Page 1 of 1

Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Wed Jan 05, 2011 11:32 pm
by The_Confessor
So, I'm in the midst of planning my next RL campaign and I have my over-arching story idea - but I'm not sure how to implement it. Basically, instead of the characters having to stand against the will of one (or even some) of the Dark Lords, what if they faced a greater foe? What if they faced the Mists themselves, and the Dark Powers.

Here's my thoughts: The Mists are the physical manifestation of The Dark Powers. The Dark Powers thrive on terror. Not, fear - for fear is natural and in it there is often some hope. I mean pure, hopeless, unreasoning terror. The Dark Powers have come to the belief that it is time to re-write the entire Domains of Dread. Hope has become too strong. The Dark Lords continue to struggle on in hope they might slake their passions and the citizens of Ravenloft struggle on day-to-day in hope of living to see tomorrow. Some are even foolish enough to believe there could be a better tomorrow. The Dark Powers decide this must be stopped.

So, now they seek to usurp the very nature of reality. To re-write the world as a pure hell. How would they choose to do this? How could it be stopped? I have loose ideas. The PCs must make some kind of alliance with several Dark Lords who find the entirety of their domains at stake, for example. The Vistani are agents of the Dark Powers and the Mists, perhaps? They are the primary physical antagonists, even?

Beyond this, I'm kinda at a loss of where to go. I think it's a great concept, but am unsure how to develop it. Does anyone have any ideas or insights?

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 4:04 am
by Manofevil
I've thought about the basic structure of RL quite often and quite indepth. An idea once occurred to me that a possible way for the DPs to do their work would be through the water. The environment of RavenLoft mirrors that of our own planet. No silicon based sulfur breathers here. All the lifeforms are carbon based and all animal life is oxygen breathers and all plant life seems to follow the process of photosynthesis in exactly the same way as it does here, therefore every life form and probably most if not all undead forms must be made up of a certain amount of water. Now suppose the DPs powers were somehow tied to this water at the molecular level. Through the water within the biostructures of the various lifeforms (and unlife forms) of RavenLoft, the DPs can change them in any way they choose. This allows for changes both in people, beasts, plants, and otherwise what might be called dead matter, i e garbage elementals. It's something you might be able to use there.

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:35 am
by ewancummins
The_Confessor wrote:So, I'm in the midst of planning my next RL campaign and I have my over-arching story idea - but I'm not sure how to implement it. Basically, instead of the characters having to stand against the will of one (or even some) of the Dark Lords, what if they faced a greater foe? What if they faced the Mists themselves, and the Dark Powers.

Here's my thoughts: The Mists are the physical manifestation of The Dark Powers. The Dark Powers thrive on terror. Not, fear - for fear is natural and in it there is often some hope. I mean pure, hopeless, unreasoning terror. The Dark Powers have come to the belief that it is time to re-write the entire Domains of Dread. Hope has become too strong. The Dark Lords continue to struggle on in hope they might slake their passions and the citizens of Ravenloft struggle on day-to-day in hope of living to see tomorrow. Some are even foolish enough to believe there could be a better tomorrow. The Dark Powers decide this must be stopped.

So, now they seek to usurp the very nature of reality. To re-write the world as a pure hell. How would they choose to do this? How could it be stopped? I have loose ideas. The PCs must make some kind of alliance with several Dark Lords who find the entirety of their domains at stake, for example. The Vistani are agents of the Dark Powers and the Mists, perhaps? They are the primary physical antagonists, even?

Beyond this, I'm kinda at a loss of where to go. I think it's a great concept, but am unsure how to develop it. Does anyone have any ideas or insights?

If I were a Darkord, I'd simply let the Dark Powers destroy my domain, Then I'd be free. :azalin:

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 10:25 am
by The_Confessor
ewancummins wrote: If I were a Darkord, I'd simply let the Dark Powers destroy my domain, Then I'd be free. :azalin:
Point.

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 11:10 am
by Strahdsbuddy
ewancummins wrote:
If I were a Darkord, I'd simply let the Dark Powers destroy my domain, Then I'd be free. :azalin:
If you were a darklord your hubris would probably not allow for such an option. I do not think the DP have any interest in destroying any part of their creation, particularly the part that imprisons their chosen playthings. I wouldn't think that would ever be their goal.

Not to dismiss The Confessor's idea out of hand--I think it could be effective on a small scale--but I've been troubled by a recent trend to turn Ravenloft into a MORE hellish realm. Take Cavitius for example: an ash-covered wasteland caught up in a constant war against its neighbor and ruled over by an undead demigod with no regard for his human subjects. The ground yields little food, the livestock are undersized, the very air you breathe is caustic (sounds like Mordor). The point is, why fight for it? Any group of heroes would be within their rights to say "To heck with this place, it's hopeless."

Hope is at the core of good horror. Even when you're telling the person in the movie "don't open that door, the killer is inside!" both the character AND you hope it's safe, on some level anyway. Removing hope removes horror, and removing the things that make the realm familiar also removes the reason for heroes to exist.

Even if the DP are evil, I would think they would find heroes entertaining diversions. Strahd was a hero once, but they got to him. I think the way Ravenloft exists now is very much by design: there is enough beauty to make it worth fighting for, and it doesn't take the eradication of an entire city (Azalin's fault, not theirs) to show how precious life is on an individual level. The DP are far more subtle than that.

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 4:30 pm
by ewancummins
Strahdsbuddy wrote:
ewancummins wrote:
If I were a Darkord, I'd simply let the Dark Powers destroy my domain, Then I'd be free. :azalin:
If you were a darklord your hubris would probably not allow for such an option. I do not think the DP have any interest in destroying any part of their creation, particularly the part that imprisons their chosen playthings. I wouldn't think that would ever be their goal.

Not to dismiss The Confessor's idea out of hand--I think it could be effective on a small scale--but I've been troubled by a recent trend to turn Ravenloft into a MORE hellish realm. Take Cavitius for example: an ash-covered wasteland caught up in a constant war against its neighbor and ruled over by an undead demigod with no regard for his human subjects. The ground yields little food, the livestock are undersized, the very air you breathe is caustic (sounds like Mordor). The point is, why fight for it? Any group of heroes would be within their rights to say "To heck with this place, it's hopeless."

Hope is at the core of good horror. Even when you're telling the person in the movie "don't open that door, the killer is inside!" both the character AND you hope it's safe, on some level anyway. Removing hope removes horror, and removing the things that make the realm familiar also removes the reason for heroes to exist.

Even if the DP are evil, I would think they would find heroes entertaining diversions. Strahd was a hero once, but they got to him. I think the way Ravenloft exists now is very much by design: there is enough beauty to make it worth fighting for, and it doesn't take the eradication of an entire city (Azalin's fault, not theirs) to show how precious life is on an individual level. The DP are far more subtle than that.

I'd say that more than a few darklords would willingly see their whole realms destroyed in order to be free of their curses. I mean, what does Hazlik care about Hazlan? He'd love nothing more than to get back to Thay and kill his old enemies in slow, hideous ways. His realm is just a tool. What do the Three Sisters care if Tepest and all it folk are swept into the Mists , if only they could escape their curses and use magic to become young and beautiful once more? Does Tristessa love Keening? Why? Why should Adam or the Doctor care about Lamordia, really? Their goals have nothing to do with the country, everything to do with their own wants and needs. Lord Godefrey is a misanthrope- why should he care if Mordent is destroyed? If it freed him from his wife and daughter's daily attacks, he'd be most pleased! Harkon Lukas isn't really a patriot- he secretly looks down on the folk of his backwoods little realm. He'd love to escape so he could claim power in a real nation, somepalce important like Cormyr. Even Vlad Drakov- why should he care if Falkovnia is destroyed if it frees him to conquer new lands? He's never shown much sign of caring for his subjects, and he is not even a native of the country. Some Darklords might defend their cages- but I don't actually think most would do so.
Most want to get out, to break free, to achieve their goals- that's the point. They are trapped by their curses, curses they brought upon themselves. Hubris might lead them to make big mistakes, but they aren't all so foolish as to not understand that 'losing' their domains means going free.

Strahd, now I could see him trying to keep Barovia and get Tatyana, and failing at both. Azalin, too, would possibly outwit himself again. Most darklords are not like those two, IMO.

YMMV,as always.





I actually agree with you on most of this- but I held back because I didn't want to seem overly critical of Confessor's idea. I, too, am not in favor of a 'hell world.' It seems very un-Ravenloft and not Gothic to me. I also like to keep the Dark Powers mysterious. In my view, they should never make an appearnce, never be fought, need no stat blocks, etc. As far as anyone, even the Darlklords knows, the powers might not even exist. Total mystery- their goals, thoughts, etc are never explained and never ought to be. That was one of the best ideas the TSR writers ever had, IMO.

That being said, it's his campaign. He knows what works for him, and I'm not one to tell him otherwise.

If he wants my advice as one Ravenloft DM to another, I'd say scale it back a notch. There are other 'epic' options for foes. Why not a cabal of pit fiends trapped in the Mists and seeking to return to Hell? They have decided that they can do this- but it will require them to build a bridge of souls to span the Ethereal Plane, connecting Ravenloft to the Prime Plane. From there, they can get back home by more usual means. It's the getting all those souls part that brings them into conflict with the heroes.
Devils can work by subtle means, cross domain boundaries, etc. They have reality bubbles, which the DM can use for all sorts of nastiness. I could easily see heroes siding with a darklord against a devil.

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Fri Jan 07, 2011 12:41 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I wasn't trying to rain all over The Confessor's idea either, only trying to point out what you lose when you go for this whole "Hell on earth" scenario. He is not the first person to bring it up in the last few months, and I'm trying to figure out if there was a movie or something that is inspiring our fellow boardmembers to shred the demiplane in their campaigns! Like I said, on a small scale I think you could get a lot of use out of this idea, even just as a rumor ("Did you hear what happened in Nova Vaasa?")

I guess my own thoughts on the demiplane are what make these suggestions so startling to me. In my mind, the world is actually getting STRONGER, it is congealing in a way that was only hinted at when the setting was first released. Untractable mist is being replaced by navigable seas; Islands of terror are forming clusters, then continents. It is becoming a REAL world. My Time of Unparalleled Darkness is really the culmination of this process and the judgment of whether the world will be allowed to exist, or be smashed into oblivion by cosmic powers.

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Fri Jan 07, 2011 1:07 pm
by The_Confessor
Don't worry about attacking my idea. I was uncertain of it and that's why I post it here. You've all made fantastic points and have thought to restructure my idea. Please, criticism is good.

Re: Legacy of the Mists: A Campaign Seed

Posted: Fri Jan 07, 2011 11:00 pm
by ewancummins
The_Confessor wrote:Don't worry about attacking my idea. I was uncertain of it and that's why I post it here. You've all made fantastic points and have thought to restructure my idea. Please, criticism is good.
Cool beans.

If my feedback has been helpful, then I'm glad of it.