AC.
8 CR2 monsters are supposed to be a CR 8 encounter.
Checking CR2 monsters we see that a great many of them (Sahuagin, cheetah, goblin fighter 1/rogue 1, dire bat or badger etc) don't have a chance to hit the heavily armored warrior of lvl 8.
Most fighter players that know what they do, will tell you that they prefer to fight solo against 8 badgers than a single hill giant although the hill giant is CR 7.
Sure, flanking is an advantage, especially for those goblins, right? Well, not really. They still hit the fighter with just a natural 20. While a fighter with cleave or two weapons will propably kill a couple each round.
What I do:
I make monsters from scratch.
- Reducing hp by a bit to increase hit roll by a bit. Not Str 12 dex 15 con 14. Str 10 dex 18 con 12 +weapon finesse works better. A Racial curse or power check or a family curse handed down by ancestors etc that gives a +1 to hit rolls, but removes 4 hp. It's not like the CR 2 monster would survive the damage from a fighter's full attack anyway.
- Every 2-3 abilities increase CR by +1. So... I make those abilities count.
The CR 2 undead explodes when dropped to 0 hp for 2d6+6 negative energy damage 10' radius, save vs will for half.
Perhaps it also can make a single ranged touch attack 1/something (hour, 1d?rounds etc) Spewing acid/exhaling fumes/throw a bolt of darkness.
Or perhaps it can make 1 attack like a melee touch attack as if using emerald razor from Tome of Nine Swords.
- Damage reduction 5/something rare.
- For mages: Simply give the monster Resistance to what they usually have. Not all elements they use because that would be unfair to the wizard/sorcerer players. Or a bit of SR, like 14.
4E tactics usable:
Use leaders.
CR 8 = 1 CR 6 + 4 CR 2. If that CR 6 has an aura that gives a 1/4 chance fallen monsters will rise up in the next round with half their hp, or +2 morale to hit/damage rolls, or can use spells to boost their health like mass aid (+1 hr, +1d10+1/lvl hp) etc etc the followers of the bad guy become more important.
Just be careful to not neutralize completely the powers of class all the time.
A fighter that boosts his AC would expect some protection. If 30% of all monsters just ignore his AC then he will rightfully feel cheated.
CR 2 monsters with SR 20 are just plain mean and make wizards feel cheated. I know from experience. "Scorcthing ray... failed. Oh, the fighter kills the one I was targeting... and with cleave the next one too.