Page 1 of 1

A Second Core.

Posted: Fri Sep 10, 2010 7:10 pm
by woodsdarkman
For some reason to me the Islands of Terror and The Cluster domains never really fit. They just seemed a little off.
Don't get me wrong most of the domains I like but I've always felt that more could be done with them. In the begining of Ravenloft their were just Islands of Terror. Then some formed into clusters and I have always felt that natural evolution would be for those domains to form a second core.

All of the clusters and Islands of Terror would form into a second core. Of course I would make the geography like our world. The Frozen Reaches would be north, the Amber Waste South, I'Cath and RT would be southeast and the Posion Sea being expanded into becoming a major sea. Shadowborn Cluster and other temperate domains would fill out the middle while some of the rocky domains (G'henna, Bluetspur, Nightmare Lands) would be west.
Pardion would go back to being a full domain as it originally was as would Timor. Timor Would be devoid of human life except when every few years some foolish humans would try and resettle there.

I would use all of the domains ever metioned in an official Ravenloft product (excluding novels) not connected to the core. I would also add a few of the fan made domains in some of the netbooks and maybe one or two of my own. I would try and keep the number of domains in the second core around the same as the number in the original core.

I would try and originate the formation of the second core as one of the results of the Time of Unparalled Darkness. I would then workout the trade and diplomacy issues of the second core. Who would be the warmonger, the isolationist, the enlightened and all that fun stuff. While all this is being worked out it would be a decade later before the people of the original core would find out about the second core. Think about the conflicts that would be sparked as domains from the first core vied for treaties, trade, colonies, and war allies in the quest for domination. Could it lead into open warfare across both cores.

I would welcome any thought or ideas in the matter. I have tinkered with this over the years, even coming up with a map. The idea is on hold for now while I await 4E Ravenloft. I like to stick to the current cannon. If however 4E Ravenloft turns out to be a bust and if it does then it will be hard to ressurect Ravenloft for third time so I will make my own second core book and new gazeteers.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Fri Sep 10, 2010 11:19 pm
by Deewun
I've always loved that Vechor is right next to the mists, but not connected to anything. In my mind, building a new core has always started there, with Vorostokov being it's neighbor and taking up a large chunk of land, like Darkon does.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Fri Sep 10, 2010 11:36 pm
by woodsdarkman
I agree. I always had Vechor as the westernmost part of the second core with the Nightmare Lands being an island in the Nocturnal Sea just south of Vechor.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Fri Sep 10, 2010 11:38 pm
by ewancummins
Why wait for 4E Ravenloft? Are you a 4E fan, or do you just assume that they may do a better job than you?

I'm more interested in your project than anything published by Hasbro these days, dude.

Slap that sucker together.

My only advice is this: some island domains are islands of terror because they work best that way. Isolation. Keep that in mind when you are making the map. If these domains are not to remaine isolated by the Mists, then you should conisder geographic barriers. High, almost impassable mountains, vast malarial swamps, etc.

Or perhaps you should leave certain small domains as islands in the mists, and work with the clusters and larger domains.

Don't forget Sourange. :misori:

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Sat Sep 11, 2010 12:57 am
by woodsdarkman
Good advice. Some of the domains like the nightmare lands or Sourange would be islands set in either an expanded Nocturnal Sea or The Posion Sea. Most of the lands of the second core have a very inhospitable climate which would be natural boundries and the domains themselves tend to be bigger making travel a lot more difficult.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 2:07 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I had the same idea way back when Vechor first showed up on the misty edge of the Notournal Sea. On the eastern side of the Cliffs of Vesanis was the Amber Wastes, greatly expanded to give the idea that portions of the Black Land had been added since Har-Akir's first appearance centuries ago. SOuth of it was the Steaming Lands, dominated by the Wildlands, whose shores were against the Noctournal Sea. The Wildlands would be a tremendous barrier to easy trade/travel to Sri Raji on the eastern edge of the cluster. Saragoss would be on the southern edge of the Wildlands, further complicating travel around the jungle to the lands beyond. Rokushima Taiyoo would be off the coast of Sri Raji, constituting the "edge of the world" as we know it.

To me the Core is not beyond modification, and the southern edge of it would be a large fence of high mountains, south of which is Vorostokhov. In the north of the Core, Darkon's Mistlands would border the Phantasmal Forest, stretching on tot he Shadowborn Cluster and giving Darkon a real threat on their border in Nidala Faith-Hold.

As suggested a good decade ago on Mordent Cartographic Society, Sanguinia would take the place of the lower Shadow Rift, and they recommend Farelle taking the top half of the Rift, but I've never found a distinguishing use for Farelle, so I'm at a bit of a loss there. Same with I'Cath, with seems to work better as a pocket of Rokushima Taiyoo, even though the base cultures are decidedly different.

I think the Fraternity's treatment of Paridon/Nosos is fantastic, and I would definitely adopt it. Bluetspur is the moon in my campaign, so it would need no land-based representation beyond that. G'Henna might fit nicely above Pharazia or another religiously opposed domain, although the more I think about it the more I think it works best back where it started, in the middle of the Core.

Staunton Bluffs works best as an island due to its history, though I can see it latching onto Ghastria or maybe getting tucked into the middle Core around Borca or Falkovnia. My treatment of the Shadow Rift is not an indictment of the fey or that supplement that describes them; but in my campaign the Fey have spread beneath the entire Core and the Shadow Rift was just an area where the "roof" had been blown off their domain.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 4:31 pm
by woodsdarkman
I like your ideas on the whole Wildlands and Amber Waste clusters. I' cath would be an island off RT somewhere close in the Posion Sea. On the other things I think we are going in different directions. I would not modify or tinker with the original core at all. My whole idea was to create a massive second core or continent (like Asia and Europe) compaired to the original core (like North america).
I will say that if I were to tinker with the original core your southern and northern border ideas are good and I would use them.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 6:30 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I thought the remoteness of the "foreign" domains like Har'Akir was a drawback of the setting's geography. I think of the Core more as Europe than north America, as being the center of "civilized" nations and their having a mission to export their culture to "savages" in other realms. Falkovnia would have the reputation of real-world Russia during the 18th and 19th centuries: that of a backwater, but still better than the indigenous peoples of Africa or India that were being exploited.

I think this sort of attitude has a place in a horror setting, particularly when you realize the horrors humans commit against each other. In that vein, I thought it was important for realms like Sri Raji and Har'Akir to have a physical route to them, like over the sea.

I like the idea of SOuragne being the gateway to a 3rd Core in the west, something more aligned to North America and the Carribean, with actual colonies from the "mainland" Core we all know so well.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 8:30 pm
by woodsdarkman
I get what your are saying. But for me it is not so much about the culture but the geography. I know the culture is more like Europe but what I want is a civilized continent with a great sea between a bigger continent with conflicting cultures and geography that is by its nature isolationist. Like the 1400's. New world vs old world if you get my meaning.
A domain like Stanton Bluffs would not fit if it were beside Sourange, the Frozen Reaches, or The Amber Waste. Put a few somewhat different type of domains inbetween and I think it would work. Like Siberia to Romania. Then from Romania to Iran. I just think there is a way that makes sense for all of the non core domains ever put into a Ravenloft product could be turned into a second core. It may not be easy but it could work. Oh yeah i would bring back Daglan as well. He could be the Azalin of the second core.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 8:42 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
A while back I spent some time working on a reorganization of Ravenloft into something more like a real world, and grouping domains was a big part of that. If you're interested, the domain grouping is in this post and the one after it. It ended up being several small continents/big islands, grouped roughly according to the Earth geography of the domain's inspiration (Asian domains together, etc. etc.)

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 8:58 am
by woodsdarkman
I read your post and I must say that is massive. I shudder to think about how much work that would take to put it all together. But it did give me an idea which I must thank you for. I would still use all of the Islands of Terror and Clusters to appear in an official Ravenloft product as the second core. But if I were to ever do a third core which I think could be done without being to absurd, I would use the fan made domains from the old Book of..... and The Undead Sea Scrolls and the QTR netbooks, maybe even some from the novels.
Of course I would have to figure out how it was discovered and the politics of the new core and how the other cores would react to it. I would also come up with a 4th sea (ocean) like in the real world. But that would probably be have the fun.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Sun Oct 03, 2010 11:04 pm
by brilliantlight
Why not a pre-existing 2nd core? The explaination of how the demiplane was created seems pretty weak. Strahd is simply not THAT important. However Ravenloft could be an entire plane in which the time was ripe to start another of almost an endless number of cores. The domains written about are just the newest core forming around Strahd's original domain and then the nearby clusters and islands. You could build another core that players could stumble into. You would need to come up a couple of dozen domains or so but with an entire site it could be done.

Re: A Second Core.

Posted: Mon Oct 04, 2010 3:04 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Har'Akir and Zherisia are mentioned as forming early, like right after Forlorn. These could be the basis for a 2nd Core, particularly Har'Akir, since we seem to be in agreement that it would be at the heart of such a continent. There seems to be a connection to Har'Akir's original homeworld, the Black Land, as shown in the addition of Sebua fromt he same realm. Har'Akir may have been steadily growing (Like Ebonbane's domain) even after its appearance as an Island of Terror. The map that came with the Red Box may have just been the area known to travelers, it could go on and on like the Sahara.

I am a huge proponent of a "connected" Ravenloft, and would be interested in any project that might expand on the concept.