Right size the Sea of Sorrows?
Posted: Sat Jan 09, 2010 1:58 pm
As entries for the Sea of Sorrows Gaz are being penned as we speak, this is probably the last occasion to weigh this idea.
Mangrum has suggested that in our treatment of the seas their size be significantly increased, that is to say the distance between the islands and their distance from the Core.
Whereas expanding the size of the Core itself is, understandably, controversial, putting more empty space between things at sea seems to me to be potentially far less so. Especially, as was noted recently, if the Core is to be claustrophobic, the seas should be terrifying by their vast emptiness. Furthermore, looking over the maps, few if any have a scale, and some at least include the islands in such away as to suggest that their distance from the Core is governed by the available space on the page rather than intended to communicate the proporitionate position. And of course the designers have by and large not given distances and have explicitly said, from time to time, that the length of a trip is whatever is convenient from the perspective of the Dark Powers, hence inevitably arriving to confront the vampire at sunset.
To my eye the idea iis almost self-evident, for it address the great inconvenience that at current dimensions we should not be discussing galleons, carracks, or perhaps even caravels, which are long range craft. Brigs, barks and smaller craft themselves being nearly overkill. We would want vessels for something much, much smaller than the Baltic Sea.
The matter was fudged as well as it could be in the Nocturnal Sea by specifying that it is not safe to sail directly from some point X to some point Y, but a similar such specification would again be a fudge rather than a chance to take advantage of the benefits that would accrue from fixing the problem.
Thoughts?
Mangrum has suggested that in our treatment of the seas their size be significantly increased, that is to say the distance between the islands and their distance from the Core.
Whereas expanding the size of the Core itself is, understandably, controversial, putting more empty space between things at sea seems to me to be potentially far less so. Especially, as was noted recently, if the Core is to be claustrophobic, the seas should be terrifying by their vast emptiness. Furthermore, looking over the maps, few if any have a scale, and some at least include the islands in such away as to suggest that their distance from the Core is governed by the available space on the page rather than intended to communicate the proporitionate position. And of course the designers have by and large not given distances and have explicitly said, from time to time, that the length of a trip is whatever is convenient from the perspective of the Dark Powers, hence inevitably arriving to confront the vampire at sunset.
To my eye the idea iis almost self-evident, for it address the great inconvenience that at current dimensions we should not be discussing galleons, carracks, or perhaps even caravels, which are long range craft. Brigs, barks and smaller craft themselves being nearly overkill. We would want vessels for something much, much smaller than the Baltic Sea.
The matter was fudged as well as it could be in the Nocturnal Sea by specifying that it is not safe to sail directly from some point X to some point Y, but a similar such specification would again be a fudge rather than a chance to take advantage of the benefits that would accrue from fixing the problem.
Thoughts?