Page 1 of 1
want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Sun Dec 26, 2010 10:31 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
check this out...
some guy on the wotc boards made
a map with the major D&D continents to scale on the same earth-sized world.
now try to find Ravenloft. It is there. (the core, at least). but it makes a good argument for expanding the scale of the Ravenloft map....
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Sun Dec 26, 2010 11:13 am
by Nathan of the FoS
I'm pretty sure I found Taladas (to which the Core is appended), but the version of the map I was looking at didn't zoom in enough to figure out what little snippet was Ravenloft.

Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Sun Dec 26, 2010 11:14 am
by alhoon
The core is the size of Switcherland. You won't be able to find it.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Sun Dec 26, 2010 11:50 am
by Strahdsbuddy
I saw this project a few years ago, my version of the map is even labeled. Ravenloft it plenty tiny, but I think our discussions on the advantages of this have been well documented. In fact, from a population standpoint, i find dialing back the monsters is even more effective. What can you do with 1000 vampires that you can't do with 10? a city the size of Lekar or Il Aluk should be enough to get lost in without giving it a population the size of modern Tokyo.
As far as area, Vorostokhov is the largest of the canon domains, and its vastness is part of the terror there. For the Core, however, the fact that there is not enough room to hide from your enemies is helpful to the DM.
That map is pretty nifty though. What would that planet be in scale related to Earth?
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Sun Dec 26, 2010 5:36 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
It's about 60-70% of the way to right (east), and about 75% of the way down (south).
See the island thing that's kinda like a swirly red eye? just east of that, across the sea, on that pennisula of what is presumably taladas, there's a black \ slash. It's the shadow rift.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Mon Dec 27, 2010 2:45 am
by Nathan of the FoS
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:See the island thing that's kinda like a swirly red eye?
It looks rather more orange than red to me...I can't get the map big enough to read the legend on it. It does seem to be the best landmark (seamark?) for finding Ravenloft.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Mon Dec 27, 2010 9:32 pm
by Jester of the FoS
The Core and the continents from Dragonlance are both pretty tiny. Chock it up to people not knowing scale.
It's a North American flaw, where judging medieval distances realistically is skewed, damaged by generations of car and the scale of terrain in North America compared to Europe. Continents are either too small or too large. I've seen a few fantasy worlds with prairies the size of the Soviet Union.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 1:33 am
by ewancummins
Jester of the FoS wrote:The Core and the continents from Dragonlance are both pretty tiny. Chock it up to people not knowing scale.
It's a North American flaw, where judging medieval distances realistically is skewed, damaged by generations of car and the scale of terrain in North America compared to Europe. Continents are either too small or too large. I've seen a few fantasy worlds with prairies the size of the Soviet Union.
Considering that a pretty fair chunk of the Soviet Union and Central Asia is steppe, that's not
totally ridiculous.

It would depend on the area of the landmass, prevailing winds, rainfall, etc. but a really huge region of grasslands might be feasible. I'd expect to find a desert in the middle of such a vast continent, although a shallow inland sea would certainly be interesting.
Krynn is
supposed to be a planet smaller than Earth. Canon states as much.
Likewise, Ravenloft's Core is supposed to be relatively small, although I rather think TSR overdid it.

There is a scale problem on some of the maps. I make the Core about the size of the HRE; not huge, but big enough to contain multiple terrain types and multiple small states.
Besides, why should Europe be the baseline for D&D settings? On the old maps Faerun is rightly compared with the continental USA, not with Europe, you'll note. American gamers will naturally compare distances to their own nation. Our country has more variety of terrain and climate than has Europe (if we leave out European Russia, certainly so). Europe is
too small for a semi realistic 'tundra to jungle' kind of fantasy continent on an
Earth sized planet. As for scale of journeys, in the early 19th century Lewis and Clark travelled very far in conditions actually
worse than what you would find in most of medieval Europe. Covered wagons that came afterward weren't a whole lot faster. Steam navigation and eventually railroads did a l
ot to effectively shorten distances- but those were unavailable to early explorers and settlers. No Roman roads out on the frontier, either. We North Americans certainly do have a good sense of scale, those of us who have studied our history.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 2:09 am
by Manofevil
I would stop to make the point of reminding you that RavenLoft is a CONSTRUCT, so you aren't necessarily going to HAVE coherent terrain across misty borders. You might have it with lands that were created from whoile cloth by the mists, but tracts of land that were yanked right off their base worlds are going to come exactly as they are regardless of all inconsistancies they cause and not just those in the landscape.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 2:42 am
by ewancummins
Manofevil wrote:I would stop to make the point of reminding you that RavenLoft is a CONSTRUCT, so you aren't necessarily going to HAVE coherent terrain across misty borders. You might have it with lands that were created from whoile cloth by the mists, but tracts of land that were yanked right off their base worlds are going to come exactly as they are regardless of all inconsistancies they cause and not just those in the landscape.
Ravenloft is a special case- but previous posters brought up
planetary worlds like Krynn. Yes, the Demiplane is not a planet, much less a 'realistic' planet. Climate and terrain variety aren't the big issues.
I think the real issue with a tiny Core is that
travel times will tend to be very shortthat can mess up adventures and 'shrink' the world more than a DM might like. Another problem is that you either don't have enough room for
sizeable populations (which some DMs want to use) or you don't have enough wilderness left over after subtracting the needed farmland to support said populations. Making the Core more like the size of Germany leaves you with plenty of room for farms, cities, wilderness, etc. Just keep the civlized domains
relatively small.
YMMV, of course.
Re: want to feel kind of insignificant?
Posted: Sat Jan 08, 2011 2:41 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Manofevil wrote:I would stop to make the point of reminding you that RavenLoft is a CONSTRUCT, so you aren't necessarily going to HAVE coherent terrain across misty borders.
Quite true. Likewise, it's inappropriate to have huge stretches of sparsely-inhabited or vacant landscape between this particular game-setting's points of interest, because the DPs only incorporate more land if it's part of a darklord's custom-made fishbowl. Why would they bother adding much terrain that no darklord will ever see? If you removed all the vacant steppeland and desert and open oceans and so forth from a map of medieval Earth, it'd look a bit crowded too.