Page 1 of 2

Meta-Domination

Posted: Tue Dec 15, 2009 6:32 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
With a powerful vampyr conspiracy in the works IMC, I've been thinking again. The personality affect of domination lends to easy discovery, and makes the thrall less of an asset in long-range plans. To get something closer to Dominic's Obedient, the vampyr analyst IMC has experimented with additional psychological techniques to make vampyr thralldom more effective. Not only does this mean that thralldom is much harder to detect via Sense Motive (it has to beat his hypnosis DC) but I have reason to believe that it would allow the vampyr to push the boundaries of what domination can force one to do.

Specifically, I think that with careful hazing and other psychological manipulation, a person could come to believe that they would be dead in minutes if they fought off control. Thus, if there was some circumstance that would warrant a new saving throw, the victim would willingly fail to avoid the life-threatening situation of being free. It's actually very similar to Stockholm Syndrome in that way: it pits the desire for life against the person's moral compass.

Any thoughts on how to reflect this in rules?

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 1:25 am
by Delyun
Problem with domination is the subject knows their will is being manipulated.It clearly states in domination that they actively fight control but cannot resist following orders.They know they are not in control and know that this is not how it should be.

Problem and i mean major problem.Hypnotism works as the spell hypnotism it is a minor compulsion effect.Domination is a higher level compulsion.They both mind affecting and per the rule of spells the stronger compulsion overrides the lesser.I don't see how can you hypnotize someone who is dominated.

A nice way around this would be a naturally submissive person who would willingly follow orders. Another way is they could in essence raise a child while using Vampyre Venom on them the whole time.The Child would never develop a will of its own since it has always been raised to serve master. It would be harder to detect that it is being controlled if its always been controlled.

Stockholm syndrome requires threats and rewards. The subject has to have free will in stockholm syndrome not the case with Domination.

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 12:55 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Delyun wrote:Problem with domination is the subject knows their will is being manipulated.It clearly states in domination that they actively fight control but cannot resist following orders.They know they are not in control and know that this is not how it should be.
Yes, but the fact remains, a person can deliberately fail a save. Isn't it possible for a person to believe they are better off dominated than free, and thus choose to fail the additional saves? Is it possible to inculcate this belief in someone?
Problem and i mean major problem.Hypnotism works as the spell hypnotism it is a minor compulsion effect.Domination is a higher level compulsion.They both mind affecting and per the rule of spells the stronger compulsion overrides the lesser.I don't see how can you hypnotize someone who is dominated.
Yes, but most skills have multiple uses. The Bluff skill can be used to send innuendo, or to seduce. LotB introduced a new use for the Bluff skill: spreading gossip. This would likewise be a new use for the hypnosis skill, much like in previous FoS works, hypnosis could be used to cloud the mind against thought reading. Hypnosis in 3E is used to cure madness, and was used in 2E to peer into past lives (reincarnation). Those aren't compulsion effects!

Moreover, we're conflating the narrow hypnosis skill with the various non-magical means of inducing a hypnagogic or suggestible state in a person. The person who designed these measures is a tenth-level analyst; I would expect such a person could construct a new means to manipulate the mind that went beyond the strictest interpretations of the class and skill abilities. It would be like researching a new spell.
Stockholm syndrome requires threats and rewards.
Only in the loosest sense of the terms; the classic case of SS required only pointing a gun at someone with the intent to kill (threat) and then choosing not to (reward). Vampyrs can do the same thing: line up all the dominated servants once a week, and make them submit to something that violates their alignment. Anyone who resists has broken the control and is killed on the spot, brutally. Those who fail their saves are glad to be alive, and while they have to do something awful, they can justify it to themselves because they are dominated. Next week, they know the consequences, and they are faced with a choice: resist, and the only way to survive would be to do the objectionable action OF THEIR OWN FREE WILL in order to fake being controlled. Not only that, but they would have to make Bluff checks to appear to be dominated. Given that, plenty of people would fail the new save on purpose, even if it's only unconsciously.
The subject has to have free will in stockholm syndrome not the case with Domination.
Ah, but do they have free will in whether or not to RESIST the domination? Do they have the option of forgoing the saving throw? That's the ONE place left where they still have free will![/quote]

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 2:00 pm
by Delyun
The issue we are bringing up is can you willingly fail a poison save.Even when people poison themselves willingly in real life.The body continues to resist. The will of the person maybe not to resist the poison.I don't see how they can willingly resist when we are talking about a physiological response to a psychological response.You could make it that they would willing allow themselves to be poisoned but the physiological response would to be resist.There are plenty of cases where people poison themselves so they can die but the body resists the poison and they live.

The domination effect we are talking about is a physical response to a poison not a willpower response.

Hypnotism in the skill description clearly states the hypnotic state is exactly as the same as the hypnotism spell.The thing you are talking about is repression where they help them forget traumatic events using hypnotism which aids but does not always work.

Then comes a third problem what if someone has a poison detecting magic item.It would show the person dominated as being poisoned.

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 2:03 pm
by HuManBing
Some physical reactions to poisons might be suppressible (e.g. gag reflex, vomiting, even increased breathing). But as Delyun points out, most of the lethal effects are taking place on a molecular level far too minute for conscious effort to affect. If somebody decides to "roll with it" and submit to a poison, I'd say give the poison roll a small bonus against his body's response rather than any sort of auto-failure.

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 2:08 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
HuManBing wrote:Some physical reactions to poisons might be suppressible (e.g. gag reflex, vomiting, even increased breathing). But as Delyun points out, most of the lethal effects are taking place on a molecular level far too minute for conscious effort to affect. If somebody decides to "roll with it" and submit to a poison, I'd say give the poison roll a small bonus against his body's response rather than any sort of auto-failure.
...okay, so you're saying this would work with magical domination, but not poison-induced domination?

If this is strictly a physiological reaction, why would the person get an additional save when called on to do something against their alignment? What does that extra save represent, if not a rallying of psychological forces? And if the person rallies those forces when put in a situation contrary to his or her alignment, can't he or she choose NOT to rally them?

So if the person actually has no choice but to resist the poison when faced with a situation that is contrary to his or her alignment, then instead of voluntary failing a save, it's a voluntary alignment change to avoid the extra save.

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 11:35 pm
by Delyun
DeepShadow you make me whip out the books so much.They starting to pile up again.

The reason they get a save versus a command that is against their alignment cause the poison may be a physical thing but its basically a psychotropic poison.They get put into a poison induced state of susceptibility.The additional save is the brain shaking off the fugue.
Since I would say its a psychotropic poison it qualifies for what i have proposed below.

They automatically make a fortitude save versus the poison when it is given to them until it becomes a drug.Once it becomes a drug to them no save required for poison or orders against alignment.They are hooked.

If they become a long time user.I would say over a few months to a year.They go no save to shake off the effects once they become a drug user to vampyre venom.

Without the poison in their system they go through withdrawal. If they been taking the poison long enough the body would be partially dependent on it. The symptoms of withdrawal suck and the would negate their desire to rally versus it. Most of the points I made are for those they are just starting to make slaves.Long term slaves wouldn't want to fight against their master as they would lose the effects of the poison in their system and go through withdrawal.

I like how this is going Deepshadow.I really do first we started with a poison, and then we found out its a venom.Now we find out its a psychoactive poison that can be used as a drug.I kinda went heavy on the low addictive save but with heavy withdrawal penalty.The dexterity is cause they feel lethargic.Wisdom cause since its a strong psychoactive poison and would have a high psychological addiction.

Withdrawal for Vampyre Venom
Addiction Rating Negligible ( Don't see many people getting addicted)
Fort DC 6( Must make save everyday or they need another bite)
Satiation 10 Days.( Same as duration)
Ability Damage when going through withdrawal 1d4 Dex 1d4 Wis.
They need to make the fort dc save every day or they need more venom.
Addiction DC +5 once satiation ends.

I kinda mixed drug ratings but this has no chance of increasing rating . My reason for that it makes better venom users without the insane I need the venom everyday with massive fort saves required.


Yes I will admit it.If you can't tell by now.I am a rules lawyer.

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 3:20 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Hmm... interesting idea. I may have an addictive version as a salient ability, but what I'm hoping for here is different. Another example may be the best way of expressing it.

Alright, a huge group of vampyr get some 60 of their thralls into the feeding houses and they play a game: force the thralls to beat up another thrall. They watch closely for people to shake off the effects and resist, because this is against their alignment. Round one, approximately ten break free and make a break for it. The vampyr call off the game, round up the ones who broke free, and kill them in front of the others. Then the game continues, and the thralls are ordered to go for the kill. More alignment violations, another ten or so break free, they are rounded up and slaughtered. Next round, the victim is dead, the thralls are told to drink the blood....

By now they know what will happen if they throw off the domination. You agreed that the extra save represented the rallying of psychological forces. What can the victims possibly do to avoid breaking the domination effect, and thus earning certain death? Can they do anything to avoid breaking free, or will this game end in death for all sixty? I think there will be a significant percentage that will quickly adapt to this game so that they stop making the bonus saves, and thus stay alive. Allow me to explain why:

We know from the books that their consciousness is still present. They are aware of what is going on, but not in control. Staying out of the driver's seat is the only way to stay alive, and they know it. So what can they do to avoid this fate? If, as you admit, this bonus save is the rallying of psychological forces to regain control, then their best hope is to not rally this forces: they voluntarily fail the save. This is allowed by the rulebooks.

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 9:37 am
by Delyun
Problem with voluntarily failing fort save it must be a conscious and willing choice.They are conscious but have no will of their own.The description of dominate states they fight this control.That is why they get the second save too.Remember as well if the master doesn't check on the thrall and tell them to continue the last order at least once a day.They get a save anyway to shake off the poison.

Voluntarily failing saving throws in PHB refers to spells. Book of vile darkness extends this to drugs.

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 1:19 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Delyun wrote:Problem with voluntarily failing fort save it must be a conscious and willing choice.They are conscious but have no will of their own.
Except the will to fight back. If they didn't have that, they wouldn't get the second save!
The description of dominate states they fight this control.That is why they get the second save too.
Unless they have lost the will to fight back.
Voluntarily failing saving throws in PHB refers to spells. Book of vile darkness extends this to drugs.


Yes, and this poison reproduces a spell effect, despite being nonmagical. Someone can voluntarily fail the save against the spell, why not the poison.

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 1:32 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Come to think of it, why DOES a vampyr's bite require a Fort save, when the only effect is mental? I think this ought to be a Will save. Anyone else?

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 1:35 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Just to throw another wrinkle in there...what does compliance prove under these conditions? The number of people who will refuse to obey an order to hurt someone else when the alternative is "being killed and eaten" is, well, not large. How do the vampyres know compliance is because their domination is still in force, as opposed to compliance because the erstwhile thrall knows which side his bread is buttered on in the present circumstances?

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 1:58 pm
by Delyun
Its a venom.

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 2:56 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Just to throw another wrinkle in there...what does compliance prove under these conditions? The number of people who will refuse to obey an order to hurt someone else when the alternative is "being killed and eaten" is, well, not large. How do the vampyres know compliance is because their domination is still in force, as opposed to compliance because the erstwhile thrall knows which side his bread is buttered on in the present circumstances?
Excellent point! What I'm going for here is actually an attempt to meld the spell effects with real-world brainwashing techniques--hazing, Stockholm Syndrome, maybe even sensory deprivation. The combined effect is going to be better than the whole. The wrinkle you are talking about is where these effects overlap and possibly have synergistic effects.

Posted: Mon Dec 21, 2009 5:21 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, I lost my post in the server glitch, and I looks like I was not the only one who did so. Let's see if I can't write it better:

We're at a critical point in my campaign: one PC has been captured by Grigor, another plans to volunteer for Modlein Haus in the hopes of becoming a deep, deep, DEEP cover operative for Kara's Daughters, and an adventure hook has suggested a possible relationship between Modlein and Mama Bertina's. I need to lay out all the mind-sculpting resources that Grigor has available, and how he uses them. Every aspect of Modlein Haus is used to reshape the trainees.

Food: occasionally laced with Wisdom-damaging poison, possibly henbane if Grigor can tweak the Madness effect. In addition, vampyr venom is frequently added to the food. This doesn't require a save or induce mind control, but it fools the trainee's body into not fighting off the venom, imposing a penalty to future saves.

Sleep: nightmare candles or other devices to induce manipulative dreams?

Hygeine: sauna area for bathing and relaxation, with drugged steam and one-way observation area.

Interviews: not sure what Grigor will be like after his writeup, but at the very least I'd expect the following of a week-long set of one-hour interviews: perma-charm, determine exact alignment, detailed records of relationships, associations, skills and other important information, and up to seven rewrites of critical memories to reduce dependency on outside relationships. Grigor uses a Heinfroth's Contemplative Davenport (RLDMG) for these interviews.

Relationships: approximately one in five trainees is a vampyr being trained for infiltrating a human family. These will often pretend to snoop around to bait out the curious and suspicious for special attention.