Page 1 of 1
Anchorite Alignment Change
Posted: Sun Mar 07, 2010 2:57 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
I'm looking to create an anchorite who started out in the Mordentish sect but had a slow, voluntary alignment change to LE. If his shield changed from LG to LN to LE over time, how would this be received by the community? Would they expect him to follow Raines' doctrine?
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 10:36 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
How often does your average anchorite active his/her shield. Is it only used when in danger (and to prove a new sect) or is it part of the religious rites? It's possible one would never know that ones own shield had changed for many years, much less know about someone else's.
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 11:39 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Me, I'd be inclined to leave the Shield unchanged, regardless of how the character's alignment has shifted. Alignment isn't supposed to be easy to discern in Ravenloft, and making the Shield a giveaway for a cleric's inner alignment could derail potential storylines about clergy who turn against the sect they'd initially followed. There's more plot potential in, say, one of Raines' recruits turning LG, but remaining in the sect to covertly keep the Zealots' fanaticism in check, than in such a cleric getting hounded out of Nevuchar Springs the first time they invoke a Shield.
Yes, there should be a way for an anchorite's Shield to change, but only if they officially leave one sect and join another. Some kind of formal ceremony of leavetaking from the old sect, and acceptance into the new one, would most likely be involved.
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 1:02 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
Even though I understand and, to certain extent, share the view of how the different outlooks of each of the Chruch of Ezra's branches affect the manifestation of the Shield, I think in game terms this is a leftover from the 2nd Edition days. If I were running a RL campaign, I think I would be inclined to let the player choose which variation of the shield he would like his character to manifest, regardless of alignment, or even have the ability replaced by a single kind of shield.
But, revisionist delusions aside, I agree with both Rotipher and Gonzoron, and think that the character's change in attitude shouldn't be evidenced through which kind of shield he manifests, but rather through actions.
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 1:43 pm
by DocBeard
Couldn't you just say the type of shield marks their personal views? Like, someone manifesting the LE Ezran shield would just be viewed as someone going to the extremist camp, rather than someone who's gone evil.
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 1:53 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I would go with Roti's view, myself: when one becomes an anchorite one makes certain vows, which differ somewhat from sect to sect. As long as one is sworn to the vows of a particular sect one continues to manifest the shield of that sect, regardless of whether one's views have more in common (in alignment terms, at least) with some other sect.
Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 8:23 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
DocBeard wrote:Couldn't you just say the type of shield marks their personal views? Like, someone manifesting the LE Ezran shield would just be viewed as someone going to the extremist camp, rather than someone who's gone evil.
Well of course it could be a reflection of personal views, the problem is how those personal views fit the Grand Scheme. In this case, the issue is that there are many ways to be LE within the Ezran clergy. Raines found one of them, this anchorite has found another.
Okay, time for specifics: this anchorite has taken the viewpoint that power is a sign of divine favor. Unlike the Lawgiver clergy, it's not political power that he favors, but monetary: he's a ruthless capitalist. To be poor is a sign of moral weakness, to be rich is proof of Ezra's grace.
Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 8:41 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Okay, time for specifics: this anchorite has taken the viewpoint that power is a sign of divine favor. Unlike the Lawgiver clergy, it's not political power that he favors, but monetary: he's a ruthless capitalist. To be poor is a sign of moral weakness, to be rich is proof of Ezra's grace.
Just to clarify--for purposes of your campaign it's what's in the heart, not one's declared allegiance to a sect, that determines the manifestation of the Shield an anchorite receives?