HuManBing wrote:LOL!
I'm going to have to remember that one: GMPC. Sums up the concept so wonderfully!

I think it's fine for a GM to recycle his old PCs for use as NPCs- just so long as they:
c) will never overshadow the party, and are in fact not even NPC 'members' of the party
b) are played just as any other NPC;
no special protection or fudging to save a 'favie' from death or misfortune- the DM must take special care to be objective and fair in handling their scences/actions
c) are used mainly as minor supporting characters, background fillers, occasional contacts__________
not as main villains, patrons, etc.
Some DMs should never use old PCs, because they cannot resist the urge to show how 'awesome' their old PCs are, or to 'help out' the players with unwanted and unneeded assistance and advice. These DMs always seem to have uberpowerful Mary Sue PCs.
So far as I know, Elminster was always an NPC, and never Ed Greenwood's PC. He's still a Mary Sue. He is
hypercompetent, built with 'special rules' unavailable to the 'mere mortal' PCs, very meddlesome, and annoyingly patronizing in his manner. I'm basing that of what I have read of the character as played by Greenwood and as represented in canon FR sources.
BTW, I think that FR is a very good classic D&D setting, but that it is justly criticized for having an overload of superheroes and for making too much use of these types in published modules. I blame the novels, really.