Page 1 of 2

"saving" the Rakshasa

Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2010 7:29 am
by alhoon
I checked them recently in 3.5. I haven't used them I think since 2nd edition (that is since 3rd came out 11 or so years ago).

I have to say I was disappointed.

1. First thing first, the Raksasha are native outsiders. :?

2. Also, they're not CR 10.

A 10th lvl D&D fighter boosted a bit by a cleric propably has 22 str, +2 weapon, +3 morale bonus to hit/drolls +1 attack when making a full attack from righteous wrath of the faithful, weapon specialization etc. Protection from evil BTW stops charms etc.
So, he has something like he has hr+20/20/15 and deals 2d6+20 with power attack 2.
Now, the Rakshasa have DR 15, and with spells, propably about AC 30. They are also next to immune to magic from these levels. On the other hand, the cleric could nicely flank the Rakshasa and give the fighter a nice +2 bonus, so he can hit, and he may strike a lucky blow.
On the other hand, while the Rakshasa would delay them, it won't be able to harm them seriously with its low-level spells and illusions or it's weapons. Also, it doesn't have the ability to teleport away.

So, once a Rakshasa's presence is discovered and the heroes confront it, it's as good as dead, without a good fight.

However:
Rakshasa (albeit weak in combat as they should be) they're very interesting antagonists. Not geniouses but smart, difficult to spot and with an array of illusions and enchantment effects.
Sure, their combat prowess isn't that of a CR 10 monster, but they're nice.

Suggestion:
Reducing it's DR to 10 instead of 15, it's SR to 25 instead of 27, giving it a bit different array of feats and reducing CR to 8 you have a nice bad guy for 6th-7th level characters.

Changes for Ravenloft:
Native outsider gives me a nice idea (kinda into theme with Ravenloft actually)

Van Richten in GtFiend suggested that perhaps outsiders are the final step of evolution for evil spellcasters. What if he was right?
What if there was an evil tome that held the rituals necessary to turn a powerful evil sorcerer to an immortal paragon of evil?

Being native outsiders, Rakshasa have no reality wrinkle BTW.

Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2010 7:33 am
by The Giamarga
Sasha who?

Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2010 12:56 pm
by Sareau
Rakshasa really depend on the GM more than other monsters. Granted, the old rakshasa with their immunity to spells below 9th level were terrors, but the new ones are still very adequate threats-i can challenge a 10th level group with one

Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2010 4:04 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
We already have an evil wizard who's turning into a rakshasa in the in-game Fraternity of Shadows, albeit by transpossession rather than just because he's a evil wizard.

Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2010 11:49 pm
by alhoon
Sareau wrote:Rakshasa really depend on the GM more than other monsters. Granted, the old rakshasa with their immunity to spells below 9th level were terrors, but the new ones are still very adequate threats-i can challenge a 10th level group with one

Remember, CR is about a fight, not how you could turn an encounter of a low threat enemy to something challenging!

I could challenge a 15th level party with a Rakshasa. That doesn't make them CR 10.

Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 12:19 am
by The Lesser Evil
Well, CRS were always a pretty subjective thing in 3.X. Remember that hypothetically are only supposed to take up "20%" of a party's resources, so a CR 10 creature for a CR 10 party really isn't all that challenging. Also, all that boosting would take time, such that good use of a Rakshasa should strike by surprise and should negate the opportunity to use a lot of those spells. Other spells slots (true seeing, etc) might already be in used determining its true nature.

That being said, you might want to look at the Pathfinder Bestiary for a version that better approaches a CR 10 approximation.

Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 12:24 am
by alhoon
Nah, pathfinder doesn't suit my tastes.

Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 7:57 am
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Nah, pathfinder doesn't suit my tastes.
That maybe so but the game is about 80% backwards compatible and could be used for ideas and numbers to "save" the Rakshasa.

Let's take a look.

Looks like the big change is more hitpoints (in line with their changes to Hit Dice) and a couple offensive spells.

Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 10:19 am
by alhoon
Yeah, with 115hp it is indeed CR 10.

The big change IMO is the turn towards melee prowess. Improved critical, magical melee weapon etc.

I prefer Rakshasa as fairly weak combatants though and powerful liars; the types that infiltrate courts and start wars. Also they should be more specialized towards enchantment and illusions.

When I use a Rakshasa, I'll propably make them from scratch according to the needs of the Campaign.

Prefered spell list for 7th lvl sorcerer:
3rd: Lighting bolt, major image
2nd: mirror image, suggestion, invisibility
1st: charm person, mage armor, magic missile, spell-that-gives-+5-to-social-rolls, silent image.

PS. I prefer suggestion as a 2nd lvl spell, especialy for the Rakshasa.

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 10:08 am
by Sareau
Given that the rakshasa in Indian myth is sort of like the troll of Norse myth, a standard encounter for the questing hero, I don't mind them being formidable combatants. However, if you use the Eberron rakshasa warriors as well as the Monster Manual clever beasts as separate castes, you can have your cake and eat it too...

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 10:38 pm
by Zettaijin
When I first saw this thread, I went "Man, I didn't know they were going extinct! Where do I send my money?"

Posted: Sat Apr 17, 2010 4:15 am
by alhoon
Sareau wrote:Given that the rakshasa in Indian myth is sort of like the troll of Norse myth, a standard encounter for the questing hero, I don't mind them being formidable combatants. However, if you use the Eberron rakshasa warriors as well as the Monster Manual clever beasts as separate castes, you can have your cake and eat it too...
And of course, we have Sareau's solution.
As you know Rakshasa are outsiders, so it's logic to have more than 2 castes. Thanks.

Going with Rakshasa being tiger-colored I think I'll use:
A kind of yellow-blackish rakshasa as inflitrators, and war mongers mostly, a kind of orange-blackish as warriors and a low caste, ochre colored (puma not tiger) as servants.
The Rakshasa leaders of shorts would be Siberian Tiger like.

Posted: Sat Apr 17, 2010 8:38 am
by Lovecraftforever
Zettaijin wrote:When I first saw this thread, I went "Man, I didn't know they were going extinct! Where do I send my money?"
For only five copper pieces a day, less than the cost of a flagon of ale, you can help save these majestic evil creatures.

Posted: Sat Apr 17, 2010 9:11 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Lovecraftforever wrote:For only five copper pieces a day, less than the cost of a flagon of ale, you can help save these majestic evil creatures.
:lol:

New members: awesome.

New members with a great sense of humor: super-awesome.

<Runs>

Posted: Sat Apr 17, 2010 9:12 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Lovecraftforever wrote:For only five copper pieces a day, less than the cost of a flagon of ale, you can help save these majestic evil creatures.
:lol:

New members: awesome.

New members with a great sense of humor: super-awesome.

[Runs out to adopt a Rakshasa from the local shelter]