Page 1 of 2
4E - Brutal weapons
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 9:59 am
by alhoon
OK... I disagree with the way this rule is implemented. A strange, weird, tiresome system, more worthy of 2nd edition than 4th.
For those that don't know: Brutal weapon X means you reroll everything equal to or below X i.e. the minimum damage is at least X+1 .
For example a weapon that deals 1d12, brutal 2 means:
on a result of 1, you reroll
on a result of 2, you reroll
on a result of 3-12, you keep the damage.
Question:
Why on earth they ask us to reroll, instead of doing the simple thing of 1d10+2 that produces exactly the same result?
I.e. instead of 1d12, reroll 1s and 2s, it could be 1d10+2. Same result, same chances for everything, less fuss and rolls.
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 10:28 am
by Scipion_Emilien
For the kick of it I calculated (and well searched the net) for the expected value of both, and it's true you come to the same one.
If you want to see the maths: (not me that did the site thought)
http://www.rhetoricalsegfault.org/wordp ... age-in-dd/
My theory is that WoTC want to entertain you with a wild dice.
N.B I only calculated brutal 2 1d12 vs 1d10 + 2, I'll look at the other one to see if it fit If I have time.
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 10:44 am
by alhoon
No worries. I have done the math ages ago, for 2nd edition. It's not a question if it's equal or not.
It's a question why they added more dice.
As a note: Brutal 1 weapons aren't easy to reproduce. For example Kukri (1d6,Brutal 1) equals 1d5 +1.
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:11 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Sounds like an experiment to me. Or like they wanted yet another way for weapons to be given more punch via magic, that would fully stack with conventional damage bonuses and existing dice-upgrades for things like wielders' size. But I'm just extrapolating from 3E here, not having gone the 4E route.
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:23 am
by Mortavius
Like Rotipher said, with having two different systems, they can stack.
For example, a Brutal 1 weapon and a +1 weapon get the same result.
But you can have a Brutal +1 weapon now. Sure, that's the same as a +2 weapon, but we're talking about low weapons. What about when you get to +3 or higher?
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:51 am
by Intrepid
Honestly, it is part of the whole 4E thing. They love giving the players and DM's re-rolls for some reason. Maybe one of their playtests had a person who was like "I LOVE REROLLING AND SO DOES EVERY OTHER GAMER!!!"
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 12:34 pm
by alhoon
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Sounds like an experiment to me. Or like they wanted yet another way for weapons to be given more punch via magic, that would fully stack with conventional damage bonuses and existing dice-upgrades for things like wielders' size. But I'm just extrapolating from 3E here, not having gone the 4E route.
And why would a weapon that does 1d10+2 / dice normally
NOT stack with a +2 enchantment?
the W damage would be 1d10+2. So with your encounter power you would do 2W = 2d10+4
Then you add magic, strength etc etc.
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 3:57 pm
by Scipion_Emilien
Intrepid wrote:Honestly, it is part of the whole 4E thing. They love giving the players and DM's re-rolls for some reason. Maybe one of their playtests had a person who was like "I LOVE REROLLING AND SO DOES EVERY OTHER GAMER!!!"
I'm pretty sure that's the main idea. WoTC seem to want to give the feel to the players that they are involved and that there character is doing something, and I guess that one way to do that is to give players rerolls. So they hoped that the player have a feeling of doing more even if statistically there is no differences.
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 8:44 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Similar logic perhaps to making all the Ref/Fort/Will saves into attack rolls against a fixed number? Attackers like to be "in control" by rolling the dice. More dice=more fun for some.
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 3:23 pm
by ewancummins
Are
non-brutal weapons Nerf-style?

Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 4:07 pm
by NeoTiamat
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Similar logic perhaps to making all the Ref/Fort/Will saves into attack rolls against a fixed number? Attackers like to be "in control" by rolling the dice. More dice=more fun for some.
I figured that to be more about not having to break the flow of the combat action in order to have someone else roll. So now it's just "I roll and that's it." and not "I cast a spell and now I have to wait for the other people to roll their saves against it to see if it works."
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 4:17 pm
by DocBeard
From a mathematical standpoint, its like this.
My weapon's +2. I roll a 1 on a d8. I do 3 damage.
My weapon's brutal 2. I roll a 1 on a d8. I reroll, doing anywhere from 3-8 points of damage.
So instead of adding a significant modifier to a bad roll, I get a chance to try to get a good roll. I cannot say if one method is "better" than the other, but they're clearly different enough to be separate mechanics. Its just a bell and whistle, like most magic item effects. Why is that a problem?
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 5:57 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
DocBeard wrote:From a mathematical standpoint, its like this.
My weapon's +2. I roll a 1 on a d8. I do 3 damage.
My weapon's brutal 2. I roll a 1 on a d8. I reroll, doing anywhere from 3-8 points of damage.
It's not that 1d8+2 is the same as 1d8 (brutal 2), it's that 1d6+2 is the same as 1d8 (brutal 2). Exactly the same, except faster to roll.
1d6+2 has a 1/6 chance of producing each number from 3-8.
1d8 (brutal 2) has a 1/6 chance of producing each number from 3-8.
Actually, it's more accurate to say that they are the same IF the brutal weapon eventually rolls a result. There is a vanishingly small, but non-zero chance that the player with the brutal weapon will keep rolling 1 or 2 until they get bored, stop rolling, quit the game, and go play WoW.
Why is that a problem?
The only "problem" is that 4e combat was supposed to be
faster than 3e, not slower...
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 7:01 pm
by Jester of the FoS
I think you're mostly on the wrong track. Brutal is a nice mathematical boost to average damage without increasing the damage die which impacts criticals.
And it does work out the same as dropping the die and adding a plus.
Two factors.
1) Weapon powers. Like powers that say 2[w]+str. If you add a plus on the weapon is that 2[d10]+2+str or 2[d10]+4+str. It adds a whole extra level of complexity and possible mistakes and math.
2) Fun. Rolling again is fun and getting to re-roll damage is exciting. It's just a little more interesting than a static bonus.
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 10:01 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:I think you're mostly on the wrong track. Brutal is a nice mathematical boost to average damage without increasing the damage die which impacts criticals.
And it does work out the same as dropping the die and adding a plus.
Two factors.
1) Weapon powers. Like powers that say 2[w]+str. If you add a plus on the weapon is that 2[d10]+2+str or 2[d10]+4+str. It adds a whole extra level of complexity and possible mistakes and math.
2) Fun. Rolling again is fun and getting to re-roll damage is exciting. It's just a little more interesting than a static bonus.
1. Just put in the description that the [W] in that case is [1d10+2] instead of [1d12, rerolling 1-2]. And a note in that paragraph that magic weapons
don't get multiplied. Sure a bit more complex, but faster.
2. Rolling again is
unfun for me and breaks the pace of action.
Another reason I
can think for the Brutal 2 weapons is...
Feats and powers.
I believe there are or there will be a smatering of feats and powers like this:
"blah blah blaj
Damage: 2[W]+strength modifier and the enemy suffers from blah blah blah.
special: If you use a brutal weapon, the brutal factor increases by 2, for example a brutal 2 weapon would faction as brutal 4"
Now, that's easier to put there instead of "your 1d10+2 weapon actually becomes 1d8+4".
And of course, more unfun. By far. Consider such a power on the
kukri. 1d6, brutal 2 => 1d6 brutal
4. And say it's 2[w]...

You have to roll 3d6 and keep rolling everything that's not 5 or 6.