Page 1 of 1
Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Sun Dec 05, 2010 10:53 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I think I read someplace that the inspiration for Valachan came from Shirley Jackson's short story, "The Lottery." I'm wondering first off if anyone else ever saw this written down someplace, and secondly how well it works. My wife bought me a Shirley Jackson collection the other day and I read the story for the first time in about 15 years, maybe longer; it was definitely in high school. I admit to being no literary genius, but I'm not sure I see the parallels. Particularly in the Black Box, before the Valachani were officially dark skinned, before von Karkhov had been fleshed out in Darklords, the only thing that sticks out about the domain was the "White Fever" contracted by people sent to serve their wicked baron. Whereas Barovians were said to give Strahd a wide berth because they feared him, the people of Valachan were blissfully unaware that there was anything out of the ordinary about von Karkhov and defended him (violently?) against his naysayers. In this respect I think they sound more like Dracula's loyal servants than the everyday folk who shrug off a barbaric act because "that's the way it is" like in Jackson's story.
Now, if i did NOT read that and imagined it, this has been a waste of time and I apologize. But I'm pretty sure I did.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Mon Dec 06, 2010 3:12 pm
by Sareau
I don't remember a panther/vampire/werebeast in The Lottery...
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Mon Dec 06, 2010 4:25 pm
by brilliantlight
There isn't one but I see what he is saying. It is a simular theme. In that story they sacrafice some random person to ensure a good harvest. In Valachan they sacrafice a woman to keep the Dark Lord from creating havoc in his realm.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Mon Dec 06, 2010 11:43 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I'm actually in agreement with Sareau. But my whole argument hinges on the fact that the domain actually WAS based on the short story. To Brilliantlight, I don't think there was ever a point when the Valachani people were said to be afraid of von Karkhov. They never seem to piece together white fever with the predations of a vampire and the lottery in Valachan (such as it is) is for labor at Castle Pantera, not really a death sentence since people tend to return from there quite frequently. I guess I'm saying von Karkhov has not been painted as the predator his species would indicate, at least not against his own people. The Lottery is a creepy story, and caused a real stir when it was released, and I think the concept has a place in our lovely setting. I'm just not sure Valachan is a good example of it. I wish I could remember where I read the comparison, for some reason I want to say it was from pretty high up, like maybe even Kargat.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Tue Dec 07, 2010 3:27 am
by LadySoth
Reading this thread caused me to reread the story and watch the film on youtube. I always saw it as a very creepy and unsetting story (which it was supposed to be no doubt) but I'd never understood why we studied it in school. Reading the Wikipedia on it years later today and reading the author's justifications for her story made it more interesting to me. So thanks for that Strahd's Buddy (

Ace name BTW!)
So far as it being the inspiration for Valachan, I have never heard of that or read that anywhere. If you ever do remember where you read that, it'd be interesting to see how they used it as a reference. I think brilliantlight's idea made the most sense.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Tue Dec 07, 2010 9:29 am
by Sareau
I am not convinced-the concept of a lottery to determine the sacrifice to the gods predates Shirley Jackson, and doesn't seem to be a dominant theme, really. If anything, Kharkov strikes me as an "innocent" darklord, sort of forced into his position by the plottings of everyone around him until forced to assert himself. I mean, he was originally an animal forced into assassination.
I'd make a case for him being inspired more by Shere Khan of The Jungle Book than by the Lottery.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Tue Dec 07, 2010 6:27 pm
by brilliantlight
Strahdsbuddy wrote:I'm actually in agreement with Sareau. But my whole argument hinges on the fact that the domain actually WAS based on the short story. To Brilliantlight, I don't think there was ever a point when the Valachani people were said to be afraid of von Karkhov. They never seem to piece together white fever with the predations of a vampire and the lottery in Valachan (such as it is) is for labor at Castle Pantera, not really a death sentence since people tend to return from there quite frequently. I guess I'm saying von Karkhov has not been painted as the predator his species would indicate, at least not against his own people. The Lottery is a creepy story, and caused a real stir when it was released, and I think the concept has a place in our lovely setting. I'm just not sure Valachan is a good example of it. I wish I could remember where I read the comparison, for some reason I want to say it was from pretty high up, like maybe even Kargat.
Every so often someone's daughter is married off to Kharov and she never comes back alive. He tries his best at first but eventually snaps and kills her. It is in Gazeteer IV. She is even picked by a lottery sometimes.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Thu Dec 09, 2010 9:34 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
I think the parallel(s) to The Lottery were added much later, when the Gaz IV entry was written. It doesn't seem to be an inspiration for the original concept of the domain.
Re: Valachan = The Lottery?
Posted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 3:31 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Von Kharkov taking a bride each year goes all the way back to the Black Box, but there's no mention of a lottery (virtually the same text is reprinted in the Red Box). The lottery bit was added later, but not in the Gaz. It dates back to the Dungeon Magazine module Felkovic's Cat, from 1994, as much of the Valachan info in the Gaz does.
But the lottery is only one aspect of Valachan, and a small one at that. And aside from the fact that they are both lotteries where the "Winner" dies, there's not much resemblance between Valachan's lottery and "The Lottery." The Jackson story may have inspired Paul Culotta (author of the module) but if so, he changed it enough so as to be quite different.