Page 1 of 2

Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sat Aug 21, 2010 3:54 pm
by Higginz
Hello,

As I've posted in another thread here on the forums, I want to start GM'ing Ravenloft games in my local gaming area here in Los Angeles. Originally, I was going to use Mistfinder rules, but now I am wondering if it is worth it to update previous Ravenloft products.

What I am asking is if it would be better to just run the 3.5 Ravenloft games or the 1 & 2e games with the rules they have?

I guess I'm just concerned that adding the Pathfinder rules will make it more difficult to find players since it is difficult to find PF players and difficult to find Ravenloft players.

Lastly, I'm thinking about what books I will have to tell the players they will need. If I run Mistfinder can I tell them they only need the PF book? If I run classic Ravenloft will they need to hunt down the old PHB's for the respective systems? These might seem like strange concerns, but I am new to GM'ing.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sat Aug 21, 2010 4:26 pm
by brass
I'm slightly biased to answer this one since I wrote the Mistfinder conversion guide. But in my opinion the pathfinder system has ironed out a number of 3.5's wrinkles and made the game easier to play. I'm a big fan of the Arthaus 3.5 stuff hence the conversion guide and would still be playing in 3.5 if paizo hadn't come along and fixed a lot the problems I had with 3.5. It has been many years since I've played 2e so I'm not qualified to comment on it. The reasons that I champion Pathfinder and paizo to my friends is their customer feedback and their concern about the balance of their game. They take feedback on board which the open playtest of most of the game has really shown. One last note is that paizo will still be releasing hopefully balanced support material for pathfinder for the foreseeable future, so when your one of your players can get some character inspiration from a new class that has just come out your game will reap the benefits.

I'll let some older and wiser heads advise you about the other systems. Thanks for taking an interest in my conversion project.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sat Aug 21, 2010 4:40 pm
by Higginz
I completely agree with you about Paizo on this one Brass. They have put out a very solid product, and I would rather support a small company that is interested in promoting quality RP'ing and the integrity of the original creation as designed by the creator than some greedy corporate profiteer that is only interested in exploiting an art form with no regard for the medium as a whole.

I am just concerned because I am going to advertise on my local Meetup group that I am running Ravenloft and I might have trouble getting people to sign up if they are confused about the rules.

In my gaming community, it is likely I will have to teach them both Ravenloft and Pathfinder.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 12:30 am
by ewancummins
Higginz wrote:I completely agree with you about Paizo on this one Brass. They have put out a very solid product, and I would rather support a small company that is interested in promoting quality RP'ing and the integrity of the original creation as designed by the creator than some greedy corporate profiteer that is only interested in exploiting an art form with no regard for the medium as a whole.

I am just concerned because I am going to advertise on my local Meetup group that I am running Ravenloft and I might have trouble getting people to sign up if they are confused about the rules.

In my gaming community, it is likely I will have to teach them both Ravenloft and Pathfinder.
I've played a little PF. It seems about as close to 3.5 as 3.5 is to 3.0. It's 3.75! ;)
I doubt the learning curve will be steep for most players.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 2:02 am
by Higginz
ewancummins wrote:
I've played a little PF. It seems about as close to 3.5 as 3.5 is to 3.0. It's 3.75! ;)
I doubt the learning curve will be steep for most players.
That's a good point too Ewan. Maybe I will just bill it as Ravenloft, and then in the details mention that we will use Pathfinder rules. So, that people who want to play Ravenloft will still want to play.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 2:14 am
by ewancummins
Higginz wrote:
ewancummins wrote:
I've played a little PF. It seems about as close to 3.5 as 3.5 is to 3.0. It's 3.75! ;)
I doubt the learning curve will be steep for most players.
That's a good point too Ewan. Maybe I will just bill it as Ravenloft, and then in the details mention that we will use Pathfinder rules. So, that people who want to play Ravenloft will still want to play.
IME, most players care more about the style of game than they do the rules. I don't see anything wrong with billing it like so:


RAVENLOFT GAME, PLAYERS WANTED
DM-Higginz
players wanted: 5-7
setting: Ravenloft, a gothic horror/heroic fantasy millieu
system: Pathfinder (compatible with/very similiar to D&D3.5)

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 3:25 am
by Higginz
ewancummins wrote:
IME, most players care more about the style of game than they do the rules. I don't see anything wrong with billing it like so:


RAVENLOFT GAME, PLAYERS WANTED
DM-Higginz
players wanted: 5-7
setting: Ravenloft, a gothic horror/heroic fantasy millieu
system: Pathfinder (compatible with/very similiar to D&D3.5)
I think that is in fact precisely how I will bill it. Now I just need to get everything ready, I want to get everything up and running in time for Halloween.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 8:24 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Exactly. Anyone who's played 3.x will have no issues with PF, IMHO.

And PF seems to be fairly popular anyway, you'd be surprised.

If your players have the PF book, great, but it's rather pricey, so I wouldn't require it. but note that anyone with a computer has this: http://paizo.com/pathfinderRPG/prd/

And if you go with 3.5 instead: http://www.d20srd.org/

That blurb looks good. You could even add: "No experience necessary" or something, if you're concerned.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 12:53 pm
by Higginz
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: You could even add: "No experience necessary" or something, if you're concerned.
That's a good idea too. I will definitely add that. On a slightly different topic, which character sheets would you use for such a campaign, the Ravenloft or Pathfinder sheets?

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2010 4:52 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Look for players through advertising it as a 3.5/Pathfinder game. Emphasis players can get the rules for free online at the Game Reference Document, which has racial and class rules. Or they can pick-up the entire 575page $40 rulebook as a PDF for $10 on the official site.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Fri Aug 27, 2010 10:10 pm
by Higginz
Hmm, I finally got Denizens of the Dread Realms, and I love it. How much would I have to modify the monsters in this book though to bring them up to PF rules? It almost seems like more trouble than it's worth. :?:

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Fri Aug 27, 2010 10:25 pm
by ewancummins
Higginz wrote:Hmm, I finally got Denizens of the Dread Realms, and I love it. How much would I have to modify the monsters in this book though to bring them up to PF rules? It almost seems like more trouble than it's worth. :?:

I don't think much work would be involved, as PF is so close to 3.5. It's certainly much less work than converting to 4E, or some other system.

Besides, why convert them all now? Just convert the ones you will use for the next adventure. :azalin:

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sat Aug 28, 2010 6:52 pm
by brass
I know it may be too late but I've plans to do a pathfinder ravenloft bestiary after the APG conversion.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Sat Aug 28, 2010 8:35 pm
by Higginz
brass wrote:I know it may be too late but I've plans to do a pathfinder ravenloft bestiary after the APG conversion.
Well, I'm going to try and adapt some of them for a game next month, so I'll post what I come up with here and see what you guys think.

Re: Mistfinder vs. 3.5 for a new GM

Posted: Mon Sep 06, 2010 2:10 pm
by Higginz
Now that I'm delving into this conversion, I'm more daunted than ever. For instance, the dread lords from Secrets of the Dread Realms, How should one adjust their ability scores in order to bring them inline with Pathfinder? This becomes especially problematic for ghostly NPC's that have levels in PC classes. Does one treat them as NPC's and thus take them through the character conversion, adding +2 to an ability and additional feats, or should one treat them as monsters?