Page 1 of 1
Improving the Analyst
Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 9:06 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, so I just ran a major encounter last night with Dr. Grigor Heimeln (LE vampyr Exp6/Ana10) and while he made out okay, I was a little disappointed in this class. Anyone else wanna take a look?
First, there's the charm ability at third level. It's permanent and can't be dispelled? Does anyone else think it's too powerful?
The rest of the class feels very underpowered. +2 bonuses for this and that, a weak spell list where tradeouts are considered a privilege, and weeks of work to grant others a bonus to a roleplaying mechanic. What suggestions for fixing it.
Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 10:34 pm
by NeoTiamat
...don't use Ravenloft classes because they're usually painfully weak?
More seriously, remind me what book the Analyst class is in? It sounds Legacy of the Blood-ish?
Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 11:08 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Yup, that's it. And I agree, but we've rebuilt several others. I'd just like to offer this one up for next on the list, eh?
Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 11:35 pm
by Delyun
Um question and its kinda important. Is Dr. Grigor Heimeln a d'Honaire?
That's a family class and requires you to be a d'honaire built using the family sub race from page 31 in legacy of blood.
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 1:06 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Ummm, not finding anywhere that says it's exclusive to the bloodline. Introduction says that some feats and classes are exclusive, while some are not. Grigor studied under Francois Mousel, who developed the theories the class is based on. Where does it say the class is exclusive to the bloodline?
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 1:26 am
by Delyun
Ok. Just find it odd a d'honaire would teach an outsider a family art.
The art was not formalized till 752. In 753 Celeste shows up.
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 2:08 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Delyun wrote:Ok. Just find it odd a d'honaire would teach an outsider a family art.
The art was not formalized till 752. In 753 Celeste shows up.
Yes, but it was formalized over the course of decades, through correspondence with the other great scholars of the mind, and with the help of a large sanitarium staff, few of whom were part of the family. Hardly something they were trying to keep exclusive to the family.
For the record, Grigor joined Mousel's staff in 728 and served for twenty years. By the time he left in 748 he was one of four "floor wardens," doctors who sat in council directly with Francois and James and reported to no one else. As the senior floor warden, Grigor had been present for or involved with every major development in the course of the method, and after he left to start Modlein Haus he continued to correspond with the Mousels, offering them valuable and sometimes critical data for the development of their method. While Francois and James were the only names on the monograph as authors, Grigor was second in the list of scholars they thanked (just under Tempus Lamark) and was cited more often than any other scholar save the Mousels.
Now, do you have anything to offer on the topic of improving the clas?
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 2:55 am
by Delyun
This has been removed by me.Read lower for revised changes.
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 3:06 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, I'm liking some of these, especially the spells. I'd swap out ventriloquism to bring back detect magic, though; an analyst would be looking for influences of magical control a lot more than throwing their voice.
I like limited trusted friend to a specific number, with new ones bumping out the old. I'll have to look at other such classes to see how the numbers go.
I'd like to see something about controlling the type or severity of a F/H/M check. At tenth level they can cure or induce madness, but there are no intermediary steps where they can nudge it in a particular direction. Why can't an evil analyst give someone a phobia of spiders? What about nudging a Madness check toward multiple personalities or amnesia?
In addition, why not dovetail this with the existing rules for recovering from Madness? A recovering patient under the care of a hypnotist gets four checks a month instead of one already, so have the analyst's bonuses figure into these checks. Perhaps a successful check allows the patient to reduce the severity of the madness, so that moderate effects become mild and so forth.
Okay, I'm gonna read some more....
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 3:47 pm
by NeoTiamat
As a thought, I think the class most like what you're looking for is the Mindbender from Complete Arcane.
The key notes of both classes is a limited number of powerful assistants, combined with spellcasting boosts.
The one major change I would recommend is that you make the Analyst class a half or two/thirds spell progression class. As is, we're talking that by 14th level or so, you can cast... a tiny amount of 4th level spells. You just got Dominate Person at the same time they're getting Mass Charm Person and Chain Lightning. A limited spell progression would also make the class much more attractive by giving it something more against enchantment-immune foes.
You may also want to simplify the Commanding Presence / Lure / Abyss Stares Back some, and maybe make them broader. A flat bonus to Enchantment spells, as well as Fear-based Necromancy spells? (Or all Necromancy spells, for that matter).
Posted: Sat Dec 19, 2009 11:59 pm
by Delyun
Removed by me. Read Lower for changes.
Posted: Sun Dec 20, 2009 3:06 am
by Delyun
Analyst(my proposed changes ignore the ones before i like this version best)
Mindshadows:
Remove Phobia
Starting at at 4th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus a specific fear you can remove a phobia related to that fear.This requires you to speak to the subject for one hour a day for a week and make a Hypnosis check DC 16.Fail the check and they lose the +2 bonus.
Instill Phobia
Starting at at 4th level on someone you permanently gave a -2 penalty versus a specific fear you can instill a phobia related to that fear.This requires you to to speak to the subject for one hour a week and make a Bluff Check DC 16.Fail and they lose the -2 Penalty.
Trusted Friend
You may only have 1 trusted friend at 3rd level.You may have 2 at 5th level.You may have 3 at 7th level. You may have 4 at 9th level.If you try to make a new friend while you have the max allowed by level you lose the oldest friend.This effect can only be broken by break enchantment.
Insightful: The bluff bonus counts for Gaslighting ,Mindshadows: Instill Phobia,ShadowTerrors:Instill Horror, Discern Nature:Fall into Darkness,Mind Bending:Instill Madness and Mind Harnessing
Shadow Terrors:
Remove Horror
At 5th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus horror.You may remove a minor horror effect.You must spend 1 hour speaking to the subject and make a hypnosis check versus the failed check dc.Success and the horror effect is removed.Fail the check and the horror effect dc increases by 5 and becomes a moderate horror effect.This may be done once per day.
At 7th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus horror.You may reduce a moderate horror effect to a minor of your choice.You must spend 1 hour a day for three days speaking to the subject and make a hypnosis check versus the failed check dc.Success and the horror effect becomes a minor of your choice and the dc decreases by 5.Fail and the horror effect increases by 5 and becomes major.This may be done once per week.
At 9th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus horror.You may reduce a major horror effect to a moderate of your choice.You must spend one hour a day for one week speaking to the subject and make a hypnosis check versus the failed check dc.Success and the horror effect becomes a moderate of your choice and the dc decreases by 5 .Fail and the DC Increases by 10.This may be done once per month.
Instill Horror
At 5th level on someone you permanently gave a -2 penalty versus horror.You may instill a minor horror effect.You must spend one hour speaking to the subject and make a Bluff check DC 8.Success and they gain a minor horror effect of your choice at DC 5.Fail and they lose the -2 Penalty.This may be done once per day.
At 7th level on someone you permenantly gave a -2 penalty versus horror.You may increase a minor horror effect to moderate.You must spend one hour a day for three days speaking to the subject and make a Bluff check DC 16.Success and they gain a moderate horror effect of your choice DC 10.Fail and the horror effect is removed completely. This may be done once per week.
At 9th level on someone you permenantly gave a -2 penalty versus horror.You may increase a moderate horror effect to major.You must spend one hour a day for one week speaking to the subject and make a Bluff check DC 16.Success and they gain a major horror effect of your choice DC 15.Fail and the horror effect is reduced to minor and the DC is reduced by 5. This may be done once per month.
Discern Nature:
See the Light
At 8th level on someone you have successfully used discern nature for their exact alignment you may move them one alignment step toward good or law.This requires seeing the patient one hour a day for a week.
Requires a Hypnosis check DC 25 for each move.They can only be moved two alignment steps maximum from their original.
At 10th level you may move them two more alignment steps. This requires seeing the patient one hour a day for a month.Requires a hypnosis check DC 35 for each move.They can be moved a maximum of two more steps.
Fall into Darkness
At 8th level on someone you have successfully used discern nature for their exact alignment you may move them one alignment step toward evil or chaos.This requires seeing the patient one hour a day for a week.
Requires a bluff check DC 25 for each move.They can only be moved two alignment steps maximum from original alignment.
At 10th level you may move them two more alignment steps. This requires seeing the patient one hour a day for a month.Requires a bluff check DC 35 for each move.They can be moved a maximum of two more steps.
Superior Technique The hypnosis bonus counts for helping a person recover from madness,Mindshadows: Remove Phobia,ShadowTerrors:Remove Horror, Discern Nature:See the light,Mind Bending:Remove Madness and Mind Harnessing
MindBending:
Remove Madness
At 8th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus Madness.You may remove a minor Madness effect.You must spend one hour speaking to the subject and make a hypnosis check versus the failed check DC.Success and the madness effect is removed.Fail the check and the madness effect DC increases by 5 and becomes a moderate madness effect.This may be done once per day
At 9th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus Madness.You may reduce a moderate Madness effect to a minor of your choice.You must spend one hour a day for three days speaking to the subject and make a hypnosis check versus the failed check DC.Success and the madness effect becomes a minor of your choice and reduce the DC by 5.Fail the check and the madness effect DC increases by 5 and becomes a major madness effect.This may be done once per week.
At 10th level on someone you permanently gave a +2 bonus versus Madness.You may reduce a Major Madness effect to a moderate..You must spend one hour a day for one week speaking to the subject and make a hypnosis check versus the failed check DC.Success and the madness effect becomes a moderate of your choice and reduce the DC by 5.Fail the check and the madness effect DC increases by 10.This may be done once per month.
Instill Madness
At 8th level on someone you permanently gave a -2 Penalty versus Madness.You may instill a minor Madness effect.You must spend one hour speaking to the subject and make a Bluff check DC 15.Success and they gain a minor madness effect of your choice at DC 10.Fail and they lose the -2 Penalty.This may be done once per day.
At 9th level on someone you permanently gave a -2 Penalty versus Madness.You may increase a minor Madness effect to a moderate of your choice.You must spend one hour a day for three days speaking to the subject and make a Bluff check DC 30.Success and they gain a moderate madness effect of your choice DC 20.Fail and the madness effect is removed completely. This may be done once per week
At 10th level on someone you permanently gave a -2 Penalty versus Madness.You may increase a moderate Madness effect to a major of your choice.You must spend one hour a day for one week speaking to the subject and make a Bluff check DC 45.Success and they gain a major madness effect of your choice DC 30.Fail and the madness effect is reduced to minor and the DC is reduced by 10. This may be done once per month.
Mind Harnessing:
Mold the Fragile Mind
A Trusted Friend Subjected to first the mind shattering and then the sanity restoring effects of Mind Harnessing is treated as under a dominate person spell.They no longer count as a Trusted friend.The domination is absolute ,they cannot be dominated by another and it has no duration.They cannot be detected as dominated due to the fact they have free will and have chosen to follow their master orders.They will follow all orders without question even suicidal orders.They always act in their masters best interest above their own interests.This can only be broken by Disjunction and that only removes the sanity restoring effect of Mind Harnessing.Which leaves an insane person in their presence.You may only have one person subject to this at a time.
Spells Per Day
Level
1st 2|1|0|-|-|-|-
2nd 2|1|1|-|-|-|-
3rd 3|2|1|0|-|-|-
4th 3|2|2|1|-|-|-
5th 4|3|2|1|0|-|-
6th 4|3|3|2|1|-|-
7th 4|4|3|2|1|0|-
8th 4|4|4|3|2|1|-
9th 4|4|4|3|2|1|0
10th 4|4|4|4|3|2|1
Spells Known(All Spells known when they become available to cast)
0 level Daze,Detect Magic,Ghost Sound ,Lullaby, Message, Prestidigitation
1st Level Cause fear, Charm Person,Comprehend Languages,Hypnotism,Lesser Confusion,Remove Fear, Sleep, Hideous Laughter,Ventriloquism
2nd Level Calm Emotions, Daze Monster, Detect Thoughts,Enthrall,Hold Person,Hypnotic Pattern, Rage ,Suggestion, Tongues
3rd Level Charm monster, Confusion,Crushing Despair,Deep Slumber,Fear, Glibness,Geas Lesser,Scare
4th Level Dominate Person, Hold Monster,Modify Memory, Rainbow Pattern.
5th Level Dream, Nightmare, Suggestion Mass,Phantasmal Killer
6th Level Charm Monster Mass, Eyebite,Geas/Quest, Irresitable Dance
Posted: Sun Dec 20, 2009 12:23 pm
by Troile
It should definitely have Phantasmal Killer.