Page 1 of 2

Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Wed Dec 29, 2010 5:32 pm
by Manofevil
By this I mean, if it's not on the encounter table, can it be there without huge background?

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Wed Dec 29, 2010 6:41 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
Sure.

Though, any Treant would definitely have a chip on its shoulder. The sun light is so weak, and the soil so cold, the tree might have had to develop other means of acquiring energy. They might be carnivorous, using blood or flesh to supplement their photosynthesis. Even more disturbing, a Barovian treant might even be herbivorous - a cannibalistic plant that sends sucker roots into nearby plants, draining them of their vital energies to maintain its own existence.

As Treants are so closely connected to the earth, a Barovian treant would be bound closely to Strahd. It might share his moods, his memories, even some of his power.That could, in theory, allow it to stay hidden from Strahd since he might sense it as part of himself rather than as an individual.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 12:26 am
by ewancummins
Manofevil wrote:By this I mean, if it's not on the encounter table, can it be there without huge background?

Sure. You are the DM, so you can do as you please. It's your game, your setting.

I don't see why the Mists couldn't nab an ent, or even why there couldn't be native ents.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 6:44 am
by Hogan Van Monsterband
I'm fairly sure one of the monsterbooks (the 3rd ed one?) explicitly mentions evil treants. They've got creepy Disney-Sleepy-Hollow faces.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 9:35 am
by HuManBing
ScS of the Fraternity wrote:As Treants are so closely connected to the earth, a Barovian treant would be bound closely to Strahd. It might share his moods, his memories, even some of his power.That could, in theory, allow it to stay hidden from Strahd since he might sense it as part of himself rather than as an individual.
I like this!

It could then make the treant a very useful NPC to help the PCs out. First, it's invisible to Strahd, so his network of informants won't have any leads on it. Second, it's always going to be in one place so the PCs can be fairly sure of having a safe home base somewhere.

Of course, this brings up other complications. If Strahd gets wind of the treant's existence, he could always find it through other means (tracking the PCs would be an obvious one). The PCs might have to take extra special precautions in order to keep the tree's location secret - maybe if things go really badly, they may have to relocate the entire tree!

Stylistically, too, it makes for an interesting plot point. Barovia's nighttime wilds are terrifying to the populace. But if the PCs need to get to their one single reliable source, it'll have to be at night, when no human eyes are watching. Merely getting to their treant could be a harrowing experience in itself...

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 12:08 pm
by Joël of the FoS
I would see them as extremely rare, in the good aligned version. And even then, as ScS said, and Mangrum too, the corrupted soil (I am the land) makes them vulnerable. I would see them away from civilisation (like in the heart of the Balinoks, in a deep forest in darkon, etc.).

So most of the animated trees in RL would be evil, IMHO.

The list of similar ideas include:

- Blightspawned [Unapproachable East], a suggestion from Chris Nichols
- Treant, warped [Monster Manual, Denizens of Dread]
- Blackfoot marauder [Dragon mag]
- Treant, wormeaten [Denizens of Dread (under Plant, Undead Treant)]

Also, in one of the USS (2002), I designed the Adohi, a rare but very evil treant-like horror, that was a lot of fun too.

Joël

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 12:15 pm
by Manofevil
I was implying the evil treant of the sort seen in the novel Death of a Darklord.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 1:14 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
Wasn't the tree in Death of a Darklord just an ordinary tree that had died, and was animated by what amounts to a rather sophisticated bit of necromancy?

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 9:01 pm
by cure
Even if there was a good aligned treant in Barovia would Strahd care? Doesn't he have better things to do than bother a tree that has no intention of setting a root on the stone of Castle Ravenloft? He is not a control freak to that degree. Heck, he lets Inijira hang out in Zeitenberg (although that one does puzzle me).

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 11:11 pm
by Saranka
The first image that comes to my mind whenever I think of Ravenloft is a panoramic of gnarled twisted evil trees in dark somber woods where eyes are hungering with full passionated hate.

The thought of huge shadowy figures creaking heavily and slowly through those darknesses full of mistery and dread sure fits my party's treasure.


In the Second Edition's Ravenloft Monstrous Compendium Appendice I there are two kinds of treants and one sentient tree. All evil and very rare.

The Quickwood (Spy Tree)
A great hardwood tree appearing to be an oak, but on close inspection reveals to have a distorted human face with sensory organs a little superior to humans. They survive on soil nutrients and water and are very intelligent. They sometimes serve as guardians for treasure or for an area.

Evil Treants
They go to great lengths to torment and terrorize travelers crossing their domains. They are carnivorous and very intelligent. They favor the flesh of intelligent creatures (usually humans and demihumans) over all other prey. Their chosen delicacy – when they can obtain it – is the flesh of innocents, who they torment and horrify before devouring. Evil Treants rarely kill their prey before consuming it, for they believe that this makes it unfit for digestion. Thus, accidentally slained victims (in combat or during torture) are discarded to the scavengers of the forest. Even if the treant was hungry at the time.

Undead Treant
“When an evil treant sees that its many years are soon to come to an end, it seldom accepts this fate quietly. For most, this means a final, wild orgy of violence and death. For a few, however, it means death and resurrection as a thing so dark and evil that even the Vistani will not speak of it.”
Undead treants are even more intelligent than evil treants. They tend to live in small copses of dead trees, are more active at night and feed on living blood through small root-like tendrils that snake out and bury themselves in a sleeping, fallen, or prone victim's flesh. Anyone being drained of blood by the treant is rendered immobile as the coils of roots encircle his body. Individuals so entrapped can only escape with the aid of a third party.


I loved the above posts about the treants. They could be good tragic heroes surviving through the hopelessness of the dread realm – like the PCs themselves –; or evil beings not worthy of the vampire lord's attention, but – by themselves – dangerous to the PCs; or even the fingers of Strahd himself exerting his will through the dark land of Barovia more directly than by his other less trustful agents.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Sat Jan 08, 2011 2:17 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
The type of tree and nature of the terrain ought to influence a treant's demeanor, not just its Ravenloft-altered alignment. I can picture a willow treant as a somber, calculating creature that attacks by surprise, dangling its whippy branches in the water as it waits for boats to pass nearby on the river. A beech treant would be ponderous and slow, with its huge limbs drooping to sweep along the ground, yet would never, ever stop coming at you, even if it means battering its own branches to flinders against the walls of the cabin you've barricaded yourself inside. An aspen treant would be cowardly, hiding in dense thickets of other aspens and animating them as cannon fodder, rather than risking its slender frame in melee.

This will, of course, be doubly surprising if the players have only met oak treants before. :D

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Sun Jan 09, 2011 2:55 am
by ewancummins
cure wrote:Even if there was a good aligned treant in Barovia would Strahd care? Doesn't he have better things to do than bother a tree that has no intention of setting a root on the stone of Castle Ravenloft? He is not a control freak to that degree. Heck, he lets Inijira hang out in Zeitenberg (although that one does puzzle me).

I have an image of an ent staking Strahd with it's index finger, then ripping off his head.

Badass.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Sun Jan 09, 2011 12:44 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:The type of tree and nature of the terrain ought to influence a treant's demeanor, not just its Ravenloft-altered alignment. I can picture a willow treant as a somber, calculating creature that attacks by surprise, dangling its whippy branches in the water as it waits for boats to pass nearby on the river. A beech treant would be ponderous and slow, with its huge limbs drooping to sweep along the ground, yet would never, ever stop coming at you, even if it means battering its own branches to flinders against the walls of the cabin you've barricaded yourself inside. An aspen treant would be cowardly, hiding in dense thickets of other aspens and animating them as cannon fodder, rather than risking its slender frame in melee.

This will, of course, be doubly surprising if the players have only met oak treants before. :D
Spruce treants lie in wait to envelope you and prickle you to death, Douglas fir treants have long long legs and step on people, and cottonwood treants just fall over on you. :shock: :wink:

WRT aspens, many aspen groves are actually one organism, which fits Roti's suggestion for their M.O. down to the ground (so to speak).

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2011 5:03 pm
by alhoon
ewancummins wrote:Sure. You are the DM, so you can do as you please. It's your game, your setting.

I don't see why the Mists couldn't nab an ent, or even why there couldn't be native ents.
That.
Because the written encounter table doesn't include the monsters you want, it doesn't mean you would get sued if you used them.

Re: Can there be any treants in Barovia

Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2011 5:36 am
by The Giamarga
cure wrote:He is not a control freak to that degree. Heck, he lets Inijira hang out in Zeitenberg (although that one does puzzle me).


Actually i think Strahd is unaware that Inajira hides in Teufeldorf.