Page 1 of 1

New Musical for the Richemulot Stage

Posted: Thu Jan 21, 2010 8:07 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
I found this puzzle in a book of logic problems, and thought it belonged in the RL theater. I vote for Richemulot because Dementlieu would disapprove of the ending because it sounds too seditious, while Borca would disapprove because it wasn't a tragedy. YMMV.

The musical Seeking Sabrina centers on a woman who runs away to join a band of gypsies, and the search for her by Raphael, her estranged lover. At the climax of the play, Raphael descends upon the gypsy encampment where Sabrina is hiding, causing her to disguise herself and pose as the wife of the gypsy man she has fallen in love with. Although Raphael cannot identify her, he sense Sabrina's presence and refuses to leave without questioning the gypsy band's five couples one by one. The women (Florita, Marisa, Rosita, Sabrina and Yolanda) and their partners (Alberto, Carlos, Eduardo, Tomas, and Zambro) reluctantly agree. Fortunately, their quick-wittedness and affection for Sabrina aid in maintaining her cover, and the finale is a song of rejoicing by the full chorus of performers.

So that's the set-up for the puzzle. I just sounded like it belonged in RL, eh? Do with it as you will.

Posted: Thu Jan 21, 2010 8:15 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
And for those who want to actually try the puzzle:

A recent production of Seeking Sabrina featured five local actresses (Grace, Hope, Lydia, Naomi, and Olivia) and actors (Bart, Daniel, Ike, Jasper, and Ken) in these important roles. Can you discover the order in which each actress was questioned, the woman that she played, the actor with whom each was partnered, and the male role he played?

1) The first woman questioned was Yolanda.
2) The five actors are Bart, Ike, the actor who played Alberto, Naomi's partner, and the partner of the actress who played Marisa.
3) The woman played by Olivia was questioned immediately before Tomas, and immediately after Jasper's character.
4) Florita was questioned at some point before Eduardo.
5) Grace, who didn't play Marisa, played the second woman questioned.
6) Ike didn't play Carlos.
7) The actress who played Yolanda (who wasn't Bart's partner) and Naomi were roommates in college.
8) Daniel was partnered with the actress who played Rosita.
9) The man who played Tomas wasn't partnered with Lydia or Naomi.
10) Grace wasn't partnered with the actor who played Alberto.

Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 7:26 pm
by Ail
I'm trying, but this seems quite hard. Can we assume that the couples are always questioned in a fixed order, say woman first?

Thanks

Posted: Fri Jan 22, 2010 10:39 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Answer submitted. :lucas:

Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:01 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Ail wrote:I'm trying, but this seems quite hard. Can we assume that the couples are always questioned in a fixed order, say woman first?

Thanks
Good question! To clarify, couples are actually questioned simultanously, thus if a woman is questioned first, her partner is also questioned first. Conversely, if a woman is questioned before a man (or vice versa) they cannot be partners.

This was not explicitly stated in the puzzle, but i realize now it was implicitly stated in the solving boxes that were included. The boxes run in five rows of five, reading L-R "order," "actress," "role," "actor," "role." Thus the pairs must be questioned simultaneously.

Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:04 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Yeah, you can't solve it without having the couples questioned together, which I suppose is what the question is trying to convey with "questions the couples one by one".

Since "couples" and "one by one" don't fit together very well it's easy to get tripped up here...the semantics were actually the hardest part of the puzzle for me, time-wise!

Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 5:18 pm
by Ail
Well, thanks. Please don't write the answer here, I'm still trying to solve it.

These problems are old old friends of mine :) good memories!

Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 6:34 pm
by Ail
Submitted an answer too.

Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 9:06 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Good work, both of you! This was a four-star puzzle, so that's pretty tough, but you both cracked it.

Anyone else wanna have a go?

Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 9:30 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
phew... that took way longer than expected, but I got it eventually. (For a while I was convinced there were two solutions, but one led into a contradiction)

Thanks, DS. I love those kind of puzzles. I actually used one of my own creation as a dungeon crawl trap in my campaign:

The exit is blocked by a wall of bone with four holes in vertical line. An inscription on the wall reads:

Coin and bone hand and stone
Open this forbidden zone
Placed in proper holes in wall
In proper order or I take them all

Bones are buried beneath the earth,
Though the stone be not in the highest hole.
Keep your hand close to your metal worth,
Or perhaps you will find that both be stole
The coin is before the lowest but below the last.
At least two follow, when the bone is in the past.




(And yes, the setup for DeepShadow's puzzle does scream Ravenloft to me as well).

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 10:09 am
by Ail
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Yeah, you can't solve it without having the couples questioned together, which I suppose is what the question is trying to convey with "questions the couples one by one".

Since "couples" and "one by one" don't fit together very well it's easy to get tripped up here...the semantics were actually the hardest part of the puzzle for me, time-wise!
The hardest part for me was dealing with hint 2. That gave me 4 possible branches, and I selected one and it did lead to a good solution. I then had to check all other 3 until they all ended in a contradiction, but that was not obvious at all at the start :)

Lucky me I picked the good one first =)