Page 1 of 3
Population and Size Variants
Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 10:02 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
I'm looking at a variations on domain population and size, as part of a project I'd like to incorporate into the Mistipedia. Specifically, I'd like to see if we can organize people's preferences into a few general types, and have those types listed in the domain descriptions.
How much do you multiply the scale and populations by? Based on prior conversations, I see three possible scales: Traditional DoD, Expanded (DoD x10), and Continental (DoD x50). Does one of these suit your preferences? If not, would you find them useful as benchmarks?
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Sat Mar 06, 2010 12:08 am
by ewancummins
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:I'm looking at a variations on domain population and size, as part of a project I'd like to incorporate into the Mistipedia. Specifically, I'd like to see if we can organize people's preferences into a few general types, and have those types listed in the domain descriptions.
How much do you multiply the scale and populations by? Based on prior conversations, I see three possible scales: Traditional DoD, Expanded (DoD x10), and Continental (DoD x50). Does one of these suit your preferences? If not, would you find them useful as benchmarks?
I use 'Expanded Scale' for the maps of the Core, but I don't make the Shadow Rift so big. I increase populations- but I do not alwyas grow the listed cities and towns. Most people live in small, rural communities or in farmhouses and cabins. You need a lot of people out in the countryside farming to support the towns and cities of
canon-loft. There are also itinerants, not listed in ''official'' estimates of population: gypsies, tinkers, peddlars, horse-traders, migrant workers,etc.
Posted: Sat Mar 06, 2010 3:16 pm
by DocBeard
Generally I'm a bit vaguer than this; if I'm using the specific region directly in the game, I set it up according to the particular campaign's needs. If not, I make a rough draft of each physical region's traits-if it has a city, is it a "big" city or a "small" city? If not, is it populated at all? Is there a rule of law, and if not, who or what is trying to fill the vacuum? How do the people make their living? Is there any element in the area that has yet to be found and exploited by people?
Blah blah blah. I've found that worrying about specific demographics beyond vague categories tends to gum things up in the long run, as that's just the sort of thing PCs notice and call you on in an attempt to work out some kind of advantage.
I think, being modern people, we sometimes underestimate what population dynamics in that era were, what with medicine and sanitation being what they were. Sure you had massive cities pop up once in a while, but for a lot of folks a thousand people living in one place really was huge. Then again, fantasy peoples have access to resources the human race did not...not necessarily "continual light spells as lamps" like that, but even a low magic era cleric would be able to keep a cleaner supply of water and equipment than he or she would without access to the arcane, and little things like that are lifesavers. Of course, we didn't have rat people creating magical plagues in their grim sewer temples either, so maybe it balances out...
Posted: Sat Mar 06, 2010 3:19 pm
by alhoon
For me what worked best was area x4, population roughly x4 (not the same multiplier in all domains) but as many said, I didn't increase the size of cities too much.
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:55 am
by Intrepid
I think what might work best for a wiki entry is a page about converting population sizes. This would be a fairly easy thing to do, allow people who want it to use it, and those who don't to not.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 2:13 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Digging this up to see if we can form it into an actual project for Mistipedia. Please answer the OP, if you have not done so already.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 2:40 pm
by HuManBing
Good bump, Deepshadow - this is a common enough topic that it's good to get a more inclusive sample of opinions. A wiki entry for guidance would definitely be useful too!
Personally, I multiply most distances and pop levels by 10, although this is more of a guideline than any rule. As others have said, cities in a pre-industrial society would likely have a hard upper limit based on sanitation and food source, so I wouldn't increase those quite as much. Il Aluk might reasonably max out at 250K residents without too much suspension of disbelief.
I'm much more likely to add in extra towns and cities in the blank spaces on the map, especially after increasing the open spaces in between through a scale multiplier. The border between Darkon and Falkovnia, for example, would have several border settlements to support a heightened military presence. Post-upheaval Invidia and the occupied Gundarak territories would have similar garrison towns.
Some domains would rely heavily on magical communication means for internal civic cohesion. Other larger domains without much magic like Falkovnia or Nova Vaasa might assert their internal line of command through a tightly regimented horse-based postal and messenger system. Falkovnia as the hub of a burgeoning messenger bird network also appeals to me.
Finally, my maps assume innumerable tiny farming settlements dotted around the blank spaces. Although the Gothic setting makes the wilderness somewhat scarier, in history it was still a pretty hostile place, but the freedom and profits of small-scale farming is still significant enough that most of the populace does still live in rural areas. (Data suggest that the Earth's population only became majority urban in the year 2005, for an anthropological context...)
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 4:17 pm
by Jack of Tears
I tend to run the Core as about half the size of the US. I have played with size over the years many times, however, and even shrank it down once so all of Ravenloft was one city the size of London.
The size variants you suggest seem reasonable - I'm assuming you're going to offer advice on how the domain is changed if the size is increased? (or decreased)
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 4:40 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I often wonder if I'm the only canon-loft player left, but I found the scale and population to need very little tweaking and would change neither by more than double. A lot of this preference come from my macro mapping projects where larger areas just introduce problems (such as in Minecraft) but I have story reasons as well. I never saw the need for large body counts or overwhelming hordes of supernatural creatures. Feeling like part of the community is important for my players. I could have the werewolf take down everyone in the square in a big city and my players will shrug. But If he kills just one townsperson, and it is the smith who was making them a special item, well then that means something.
I've heard all the arguments for expanding the distances and respect the different styles of games. I even understand some of the warts caused by small populations and how they may seem like game breakers. Honestly, I think I can live with them.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 5:29 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I like a Core reminiscent of 17th century Europe in terms of scale, so I'm a 50x man.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:13 am
by alhoon
To help people populate their domains:
Here are some historical examples from Wikipedia, about population density.
In most cases, I took the population estimates and I divided by what I considered to be the area. So, take those with a grain of salt.
Pop density (people/sq km):
Sicily 5th Century BC (CL 4): ~30-35 (Heavily urbanized for the period, about 50% of population living in large towns and cities)
Roman Italy 3rd Century BC (CL 4): ~15 (For the whole Roman Empire, the average was less than 10)
Europe 7th-9th century (CL5):~3.5-6 (With the Carolignian Empire having pop density 11-12 at 814). More a points of light thing, with large lawless wilderness between settlements.
England 1086 (CL7): 7-8
England 14th century (CL8): 35-45
France 14th century pro-plague (CL8):35-40
England in 1541AD(CL8): ~20
England in 1600AD (CL9): ~30
What this tells us?
That a somewhat stable non-overly urbanized areas before the population boom of the high middle ages, would have a population density of up to 7-15 people/Sq km.
A troubled area, like Europe was in the middle ages or Darkon after Requiem, that is more or less settlements seperated by lawless wilderness would have a population density of 3-5 people/sq km.
A more-or-less stable late medieval (Like France in 1328AD or say, Borca) or Renaissance (like England in 1600AD or Mordent) would have a reasonable population density of up to 35-40.
A troubled area like Europe was in the late Middle ages (Black plague + 100 years war) would have a population density like 10-20 people/square km.
Using 1"= 25 miles (40 km) the Core ends up like 65000-70000 sq km. Using 1"=100 miles the core ends up 16 times bigger, over 1million sq km in size.
Example: Barovia is CL7 but somewhat backwards, heavily forested and mountainous without being heavily farmed. No serious wars but monsters. So I would assume a pop density of 5 people sq km.
Using the core scale (1"=25 miles => 1cm = 16 km) is about 5000-6000 sq km. If you double the scale to 1"=50 miles then Barovia is about 20-25000 sq km and would have something like 100000 - 125000 people. Doubling the population of the major settlements would seem reasonable, since then just 1/4 people would live in settlements of over 3000 people instead half of them.
If you quadraple the scale to 1" = 100 miles, then Barovia would be about 80-100000 sq km (like
Wallachia and would have something like 400-500K people. x3 to the settlements as presented would lead to 1/10 people living in small or larger cities (yes, you have to pump Vallaki and Immol a bit further to reach the 5K mark).
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Tue Jan 10, 2012 7:21 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Not sure this counts as an option, but:
I just don't sweat it.
My Ravenloft is as big as it needs to be at any given time. Travel times are at the speed of the plot. The players have never even asked about populations. "Big City" "small town" "tiny hamlet" have been good enough descriptors.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:27 am
by ewancummins
I ended up using something not too much smaller than the Thirteen Colonies in the mid-18th century, in both area and population.
It allows for large wilderness areas, plenty of cultivated land, multiple cities, many small towns and hamlets, natural-seeming climate and terrain variation, and so on.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 5:10 pm
by alhoon
ewancummins wrote:I ended up using something not too much smaller than the Thirteen Colonies in the mid-18th century, in both area and population.
It allows for large wilderness areas, plenty of cultivated land, multiple cities, many small towns and hamlets, natural-seeming climate and terrain variation, and so on.
Well... that's not much bigger than actual Ravenloft. I would say same population, about double the area or something. Of course, I could be wrong.
Re: Population and Size Variants
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 7:05 am
by Strahdsbuddy
I'd say yo may be wrong, Mr Alhoon. The Core is about the size of Switzerland without its seas, according to canon. The entire East Coast of the US seems like a large area for gaming without advanced transit. I'm reminded of Middle Earth which is roughly the size of western & central Europe....it took them forever to get anywhere!
Something to remember when looking at the "small" canon version of the Core is that it may look like you can ride across Mordent in a day, but that's as the crow flies, not as the winding road or pathless bogs take you. Driven properly, it can take any amount of time the DM wants to get somewhere without stretching things to much.