Page 1 of 2
What are natural spellcasters?
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 4:55 am
by cure
Gaz V, p 50 gives us Fairy Stools that are basically very slow Detect Magic spells. One of things that they detect are "natural spellcasters such as sorcercers". My question is what else is a natural spellcaster as I can't seem to find a defintion of it. Initially I thought that would be spellcasters that spontaneous spellcasters like bards would also be an example. But I am being to suspect that is wrong.
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 6:28 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
From what I can remember from t3e, natural spellcasters are innate spellcasters, those who have latent magic within them; or, more clearly, those who didn't need to learn magic to possess magic. Sorcerers are the most obvious specimen, but I think druids were natural as well.
I don't think "innate spellcasters" are options in 4th ed. Your powers are just that, powers.
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 8:55 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
I don't think "natural spellcasters" was ever actually defined as a game-mechanic, just used in flavor text. In the flavor sense, 3E-era gnomes would be another example of a natural spellcaster, as would other beings with an inherent ability to cast spells (e.g. a solar or lillend) rather than just use spell-like abilities.
Ironically, I don't think druids would be considered "natural spellcasters" in that sense. Their abilities generally require training to achieve.
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 9:38 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
I agree that druids would not qualify, but Redheads would. Hags, half-fey, and some with feytouched feats would also qualify, which is probalby another reason why they justify it.
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 3:11 pm
by ewancummins
I get that 'fairy stools' are mushrooms, but I keep thinking of excrement. As a medic, this just comes straight to my mind when you say 'stools.' Pixie poop?
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 3:15 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
ewancummins wrote:I get that 'fairy stools' are mushrooms, but I keep thinking of excrement. As a medic, this just comes straight to my mind when you say 'stools.' Pixie poop?
you're not the only one. My wife was totally grossed out when I used these in our game.
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 4:09 pm
by Mangrum
The intention was to include anyone who could use spells through some sort of natural talent or innate trait rather than training. This would include A) creatures with spell-like abilities, B) creatures who gain spellcaster levels from their race, and C) the sorcerer (as well as any similarly themed classes that might be out there, none of which come to mind at the moment).
Posted: Mon Feb 22, 2010 4:28 pm
by cure
Mangrum wrote:The intention was to include anyone who could use spells through some sort of natural talent or innate trait rather than training. This would include A) creatures with spell-like abilities, B) creatures who gain spellcaster levels from their race, and C) the sorcerer (as well as any similarly themed classes that might be out there, none of which come to mind at the moment).
A) is clear in the orginial text (which I didn't site).
B) is a very good precision to have.
C) is a good precision also.
As to B) these would be the ones, without straying to far from Ravenloft, that I could kind:
DoD
Shadow Fey (most and perhaps all)
Hebi-no-onna
Ravenkin
Undead Treants
MM
Aranea
Couatl
Naga
Lammasu
Nymph
Rahshasa
Androsphinx
Formian Queen
Dragons
Outsiders
Angels
Ghaele
Trumpet Archon
Additionally, I wonder about Hags as modifiered in Ravenloft, who would be in much the same boat as dragons. And I also wonder about liches as spellcasting is inherient to their very nature.
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 4:01 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Would psionicist classes--well at least the wilder, since they don't gain their powers from formal training--count?
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 6:10 pm
by ewancummins
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Would psionicist classes--well at least the wilder, since they don't gain their powers from formal training--count?
No, if you ask me. Psionics isn't magic.
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 6:50 pm
by Mangrum
ewancummins wrote:No, if you ask me. Psionics isn't magic.
That's a point of personal taste, however. Personally, I recommend the "psionics is magic" approach, since it's the only (non-incredibly labor intensive way) of fully integrating a snap-on ruleset. Otherwise you get characters (let's face it, PCs) whose power level gets blown completely out of proportion simply because psionics are typically rare and no one -- even your high-level baddie -- is prepared for them.
In a setting (like Dark Sun) where psionics are fully integrated from the ground up, on the other hand, your choice might well be the best one.
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:28 pm
by ewancummins
Mangrum wrote:ewancummins wrote:No, if you ask me. Psionics isn't magic.
That's a point of personal taste, however. Personally, I recommend the "psionics is magic" approach, since it's the only (non-incredibly labor intensive way) of fully integrating a snap-on ruleset. Otherwise you get characters (let's face it, PCs) whose power level gets blown completely out of proportion simply because psionics are typically rare and no one -- even your high-level baddie -- is prepared for them.
In a setting (like Dark Sun) where psionics are fully integrated from the ground up, on the other hand, your choice might well be the best one.
I have never used 3E psionics, but if I did, I'd run it like I do with AD&D 2E. That is, if a PC has psionics, I will include
at least a few psionic monsters and villains in the campaign. I didn't find it labor-intensive or difficult to balance. Cerebreal parasites can work wonders.

Evil psionicists make good villains, too.
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:49 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
ewancummins wrote:Mangrum wrote:ewancummins wrote:No, if you ask me. Psionics isn't magic.
That's a point of personal taste, however. Personally, I recommend the "psionics is magic" approach, since it's the only (non-incredibly labor intensive way) of fully integrating a snap-on ruleset. Otherwise you get characters (let's face it, PCs) whose power level gets blown completely out of proportion simply because psionics are typically rare and no one -- even your high-level baddie -- is prepared for them.
In a setting (like Dark Sun) where psionics are fully integrated from the ground up, on the other hand, your choice might well be the best one.
I have never used 3E psionics, but if I did, I'd run it like I do with AD&D 2E. That is, if a PC has psionics, I will include
at least a few psionic monsters and villains in the campaign. I didn't find it labor-intensive or difficult to balance. Cerebreal parasites can work wonders.

Evil psionicists make good villains, too.
Labor intensive? I never really found differentiating psionics from magic as being very difficult. 2e psionics were what really killed me, though. "You need X power to learn this, roll "attribute - Y" for Power Score, beware of a natural 20." I found that a pain. Eh. To each his own.
Let's just forget the psionics argument for now. What about warlocks? Are they "innate spellcasters," even though they don't actually cast spells but still use magical abilities that don't stem from training? If we're going to be hypothetical than let's forget frequency of a class/monster/whatever in the canon Ravenloft setting. Some of us do include things that wouldn't fit the default RL as written.
Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 4:27 am
by Mangrum
OK, look, here's the thing. The days of Ask Azalin are long gone. I provided the intended meaning: characters and creatures that use spells through inborn ability rather than training. I think that's a reasonably clear concept. If that does not suffice, apply one part common sense and two parts imagination, then come up with answers yourself.
Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 4:33 am
by Mangrum
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Labor intensive? I never really found differentiating psionics from magic as being very difficult.
Well, except that if "psionics are different" and you're playing in a setting where psionics aren't fully integrated, then basically what you have is a spellcaster against whom all the standard and commonplace magical tactics and defenses (ranging from
detect magic to
anti-magic shell) suddenly don't apply. it's an X-factor that most published scenarios don't take into account, much in the same way your typical low-level dungeon can get completely thrown out of whack by, say, a PC who can fly.