Page 1 of 1

How do tumble, jump and movement interact?

Posted: Sat Jun 05, 2010 3:05 pm
by cure
I am confused as to how the rules for movement, tumbling and jumping combine. In particular, given a human with Str 10 and hence a 30ft speed with no skill modifier, I want to determine in tactical movement the DC for a 10 ft jump at the end of a double move action half-speed tumble and the DC for a 10 ft jump at the end of a move action full speed tumble. Equally, I want to determine in local movement the DCs for 10 ft jumps made at a running pace, at a hustling pace, and at a walking pace. And for completeness, the DC of a jump proceeded by 4 x 5ft at a tumbling crawl. My suspicion is the DC is in fact the same in every case, but I would very much like to be proven wrong.

The relevant SRD info on jumping is this: "Your Jump check is modified by your speed. If your speed is 30 feet then no modifier based on speed applies to the check. If your speed is less than 30 feet, you take a -6 penalty for every 10 feet of speed less than 30 feet. If your speed is greater than 30 feet, you gain a +4 bonus for every 10 feet beyond 30 feet. All Jump DCs given here assume that you get a running start, which requires that you move at least 20 feet in a straight line before attempting the jump. If you do not get a running start, the DC for the jump is doubled" and " Effects that increase your movement also increase your jumping distance, since your check is modified by your speed. If you have the Run feat, you get a +4 bonus on Jump checks for any jumps made after a running start. "

The relevant SRD info on tumbling is this: "Tumble at one-half speed as part of normal movement." and " You try to tumble past or through enemies more quickly than normal. By accepting a -10 penalty on your Tumble checks, you can move at your full speed instead of one-half your speed."

The relevent info on movement is scattered through the SRD, mainly in the section Carrying, Movement, & Exploration but also under Run in Combat.

Thanx for your assistance.

Re: How do tumble, jump and movement interact?

Posted: Sat Jun 05, 2010 5:09 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
First off, my ruling would be that if you're trying something that requires a skill check, like jumping, you are effectively in "combat". Hence, I would just ignore the local movement aspect. If you're jumping, it's tactical movement. Granted, the RAW doesn't say this explicitly, that's just my opinion.

Next, I think these two are pretty straightforward. (I'm assuming you mean long jump, not high jump, right?)
cure wrote:I am confused as to how the rules for movement, tumbling and jumping combine. In particular, given a human with Str 10 and hence a 30ft speed with no skill modifier, I want to determine in tactical movement the DC for a 10 ft jump at the end of a double move action half-speed tumble
speed is 30, so half-speed is 15, which is 15 feet less than 30. I believe that means a -6 penalty. (Yes, reading the rules literally, there is no penalty or bonus from speed 21 to speed 39!) You move 30 feet this round, the last 10 are the jump, so you have the required 20ft head start. Ergo, DC16.
and the DC for a 10 ft jump at the end of a move action full speed tumble.


speed is 30, no penalty. again, you move 30 feet total, 10 of which is the jump, so you have a 20ft running start. DC is only 10. (But you have to make the tumble check with the -10 penalty to move full speed, accepting the AoO's for failure.)
And for completeness, the DC of a jump proceeded by 4 x 5ft at a tumbling crawl.
Tumbling crawl? I don't see the rules for that in the SRD, and I don't recall hearing of it.

Posted: Sat Jun 05, 2010 9:13 pm
by Jester of the FoS
The SRD speed modifier applies to base speed. You don't get a bonus if you double move (aka 60 feet that round) but you do if you're a monk or barbarian with fast movement.
So that part is irrelevant for this discussion.

They need to move at least 20 feet or the DC is doubled. That's pretty straight; it's not using 20' worth of movement (which they would do in a single square if tumbling through difficult terrain).
Since they're tumbling they're moving at half speed, so they're using 40 feet of their movement ( 40/2 = 20). Followed by the 10 foot jump (standard DC 10). So they'd have used 50 feet of their maximum 60 feet of movement.
I want to determine in local movement the DCs for 10 ft jumps made at a running pace, at a hustling pace, and at a walking pace. And for completeness, the DC of a jump proceeded by 4 x 5ft at a tumbling crawl. My suspicion is the DC is in fact the same in every case, but I would very much like to be proven wrong.
Nope. You are right, they are all the same.
D&D 3e is closer to reality than most editions, but there are still some limits and flaws. To make entirely realistic jumping rules with hard caps and limits and bonuses for speed and distance travelled there'd need to be a half-page of columns.
Given you only ever move in five-foot increments it's easy enough to hand-wave away extra distance from speed as just not enough to hit that extra fifth foot (i.e. you travel just as far with a DC 14 as with a DC 10). If you feel the player is really straining to make the jump (running and getting a good head-start) you could rule they get a +2 circumstance bonus to the check.

Re: How do tumble, jump and movement interact?

Posted: Sat Jun 05, 2010 11:50 pm
by cure
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:First off, my ruling would be that if you're trying something that requires a skill check, like jumping, you are effectively in "combat". Hence, I would just ignore the local movement aspect. If you're jumping, it's tactical movement. Granted, the RAW doesn't say this explicitly, that's just my opinion.
In the case of tumbling to avoid attacks of opportunity that evidently makes sense. But as for jumping, that doesn't square with the option of taking 10 when not threatened, hurried or otherwise distracted.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Next, I think these two are pretty straightforward. (I'm assuming you mean long jump, not high jump, right?)
Yes, long jump.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: Tumbling crawl? I don't see the rules for that in the SRD, and I don't recall hearing of it.
From the FAQ and Rules of the Game. For a DC 20 or 25 tumble skill check, the sources differ on the DC, you can take a 5ft step while prone and so not incur attacks of opportunity on quitting a square. The absurd example I was constructing was that four 5 ft steps taken in a straight line over 4 rounds would give you the 20 ft for an unpenalised jump. But the notion that you could jump from a prone position using tumble is certainly open to challenge and the more so if one could subsequently land standing up.

Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 8:15 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Jester of the FoS wrote:The SRD speed modifier applies to base speed. You don't get a bonus if you double move (aka 60 feet that round) but you do if you're a monk or barbarian with fast movement.
So that part is irrelevant for this discussion.
I don't see anything about base speed in the SRD jump section, just "speed". I agree that double movement doesn't change the speed. (you can run at 30ft/3sec for 3 sec or for 6 sec, it's still 30ft/3sec). But the half-speed from tumbling should impose a penalty, IMHO.
cure wrote:In the case of tumbling to avoid attacks of opportunity that evidently makes sense. But as for jumping, that doesn't square with the option of taking 10 when not threatened, hurried or otherwise distracted.
True. But I would argue that you don't have to be threatened to use tactical movement. If you're not threatened or hurried and trying to jump a gap, why wouldn't you try to move at your maximum speed? (tactical movement is feet/round, local is feet/minute, a 10x speedup.)
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:From the FAQ and Rules of the Game. For a DC 20 or 25 tumble skill check, the sources differ on the DC, you can take a 5ft step while prone and so not incur attacks of opportunity on quitting a square. The absurd example I was constructing was that four 5 ft steps taken in a straight line over 4 rounds would give you the 20 ft for an unpenalised jump. But the notion that you could jump from a prone position using tumble is certainly open to challenge and the more so if one could subsequently land standing up.
Personally, I'd disallow it. That's stretching the meaning of "running start" beyond the breaking point. I can't find the rule for moving while prone in the SRD, but it's referenced in the FAQ that the ONLY movement you can do while prone is a 5ft step. Jumping is not a 5ft step. So at the very least, you'd have to stand up first. Then if you stood up, I'd rule that broke the "straight line" rule for a running start. 20ft on the ground and then 5ft or so standing up is an L shape, not a line.

In any event, though the rules don't say it, I'd say the running start has to be in the same round as the jump. I mean, is there anything in the rules that says I can't move 20 ft as part of a move action, then stand around for a half-hour in place, then jump? not that I see, but it's patently absurd.

Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 1:22 pm
by cure
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:The SRD speed modifier applies to base speed. You don't get a bonus if you double move (aka 60 feet that round) but you do if you're a monk or barbarian with fast movement.
So that part is irrelevant for this discussion.
I don't see anything about base speed in the SRD jump section, just "speed". I agree that double movement doesn't change the speed. (you can run at 30ft/3sec for 3 sec or for 6 sec, it's still 30ft/3sec). But the half-speed from tumbling should impose a penalty, IMHO.
The heart of the matter seems to lie here, in at least two different respects. What "should" impose a penalty or afford a bonus is quite possibly not of consequence since pace (walking, hustling, running) should be considered but there is no room to do so in the rules as written. The question then focuses on whether the rules as written are essentially talking about racial speed, modified by class in the case of the barbarian or monk, or actual speed, unmodified by pace, including full speed tumbling at a running pace, yet modified by the half speed of tumbling. That tumbling at half speed, tumbling at full speed, and tumbling at full speed at running pace all fall on the same spectrum renders the matter all the more obscure to me. Can you tumble at half speed at a running pace? I would think not. Do the haste and slow spells shed any useful light on any of this?

My ultimate interest in the matter concerns amputees (peg-leg pirates and such), with and without crutch(es) and prosthesis(es). My thinking is that their racial speed is unchanged, but their actual speed is modified according to the type of movement attempted along the lines of tumbling (e.g. half-speed). How that impacts jump DC in respect to the 20 ft proceeding the jump is what I am struggling with.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:If you're not threatened or hurried and trying to jump a gap, why wouldn't you try to move at your maximum speed? (tactical movement is feet/round, local is feet/minute, a 10x speedup.)
There is, I think, no difference in speed. Moving 15ft in 6 seconds and moving 150ft in 60 seconds is moving at the same speed. The "potential" advantage of doing a jump in local movement is that moving at a run is no longer a full action so doing the distance in front of a jump at a run is possible, but seemingly irrelevent for two different reasons. First, I don't see why a full action run couldn't be proceeded in the next round of tactical movement by a jump. Second, running is a question of pace of which jumping rules take no account.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Personally, I'd disallow it. That's stretching the meaning of "running start" beyond the breaking point.
By all means it does such stretching. But it was cited to underline the strangeness that the 20 ft proceeding a jump is pace independent, yet is modified by having the Run feat, is at least racial speed dependent, is impacted by a haste spell for the reason that the spell description explicitly says so, might or might not be impacted by tumbling at half speed, and might or might not be impacted by hobbling along on a crutch. It is patently absurd that someone hobbling with a crutch or a zombie shuffling along, on one hand, and somebody capable of running at x4, on the other hand, extract the same benefit from the 20ft proceeding a jump, yet my suspicion is that is precisely what the rules as written say.

Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 10:06 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
cure wrote:The heart of the matter seems to lie here, in at least two different respects. What "should" impose a penalty or afford a bonus is quite possibly not of consequence since pace (walking, hustling, running) should be considered but there is no room to do so in the rules as written.
because nobody tries to make a long jump while moseying. :) Speed is speed and pace is pace, and the two are not related in the rules. Pace merely indicates how much of the time you're moving at that speed and how much of the time you're doing other stuff.
The question then focuses on whether the rules as written are essentially talking about... or actual speed, unmodified by pace
I believe this to be the case.
. Can you tumble at half speed at a running pace?
No. Running in combat is a full-round action, not a move action, and tumbling is part of a move action.
My ultimate interest in the matter concerns amputees (peg-leg pirates and such), with and without crutch(es) and prosthesis(es). My thinking is that their racial speed is unchanged, but their actual speed is modified according to the type of movement attempted along the lines of tumbling (e.g. half-speed).
I don't know of any clear rules regarding amputees, but I would say just reduce their base speed and go from there.
There is, I think, no difference in speed. Moving 15ft in 6 seconds and moving 150ft in 60 seconds is moving at the same speed.
From the SRD:

"
Tactical, for combat, measured in feet (or squares) per round.
Local, for exploring an area, measured in feet per minute.
"

So it's the difference between moving 15ft in 6 seconds or 15ft in 60 seconds.
First, I don't see why a full action run couldn't be proceeded in the next round of tactical movement by a jump.
That seems sketchy to me, though I can't point to a rule against it. As I mentioned, I think the movement needs to be in the same round as the start of the jump, but maybe I'm wrong.
It is patently absurd that someone hobbling with a crutch or a zombie shuffling along, on one hand, and somebody capable of running at x4, on the other hand, extract the same benefit from the 20ft proceeding a jump, yet my suspicion is that is precisely what the rules as written say.
Agreed on the zombies. The "partial actions only" zombie thing is not accounted for by the jump rules, but it's a weird corner case.

For the hobbling person, as I said, I'd think would just be a matter of reduced speed and maybe a circumstance penalty to jumping, not because of speed, but because jumping even in place is difficult with a crutch or pegleg.

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 12:11 pm
by cure
According to the SRD: "A slowed creature moves at half its normal speed (round down to the next 5-foot increment), which affects the creature’s jumping distance as normal for decreased speed." Would this support the idea that tumbling at half speed affects jumping distance?

As to tactical movement being 10x faster and thus the only time frame in which one would want to jump, I still don't see how it is 10x faster:

Code: Select all

One Minute (Local) Speed
Walk 	150 ft. 	200 ft. 	300 ft. 	400 ft.
It is 150 ft in 60 seconds as local movement vs. 15 ft in 6 seconds as tactical movement which is exactly the same rate of movement, non?






, the former being internally divided by actions and the latter (as far as I can tell) not being internally divided. This is consequential as the internal division establishes minimium times for certain actions. For example, walking is



Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
cure wrote:The heart of the matter seems to lie here, in at least two different respects. What "should" impose a penalty or afford a bonus is quite possibly not of consequence since pace (walking, hustling, running) should be considered but there is no room to do so in the rules as written.
because nobody tries to make a long jump while moseying. :) Speed is speed and pace is pace, and the two are not related in the rules. Pace merely indicates how much of the time you're moving at that speed and how much of the time you're doing other stuff.


The question then focuses on whether the rules as written are essentially talking about... or actual speed, unmodified by pace
I believe this to be the case.
. Can you tumble at half speed at a running pace?
No. Running in combat is a full-round action, not a move action, and tumbling is part of a move action.
My ultimate interest in the matter concerns amputees (peg-leg pirates and such), with and without crutch(es) and prosthesis(es). My thinking is that their racial speed is unchanged, but their actual speed is modified according to the type of movement attempted along the lines of tumbling (e.g. half-speed).
I don't know of any clear rules regarding amputees, but I would say just reduce their base speed and go from there.
There is, I think, no difference in speed. Moving 15ft in 6 seconds and moving 150ft in 60 seconds is moving at the same speed.
From the SRD:

"
Tactical, for combat, measured in feet (or squares) per round.
Local, for exploring an area, measured in feet per minute.
"

So it's the difference between moving 15ft in 6 seconds or 15ft in 60 seconds.
First, I don't see why a full action run couldn't be proceeded in the next round of tactical movement by a jump.
That seems sketchy to me, though I can't point to a rule against it. As I mentioned, I think the movement needs to be in the same round as the start of the jump, but maybe I'm wrong.
It is patently absurd that someone hobbling with a crutch or a zombie shuffling along, on one hand, and somebody capable of running at x4, on the other hand, extract the same benefit from the 20ft proceeding a jump, yet my suspicion is that is precisely what the rules as written say.
Agreed on the zombies. The "partial actions only" zombie thing is not accounted for by the jump rules, but it's a weird corner case.

For the hobbling person, as I said, I'd think would just be a matter of reduced speed and maybe a circumstance penalty to jumping, not because of speed, but because jumping even in place is difficult with a crutch or pegleg.

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 12:12 pm
by cure
According to the SRD: "A slowed creature moves at half its normal speed (round down to the next 5-foot increment), which affects the creature’s jumping distance as normal for decreased speed." Would this support the idea that tumbling at half speed affects jumping distance?

As to tactical movement being 10x faster and thus the only time frame in which one would want to jump, I still don't see how it is 10x faster:

Code: Select all

One Minute (Local) Speed
Walk 	150 ft. 	200 ft. 	300 ft. 	400 ft.
It is 150 ft in 60 seconds as local movement vs. 15 ft in 6 seconds as tactical movement which is exactly the same rate of movement, n'est-ce pas?






, the former being internally divided by actions and the latter (as far as I can tell) not being internally divided. This is consequential as the internal division establishes minimium times for certain actions. For example, walking is



Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
cure wrote:The heart of the matter seems to lie here, in at least two different respects. What "should" impose a penalty or afford a bonus is quite possibly not of consequence since pace (walking, hustling, running) should be considered but there is no room to do so in the rules as written.
because nobody tries to make a long jump while moseying. :) Speed is speed and pace is pace, and the two are not related in the rules. Pace merely indicates how much of the time you're moving at that speed and how much of the time you're doing other stuff.


The question then focuses on whether the rules as written are essentially talking about... or actual speed, unmodified by pace
I believe this to be the case.
. Can you tumble at half speed at a running pace?
No. Running in combat is a full-round action, not a move action, and tumbling is part of a move action.
My ultimate interest in the matter concerns amputees (peg-leg pirates and such), with and without crutch(es) and prosthesis(es). My thinking is that their racial speed is unchanged, but their actual speed is modified according to the type of movement attempted along the lines of tumbling (e.g. half-speed).
I don't know of any clear rules regarding amputees, but I would say just reduce their base speed and go from there.
There is, I think, no difference in speed. Moving 15ft in 6 seconds and moving 150ft in 60 seconds is moving at the same speed.
From the SRD:

"
Tactical, for combat, measured in feet (or squares) per round.
Local, for exploring an area, measured in feet per minute.
"

So it's the difference between moving 15ft in 6 seconds or 15ft in 60 seconds.
First, I don't see why a full action run couldn't be proceeded in the next round of tactical movement by a jump.
That seems sketchy to me, though I can't point to a rule against it. As I mentioned, I think the movement needs to be in the same round as the start of the jump, but maybe I'm wrong.
It is patently absurd that someone hobbling with a crutch or a zombie shuffling along, on one hand, and somebody capable of running at x4, on the other hand, extract the same benefit from the 20ft proceeding a jump, yet my suspicion is that is precisely what the rules as written say.
Agreed on the zombies. The "partial actions only" zombie thing is not accounted for by the jump rules, but it's a weird corner case.

For the hobbling person, as I said, I'd think would just be a matter of reduced speed and maybe a circumstance penalty to jumping, not because of speed, but because jumping even in place is difficult with a crutch or pegleg.

Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 12:12 pm
by cure
According to the SRD: "A slowed creature moves at half its normal speed (round down to the next 5-foot increment), which affects the creature’s jumping distance as normal for decreased speed." Would this support the idea that tumbling at half speed affects jumping distance?

As to tactical movement being 10x faster and thus the only time frame in which one would want to jump, I still don't see how it is 10x faster:

Code: Select all

One Minute (Local) Speed
Walk 	150 ft. 	200 ft. 	300 ft. 	400 ft.
It is 150 ft in 60 seconds as local movement vs. 15 ft in 6 seconds as tactical movement which is exactly the same rate of movement, n'est-ce pas?

Re: How do tumble, jump and movement interact?

Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2010 1:31 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Sorry for the long time to reply (BTW, looks like some weird triple post above. want me to clean it up, cure?)

You're right, I didn't look far enough down in the local movement section to see that chart. tactical movement is in feet per round, and local movement is in feet per minute, but the distance moved in local movement is exactly scaled by 10, so it matches up. Sorry, my mistake.

But the fact remains that (as you mentioned), pace is irrelevant to jumping speed. And I will begrudgingly admit that actions seem irrelevant as well. So you could use a hustling (i.e. doubling move) or running pace in either tactical OR local movement, and it would have no effect. your speed remains your speed, and that's what determines the jumping DCs.

But IF your speed is reduced, say by tumbling, armor, or by being slowed, that would affect your jumping. If your speed is increased, by expeditious retreat, monk or barbarian fast movement, etc, that would affect your jumping. This all seems reasonable until you get to the zombies. (I love that I can type a sentence like that previous one without it seeming odd, by the way. ;) ) The enforced "pace" of partial actions only seems like a bit of a single-use hack. I don't remember it used anywhere else aside from the disabled and staggered conditions. I would simply rule that for purposes of jumping their speed is half normal due to their permanent partial-action only condition.