Page 1 of 5

The Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 10:47 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Alright, IMC I have one PC with strong familial ties to this group, and I'm considering tying another to them. So I figure it's about time to brainstorm some things about these folks. First things first: what is their advantage? How do they manage to wage a campaign of extermination against all manner of supernatural critters while eschewing magic themselves? How do they avoid getting infiltrated by supernatural creatures bent on revenge,or at least self-preservation? I have my thoughts on the matter, but I'd like to hear from all of you first.

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 6:33 am
by Germaine
IMC, I have adopted a sort of "end justifies the means" attitude for the Syndicate. In other words, they hate the supernatural and seek its overall destruction, but will still use it in "small" ways to accomplish their overall goal- for example, using wizards to create special weapons for them, or manipulating magic-using adventurers. In addition, I've had some of their members be able to use science to create non-magical "spell-like" effects, much like Mordenheim, and given them a healthy interest in psionics, since they see this as non-magical, and the lesser of two evils. Among their major tools have been a kind of "super soldier"/ assassin that they call Blades of Enlightenment, the Brotherhood of Broken Blades,-which IMC is the creation and pet project of a major Syndicate member- and a strange sort of "double agent" connection with the FoS Umbra- well, one member anyway.And also never forget that enough money and political influence can buy a lot of knowledge, rare materials, "expendable" mercenaries,etc.

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 8:36 am
by Guzrath
At the moment I can't firgure out who those enlightened are. Was that in Lamordia?

Anyway,
In Legacy of Blood, the Mordenheims have a class with which they can create items that can copy the exact effect of a spell. In stead of them using magic, let them use "rational created items" that have the same effect as the spells.

As for infiltration, I have no idea..... True seeing item?

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 11:47 am
by Herman Strauss
You can always use the “Paradox” effect from the old “Mage the Ascension” RPG.
Magic (and Faith in this case) are actually disbelieved by the powers of the rational mind. The more people to solidify the supernatural “grounding” effect, the more severe its effects are on creatures closely related with the Arcane or the Divine. Fey wither and die, ghosts fade into nothingness and magical beasts are weakened until they become mere natural anomalies, caged for scientific experimentation with nothing extraordinary about them.

This could be simulated with a feat that allows those that have it to establish a Reality where the supernatural is confronted with resistance(e.g. DC to use supernatural powers or spells equal to 10+1/2 the levels of the senior character + the combined Int modifiers of the group -positive or negative)

Extra feats could grant access to a Turn simulating ability, fear and horror resistance/immunity, dead magic zones/circles of protection and negative level bestowing upon supernatural creatures (the last once is really ironic, especially on vampires!).

All these however should depend on strength of numbers; one man’s point of view isn’t enough to establish a mundane reality.
Also, creatures with these feats or a class with similar abilities should have the same effects on magic-using Darklord as a paladin of equal level)

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:22 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Herman Strauss wrote:Magic (and Faith in this case) are actually disbelieved by the powers of the rational mind.
Sounds like the Logical Mind or Godless feats, which I agree would be very common in the Syndicate, if not prerequisites for advancement.
The more people to solidify the supernatural “grounding” effect, the more severe its effects are on creatures closely related with the Arcane or the Divine. Fey wither and die, ghosts fade into nothingness and magical beasts are weakened until they become mere natural anomalies, caged for scientific experimentation with nothing extraordinary about them.
And that sounds like the Smothering of Reason effect in Lamordia. Could the Syndicate create an accelerated version of it in a localized area?
This could be simulated with a feat that allows those that have it to establish a Reality where the supernatural is confronted with resistance(e.g. DC to use supernatural powers or spells equal to 10+1/2 the levels of the senior character + the combined Int modifiers of the group -positive or negative)
Actually, this sounds like a prestige class that would have one of the above feats as a prerequisite.
Extra feats could grant access to a Turn simulating ability, fear and horror resistance/immunity, dead magic zones/circles of protection and negative level bestowing upon supernatural creatures (the last once is really ironic, especially on vampires!).
Again, this sounds a lot more like a prestige class than a set of feats.
All these however should depend on strength of numbers; one man’s point of view isn’t enough to establish a mundane reality.
Add combined levels in the prestige class to determine the localized effect, and require it to be around 25 before you get any significant localized effect.
Also, creatures with these feats or a class with similar abilities should have the same effects on magic-using Darklord as a paladin of equal level)
All the more reason to base them in Lamordia! Okay, I'll go a step further: members of this class also offend magical creatures the way paladins offend evil ones.

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 3:17 pm
by The Giamarga
Guzrath wrote:At the moment I can't firgure out who those enlightened are. Was that in Lamordia?
Yes, apparently they are based in Lamordia and described in GAZ2. I had to look them up too. (The Catalogue is an invaluable resource.)

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 3:27 pm
by DocBeard
Here's what I don't quite parse. Well beyond using a very 20th century villain in a setting where the line between scientist and wizard is pretty darn blurry.

Arcane magic is supposed to be relatively scientific, right? It follows formula, and creates or controls what are essentially mostly natural reactions in the world. The difference is that the stuff works in a D&D setting. So why are we retreading the old, "Science versus Magic" thing, when in fact all of the major centers of learning in Ravenloft were founded by and staffed with mages? How do you represent their scientific knowledge when the skills representing the kind of rigorous knowledge of the natural world any kind of scientist needs have undeniable ties to either arcane or primal magic?

Now, if you had these guys attacking "witchcraft" like warlock pacts, primaly powered characters and the like, that'd be a bit more logical. But as it is, I don't really know how the Lamordians define what is and isn't "real" science. Mordenhiem's beliefs have only been codified as, well, Athar-esque; he did not deny the gods existed because he spent a lot of time yelling at them, but he did deny they were divine.

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 6:09 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
Herman Strauss wrote:Magic (and Faith in this case) are actually disbelieved by the powers of the rational mind.
Sounds like the Logical Mind or Godless feats, which I agree would be very common in the Syndicate, if not prerequisites for advancement.
The more people to solidify the supernatural “grounding” effect, the more severe its effects are on creatures closely related with the Arcane or the Divine. Fey wither and die, ghosts fade into nothingness and magical beasts are weakened until they become mere natural anomalies, caged for scientific experimentation with nothing extraordinary about them.
And that sounds like the Smothering of Reason effect in Lamordia. Could the Syndicate create an accelerated version of it in a localized area?
Godless and Logical Mind (which could use a v3.5 update for those of us using that edition; guess I'd better break out VRArsenal for a review) do emulate the powers of Disbelief quite well for d20 systems. I'd add the feat Apostate (p. 12, 3.5 book Elder Evils) but that's a Vile feat; only evil-aligned characters could take it (and who have also failed a powers check; DM's option).

As for localizing the Smothering of Reason, as I read it that's a side effect of Mordenheim's extreme rationality--and Lamordia is an extension of him and his hubris that led to him being sub-Darklord under Adam. Creating the Smothering outside Lamordia would take generations of intense and endless work to stamp out belief in the supernatural (which likely wouldn't work), some sort of epic-level power (the very possibility of which even I discourage), or entreaties to the Dark Powers that would likely lead to the entreators ending up as darklords themselves. The latter would make for a deliciously ironic outcome; the Enlightened succeed locally, only to realize they can never attain their true goal of utterly obliterating the supernatural elsewhere.

Regardless of how, it begs the question: does this extension of the Smothering work on all supernatural powers or just ones that can't be rationalized by science?

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 9:28 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Godless and Logical Mind (which could use a v3.5 update for those of us using that edition; guess I'd better break out VRArsenal for a review) do emulate the powers of Disbelief quite well for d20 systems. I'd add the feat Apostate (p. 12, 3.5 book Elder Evils) but that's a Vile feat; only evil-aligned characters could take it (and who have also failed a powers check; DM's option).
What's it do? If the benefits are good, this might work as an auto-fail powers check type of situation for the truly initiated.
Creating the Smothering outside Lamordia would take generations of intense and endless work to stamp out belief in the supernatural
Of course, but I'm talking about accelerating it locally, within Lamordia. As it says in Gaz2, the Smothering has been building for years, starting at 1% and now it's 2% domain-wide. Could the Syndicate accelerate this effect to 5% in one small corner of Ludendorf--say, their meeting hall--by virtue of their combined skepticism? If so, the effects could be devastating.
Regardless of how, it begs the question: does this extension of the Smothering work on all supernatural powers or just ones that can't be rationalized by science?
Of course, if it's the latter, then could works such as the Guide to Dopps that work out the biology and whatnot could actually make the creatures immune to it?

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2010 12:37 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
DocBeard wrote:How do you represent their scientific knowledge when the skills representing the kind of rigorous knowledge of the natural world any kind of scientist needs have undeniable ties to either arcane or primal magic?
Simple. They don't have to say that magic doesn't exist, they just have to say that magic shouldn't exist: that it's an offense against the orderly operation of the universe. The very concept that things can happen without any tangible mechanism of cause-and-effect offends these guys.

Plus, they're a bunch of bigots, and don't like sharing the world with nonhumans and supernatural entities.

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2010 5:24 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Godless and Logical Mind (which could use a v3.5 update for those of us using that edition; guess I'd better break out VRArsenal for a review) do emulate the powers of Disbelief quite well for d20 systems. I'd add the feat Apostate (p. 12, 3.5 book Elder Evils) but that's a Vile feat; only evil-aligned characters could take it (and who have also failed a powers check; DM's option).
What's it do? If the benefits are good, this might work as an auto-fail powers check type of situation for the truly initiated.
Apostate adds a profane bonus to saving throws against divine magic and effects equal to half your class level. You also can't voluntarily fail any saving throw against the same, even if it's harmless. Prereq: Wis 15. Also any divine caster with a code of conduct automatically breaks that code; I'd wave that for blackguards and tyrrany/slaughter paladins who serve evil as a cause.

Just taking a Vile feat should be an Act of Ultimate Darkness IMO, though obtaining the taint of the Lower Planes in Ravenloft (or the purity of the Upper Planes for Exalted feats) should be a major undertaking in itself. Contact with true fiends or celestials (not ascended or Mist-subtype ones) or finding rare holes in the fabric of Ravenloft's reality that allow such powers to funnel in are two ideas.
Creating the Smothering outside Lamordia would take generations of intense and endless work to stamp out belief in the supernatural
Of course, but I'm talking about accelerating it locally, within Lamordia. As it says in Gaz2, the Smothering has been building for years, starting at 1% and now it's 2% domain-wide. Could the Syndicate accelerate this effect to 5% in one small corner of Ludendorf--say, their meeting hall--by virtue of their combined skepticism? If so, the effects could be devastating.
Okay, that makes more sense. My bad for misunderstanding.

Yeah, that could easily be achieved by "rituals" that debunk the supernatural: reading from science texts, quoting "inviolate" laws of physics, and simply keeping any supernatural effects away for extended periods of time. Say for every month with no supernatural "taint" the area gains a temporary +1% bonus; maintaining that bonus for a full year makes it permanent. After that they start over to add another 1%. Until an area's bonus is permanent, any supernatural effect activated in or brought into the area would undo the new bonus and require the Enlightened to start over from scratch. Unless it's something they've already rationalized away as "not supernatural."
Regardless of how, it begs the question: does this extension of the Smothering work on all supernatural powers or just ones that can't be rationalized by science?
Of course, if it's the latter, then could works such as the Guide to Dopps that work out the biology and whatnot could actually make the creatures immune to it?
Yes, such a creature would be immune. It's not the actual laws of reality at work so much as the power of belief influencing those laws. Once something is accepted into the belief system it becomes immune to the Smothering. Ironically that creates an incentive to remain ignorant of certain truths, lest they become immunized to the Smothering the Enlightened have worked so hard to foster and fortify.

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2010 7:33 am
by The Giamarga
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Godless and Logical Mind (which could use a v3.5 update for those of us using that edition; guess I'd better break out VRArsenal for a review) do emulate the powers of Disbelief quite well for d20 systems. I'd add the feat Apostate (p. 12, 3.5 book Elder Evils) but that's a Vile feat; only evil-aligned characters could take it (and who have also failed a powers check; DM's option).
What's it do? If the benefits are good, this might work as an auto-fail powers check type of situation for the truly initiated.
Apostate
Wis 15; may not have any cleric, ranger, or paladin levels
Gain one-half level as bonus against divine spells
Elder Evils

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2010 9:50 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Ironically that creates an incentive to remain ignorant of certain truths, lest they become immunized to the Smothering the Enlightened have worked so hard to foster and fortify.
That depends on if the Syndicate truly embraces science as they claim or really only use it as an excuse for bigotry. A true scientist would never want to remain ignorant of anything, even if it would be convenient to do so. If something supposedly supernatural were explained as a scientific truth, a true scientist would accept it and integrate it into his or her worldview. That's the scientific method at its purest, no?

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2010 12:23 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Ironically that creates an incentive to remain ignorant of certain truths, lest they become immunized to the Smothering the Enlightened have worked so hard to foster and fortify.
That depends on if the Syndicate truly embraces science as they claim or really only use it as an excuse for bigotry. A true scientist would never want to remain ignorant of anything, even if it would be convenient to do so. If something supposedly supernatural were explained as a scientific truth, a true scientist would accept it and integrate it into his or her worldview. That's the scientific method at its purest, no?
Who said these guys were true scientists? Even some scientists aren't true scientists when it comes to dealing with evidence that clashes with their own pet theories. "Always trust the evidence, not your own theories" and all that.

The Enlightened are more like politicians who jump on an issue without knowing all--or even any--of the facts just to improve their approval ratings. They're just giving folks easy answers and, sadly, that's what a lot of sheeple (from "people are sheep") want. It gets rid of bothersome things like thinking for themselves. If their methods happen to benefit their own prejudices, so much the better.

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2010 12:44 pm
by Brandi
You not only used the word "sheeple" with a straight face but felt the need to define it for us?

I think you're dead to me now.