Page 1 of 1

Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 4:55 pm
by DoctorMoreau
The Ravenloft DMG mentions using cut scenes to really feel in the players when it comes to the background of a villian for example. Has anyone actually used these? How do they feel, how do you avoid giving too much away. Are they avoid idea, a bad idea or any advice?

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 5:43 pm
by HuManBing
I like cutscenes, but I try to avoid movie-style cutscenes (where something that's way the hell away from the PCs happens and they're allowed to see it). Some games have very effective cutscenes in them, where the players are seeing things that the characters could reasonably see, but cannot influence the outcome until the scene is over.

For one of the most effective ones in my recent memory, check out Bioshock when you finally confront Andrew Ryan. Very powerful plot elements brought out in that scene, and the player can't do anything (of his own will, anyway). Somehow it works.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 5:57 pm
by Deewun
I don't so much as do Cutscenes as I do deleted scenes. AFter a story-arc, I'll show them what happened while they were somewhere else, to help explain villain motivations or little secret things that happened they didn't realize.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 9:06 pm
by Mangrum
I do something similar. After an adventure/campaign/what-have-you is wrapped up, I'm more than happy to explain what was going on behind the scenes.

As for using cut scenes to provide villain backstory; no, never. Closest I've ever done to that is presenting players with the Songs of Shazathared in Paizo's Legacy of Fire campaign. To be honest, I didn't even like the idea at the time it was going in the RLDMG, but hey, different strokes.

I do agree that there needs to be some way to present darklord backstories in Ravenloft games, but were I working on the setting now, I'd go with a more organic, in-game method somewhat inspired by the fanes in Expedition to Castle Ravenloft.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 9:37 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I do it semi regularly... I fell in love with the idea the moment I read it. (Thanks for not pushing too hard to take it out of the RLDMG, John! :) )

here are some examples from my journals (search for "Cut scene" on each page. the stuff inside the boxes is DM's commentary. The cut scenes themselves are outside of the boxes.)
http://themistway.com/Ravenloft-Session7-DMC.html
http://themistway.com/Ravenloft-Session9-DMC.html
http://themistway.com/Ravenloft-Session11-DMC.html
http://themistway.com/Ravenloft-Session16-DMC.html
http://themistway.com/Ravenloft-Session8-DMC.html

I primarily used them to show the aftermath of their successes, as the villains stewed and regrouped. While I do have a PC who is "wacky vision guy," I didn't bother framing them as an in-character vision. I went with the full movie-style, out-of-character method.

It seemed to work very well. The players enjoyed getting the extra puzzle pieces, and they successfully kept the knowledge away from their characters.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2010 10:01 pm
by Higginz
I'm going to start DM'ing a Ravenloft campaign shortly, and I intend to use them extensively. However, I subscribe to a more story driven style of rpg than many.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 4:49 am
by brass
The Call of Cthulhu D20 rulebook has a great section on using cinematic techniques in horror in the GM section. It might not be to everyone's taste but it's good reading.

I used to use them quite a bit while running Call of Cthulhu and In Nomine.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 5:41 am
by The Giamarga
Most of the PbM campaigns that i've read use them to great effect. Check out the ones in the subforum.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:44 am
by Joël of the FoS
Yes I do, once a while, to show them the aftermath of their actions. You can check my campaign and scan the document for "cut scene". I use it to give atmospherics, as well as provide info to the players (stuff most of the time they could have found with gather info afterward).

But seeing a scene is sometimes more vivid than a story by a NPC.

I often use them at the end of a game, as a teaser, after a climatic battle. Or send to all players via email a few days before the game.

Once, they had a fight with a pack of lycanthropes led by Nathan Timothy. One of the few werewolf to escape was Natalia. The cut scene was along the lines of "After the battle, Natalia is alone in a small hole in a rocky hill. She is licking her wounds and is shaking with rage …"

It confirmed (but they already knew it), that they had a new friend :)

Same topic, another question. How do you justify these in game? I usually say they "all have the same dream", or the same vision.

Joël

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 2:53 pm
by The Giamarga
Here are four very interesting blog posts from ars ludi on his take on cut scenes, where the players get to play NPCs in a foreshadowing scene:
Normal Vision, part 1
Normal Vision, part 2
Normal Vision, part 3
Normal Vison ,part 4
(Be sure to also read the comments where lots of great discussion takes place)

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Tue Sep 14, 2010 7:15 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
The Giamarga wrote:Here are four very interesting blog posts from ars ludi on his take on cut scenes, where the players get to play NPCs in a foreshadowing scene:
Oh yeah, I forgot to mention the payoff to all my cutscenes... In running From the Shadows, I told my players that I was doing an extended cut scene, showing what was happening to Azalin's victims, and I gave them each an "NPC" to play, starting as a head on a shelf in Azalin's lab. When they reached the library and saw their PC's names in the Book of Names, they realized it wasn't a cut-scene at all, but that their PC's had become claimed by Darkon's memory effect, and turned into "native darkonian" NPC's.

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Wed Sep 15, 2010 11:52 am
by DoctorMoreau
I loved the emailed cut scene idea by the way. That sounds like a great idea

Re: Cut Scenes: Does anyone use them?

Posted: Mon Sep 20, 2010 12:54 pm
by alhoon
I also use cut scenes from time to time. Usually, to not break the tension, I use them as dreams or omens for the PCs, especially clerics.