Page 1 of 2

Shadow asp troubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 2:22 am
by cure
I really do like the concept of shadow asps. But as written they seem troubled to me. Perhaps you can set me straight . . .

First, I summon 5d6 shadow asps and permanently bind them to my tomb. Eventually a tomb robber breaks in and my shadow asps manage to poison him down to 0 strength. He then dies while failing his fortitude saving throw and becomes an undead shadow. It proceeds to kill all my shadow asps. I have just exchanged 5d6 guardians for one miserable shadow.

Second, I summon 5d6 shadow asps and permanently bind them to my tomb. They are magical beast so they eat, drink, and sleep. They begin to die of hunger and thirst. Must my desert tomb have running water for eternity and must I train my shadow asps to use a sustaining spoon?

Third, at great expense I arrange for my tomb to have a minor but permanent rat infestation so that my shadow asps won't starve to death. A shadow asp bites a rat, poisons it, the rat dies, it makes its fortitude save, and dissipates into nothing, leaving my shadow asp as hungry as before.

Fourth, the shadow asp tries again and this time the rat fails its fortitude save and arguably turns into an undead shadow that kills all my shadow asps.

Fifth, I decided to find something for the shadow asps to eat that will make its fortitude save, but they won't be able to poison such a thing in the first place, and probably won't be able to kill it either in the second place as they deliver only 1 hp per bite.

Sixth, I discover that have a morale problem with my shadow asps. They don't understand why they do 1d2-3 damage when they bite something. I explain that they aren't actually healing their victims, that they in fact are doing 1 hp of damage. But then they are confused as to why it doesn't just say 1d2-1 damage or simpler still 1 damage. And I can only say that it is the will of Ra which is not a name that a shadow asp wants to hear.

Seven, despite what my best magicians keep telling me, I can't help but wondering if shadow asps really are magic beasts. Ra is strangely silent on the matter . . . .

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 6:22 am
by The Giamarga
Clearly we need an ecology of the shadow asp.

According to the Sulerin monster index, the Shadows Asp is also detailed in the following sources: 3E Fiend Folio, Denizens of Darkness, Ravenloft: Creatures of Darkness, Dragon#174.

The Dragon article is probaby the oldest and might even contain a few interesting ecology details.

You could simply make them undead, same as the shadow. I wonder how a simple viper with the shadow creature template would fare?

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 7:43 am
by Rock of the Fraternity
A shadow isn't bound to the place where it first spawns, right? If the shadow asps just hide after the killing, the shadow will eventually get bored and look for living people to kill elsewhere.

You could just adjust the binding of the shadow asps, so they're free to roam around as long as they return to the tomb at regular times, and can find food and water outside. Having rugged nature around your tomb actually works; it's good camouflage.

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 9:33 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I'm away from my books right now, so I don't know if any of the others are answered anywhere, but I can answer this one:
cure wrote:Sixth, I discover that have a morale problem with my shadow asps. They don't understand why they do 1d2-3 damage when they bite something. I explain that they aren't actually healing their victims, that they in fact are doing 1 hp of damage. But then they are confused as to why it doesn't just say 1d2-1 damage or simpler still 1 damage.
This is some slight rules baggage. Since damage is Strength based, and the asps have a STR of 4 or 5, they have a strength modifier of -3. So in the unlikely even that they got stronger (much stronger), and got to a strength modifier of 0 or better, they could actually get to do a d2 of damage (plus strength mod). I doubt any tomb preparation specialist is going to waste their time trying to teach their shadow asps to read a Manual of Gainful Exercise (and then fit them with cute little belts of giant strength). But the rules support it.... (or I guess, you could say, the rules are there to subtly indicate that this would be really futile to attempt).

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 10:37 am
by The Giamarga
Well someone could cast enlarge or even animal growth them to get a whopping +8 to strength.

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 12:35 pm
by cure
Rock wrote:A shadow isn't bound to the place where it first spawns, right? If the shadow asps just hide after the killing, the shadow will eventually get bored and look for living people to kill elsewhere.

You could just adjust the binding of the shadow asps, so they're free to roam around as long as they return to the tomb at regular times, and can find food and water outside. Having rugged nature around your tomb actually works; it's good camouflage.
The shadow is bound to the site of its creation but otherwise has freewill.

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 1:56 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
Tisk. How bothersome.

Oh, well. The shadow asps could always retreat until the inevitable band of adventurers has killed the undead shadow, then return to their place of 'employment'. Sure, the treasures being guarded will be gone by then, but what's that to a snake?

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 3:10 pm
by cure
How about giving them the cold one feat? Or would a shadow "see" through that eventual?

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 3:12 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
Cold One only works against mindless undead, doesn't it?

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 4:04 pm
by Kadarin
I know that add2e isn't very popular 'round here, but sometimes it pays to take a look back:

"Shadow asps are not a part of the physical world. Because of their extradimensional origins, they play no part in the grand scheme of nature apart from bringing death to their victims and creating undead shadows."
(RVMC III, tsr2153)

So:
Shadows do not attack Shadow Asps.
Shadow Asps do not require food or water, just shadows (but not Shadows).
Shadow Rat would make a nice monster, imo.
Shadow asps aren't magic beasts, they're demiplanar-elemental beasts. Or maybe pseudo-undeads. Whatever.

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Sat Jan 01, 2011 4:12 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
I haven't been exposed to a lot of 2e, and this was interesting, useful info. ^^ Thanks for sharing!

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 9:59 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Kadarin wrote:I know that add2e isn't very popular 'round here,
While many of us have moved on to other rule systems, I think everyone 'round here appreciates the 2e Ravenloft line.
Kadarin wrote:but sometimes it pays to take a look back:

"Shadow asps are not a part of the physical world. Because of their extradimensional origins, ..."
(RVMC III, tsr2153)
...
Shadow asps aren't magic beasts, they're demiplanar-elemental beasts. Or maybe pseudo-undeads. Whatever.
Based on that description, I'd tend to agree. In 3e-speak, they should probably be elementals (shadow, extraplanar) or outsider (mists).

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 3:50 pm
by alhoon
An asp that turns victims to undead shadows... should be undead, which incidentally solves a great deal of your problems. Or as Gonzoron suggested, shadow elementals.
As of what the asps eat if not undead, well, they could nest in the tomb and leave it through cracks to hunt outside.

In a sealed tomb, both them and the rats that would feed them would suffocate to death. Also, rats need food and water too you know. :wink: You can't bring rats in your tomb unless there's something the rats feed on.

About shadows getting bored: Ehh... no. They're dead. They have nothing better to do that wait the asps to come out and kill them. Unless of course they can sense life somewhere else.

Another solution to your troubles could be a magical trap (sign, statue, etc) that actually summons those 5d6 shadow asps for 5 mins.

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Thu Mar 03, 2011 4:35 am
by Kadarin
alhoon wrote:In a sealed tomb, both them and the rats that would feed them would suffocate to death. Also, rats need food and water too you know. :wink: You can't bring rats in your tomb unless there's something the rats feed on.
As to the asps: if they are indeed elemental or undead creatures, they do not need to breathe. And for the rats: "sealed" does not necessarily mean "air-tight". Also, rats are survival masters. They'll survive on much lower oxygen levels than humans. (And if any tomb is air-tight, it would be very hard for adventurers to survive without space suits or magical means. Speaking of that, it is not so easy for pre-industrial or non-magical societies to seal any room air-tight.)
The rats could survive on lichen, mosses, or insects.
Or they could be turned into shadow rats.

Re: Shadow asp toubles

Posted: Thu Mar 03, 2011 9:31 am
by alhoon
Kadarin wrote: And for the rats: "sealed" does not necessarily mean "air-tight". Also, rats are survival masters. They'll survive on much lower oxygen levels than humans. (And if any tomb is air-tight, it would be very hard for adventurers to survive without space suits or magical means. Speaking of that, it is not so easy for pre-industrial or non-magical societies to seal any room air-tight.)
The rats could survive on lichen, mosses, or insects.
Or they could be turned into shadow rats.
Actually, no it wasn't difficult at all, even for stone age societies. Just throw clay or tar at the cracks and it's airtight. ;) Egyptians used tar I think.
As for PCs... breaking the stone slab of the door after 200 years of it being sealed with clay or tar requires just a couple of pick axes.
Rats would survive on insects and moss, and insects would survive on moss. Moss would survive on nutriciens from dead insects/rats and the walls.
But an asp needs quite a few rats to survive. And if these rats turn to undead, it will be even harded.

So, my suggestion about making them shadow elementals remains.