Page 1 of 1

Proposed Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (dread & non-dread)

Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2011 7:09 pm
by cure
EDIT: Please skip down to the bottom of this page to see my post with the new and better stats, now proposed for both the magically created and the dark desired created flesh golem.

- - -

As discussed recently, the Denizen of Dread Golems are troubled, to not say borked. How about the following then as the corrected, standard, magically animated flesh golem in Ravenloft?

Flesh Golem (Ravenloft)

12d10+30

Initiative +2

Speed: 30ft

AC 23 (-1 size, +2 Dex, +12 natural), touch 11, flat-footed 21

Base Attack/Grapple: +9/+18 [+9+5+4]

Attack: Slam +13 [+9-1+5] (2d8+5)

Full Attack: 2 Slam: +13 [+9-1+5] (2d8+5)

Space/Reach 10 ft./ 10 ft.
Special Attacks: besrerk, constrict

Special Qualities: Construct traits, darkvision 60 ft, low-light vision, damage reduction 5/adamantine or magic, regeneration, immunity to magic, immunity to disease, poison, level drains and gases, vulnerability to fire and acid.

Fort +4 [?]/ Ref +6/ Will +4 [?]

Str 21, Dex 14, Con Ø, Int Ø, Wis 11, Cha 1

Skills: none

Feats: none

Challenge Rating: 10 (14 using Challenging Challenge Ratings version 5 at http://www.enworld.org/forum/2289968-post42.html)

Alignment: Neutral

Note: -4 penalty to Hide checks

- - - Elements - - -
Base Ability Scores: 11 Str, 11 Dex, 10 Con, 10 Int, 11 Wis, 10 Cha

Large: +8 Str, -2 Dex, +4 Con, +2 Natural Armour, -1
AC/Attack Bonus

Large: +4 Grapple, -4 Hide

Racial Adjustments: +2 Str, +2 Dex, Ø Con, Ø Int, Wis 0, Cha -9.

Ability Score Increases: +3 Dex

- - - Comments - - -

I am not an expert at this. Corrections, improvements, and comments generally are wanted.

I followed the existing statistics as much as possible.

The racial adjustments and three ability point increases into dexterity are debatable. Both were arbitrarily decided as part of backing out the numbers.

Fortitude and Will saves were given without modification for having no Constitution and Intelligence. Is this correct?

The Challenge Rating was ultimately worked out by using Challenging Challenge Ratings to determine the difference between a MM 9HD flesh golem and one improved to 12 HD and then from there to one with the traits of its Ravenloft cousin.

Does anyone have any idea how to calculate the XP required for a spellcaster to make a construct. Comparing with existing constructs is a tedious and unscientific process at best.

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2011 11:02 pm
by cure
Proposed creation conditions:

Subzero conditions, the spell Gentle Repose, or other means of preserving body parts.

XP 1640 (which is more than a 11 HD, CR 10 clay golem and less than a 12 HD, CR 10 sentient brain golem)

21,000 gp of which 500 gp is for the fitting out of a reusable workshop with appropriate tools. Hence the next time around the price drops to 20,500 gp. The "market price", for the heck of it, is 41,000 gp.

The construction of the body itself costs a scant 200 gp. (This 200gp, the fitted workshop, and the cold conditions would be all the expense that a maker of a flesh golem of obsession would have to meet. And were that maker a mortician, for example, he would be presumed to already have fitted out workshop.)

Spells: animate dead, bull’s strength, geas/quest, limited wish

Caster Level 9th (prior to reaching the 13th level good luck with the task of finding or buying a scroll with limited wish however)

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2011 12:29 am
by alhoon
cure wrote:Proposed creation conditions:

Subzero conditions, the spell Gentle Repose, or other means of preserving body parts.

XP 1640 (which is more than a 11 HD, CR 10 clay golem and less than a 12 HD, CR 10 sentient brain golem)

21,000 gp of which 500 gp is for the fitting out of a reusable workshop with appropriate tools. Hence the next time around the price drops to 20,500 gp. The "market price", for the heck of it, is 41,000 gp.

The construction of the body itself costs a scant 200 gp. (This 200gp, the fitted workshop, and the cold conditions would be all the expense that a maker of a flesh golem of obsession would have to meet. And were that maker a mortician, for example, he would be presumed to already have fitted out workshop.)

Spells: animate dead, bull’s strength, geas/quest, limited wish

Caster Level 9th (prior to reaching the 13th level good luck with the task of finding or buying a scroll with limited wish however)
Agree on:
Stats, cost, level requirement

Disagree with:
Spells needed, XP cost, CR, racial adjustments.

Suggestions:
- Spells needed: Exactly. There's no chance in heavens that a 9th lvl caster would find a scroll of limited wish. My sister has an 18th lvl wizard in a fantasy homebrew world and she doesn't sell those.
When she was 10th or 11th lvl, she made a quest to find one such scroll. Taking it from the dead hands of an evil wizard after consulting divinations, greater divinations, following rumors etc.
I would suggest simply dropping the limited wish spell altogether. That way even clerics will be able to construct that golem.

- CR: Compare the golem suggested with the fire giant (CR 10 monster). Nope, doesn't cut it. :) Compare the golem with a hill giant: less hp, more AC, less hit roll, less damage, no brain/creativity, no healing capabilities, chance to go berserk. Nope, doesn't make it either.
The golem as you made it (Without any special abilities) should be CR 6 IMO. With a couple of abilities and qualities (like DR 5/-), it should be CR 7 IMO.
About the CR 14 suggestion: :? So, according to some suggestions in enworld, a single monster with no special abilities, about 100 hp, 23 AC, 2 attacks with +13 hr that deal on average 14 damage/hit = about as tough as 3 cloud giants together?

- Racial adjustments: I disagree with the +2 dex altogether. The idea of a stiff moving Frankestein in my mind. I would suggest a -4 dex, with the level bonuses +1 to dex +2 to strength.

- XP cost: 1640 XP is waaay to much for this IMO. 1640 XP is the XP required for a greatsword+3, an armor +3 and a cloak that gives +3 to saves, with bracers that give +2 to strength. That incidentally is good equipment for a 10th+ level fighter.
Most constructs I've seen (and that I agree with their XP cost :roll: ) have XP cost about 1/50 to their construction price.
21000/50 = 420. Oooops too low. Let's go for "market" price/50 = 840 XP. Better. :)

PS, wildly off topic: Today is 11/1/11. 5 1's in row. :)

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2011 2:29 am
by cure
alhoon wrote: Agree on:
Stats, cost, level requirement

Disagree with:
Spells needed, XP cost, CR, racial adjustments.

Suggestions:
- Spells needed: Exactly. There's no chance in heavens that a 9th lvl caster would find a scroll of limited wish. My sister has an 18th lvl wizard in a fantasy homebrew world and she doesn't sell those.
When she was 10th or 11th lvl, she made a quest to find one such scroll. Taking it from the dead hands of an evil wizard after consulting divinations, greater divinations, following rumors etc.
I would suggest simply dropping the limited wish spell altogether. That way even clerics will be able to construct that golem.

- CR: Compare the golem suggested with the fire giant (CR 10 monster). Nope, doesn't cut it. :) Compare the golem with a hill giant: less hp, more AC, less hit roll, less damage, no brain/creativity, no healing capabilities, chance to go berserk. Nope, doesn't make it either.
The golem as you made it (Without any special abilities) should be CR 6 IMO. With a couple of abilities and qualities (like DR 5/-), it should be CR 7 IMO.
About the CR 14 suggestion: :? So, according to some suggestions in enworld, a single monster with no special abilities, about 100 hp, 23 AC, 2 attacks with +13 hr that deal on average 14 damage/hit = about as tough as 3 cloud giants together?

- Racial adjustments: I disagree with the +2 dex altogether. The idea of a stiff moving Frankestein in my mind. I would suggest a -4 dex, with the level bonuses +1 to dex +2 to strength.

- XP cost: 1640 XP is waaay to much for this IMO. 1640 XP is the XP required for a greatsword+3, an armor +3 and a cloak that gives +3 to saves, with bracers that give +2 to strength. That incidentally is good equipment for a 10th+ level fighter.
Most constructs I've seen (and that I agree with their XP cost :roll: ) have XP cost about 1/50 to their construction price.
21000/50 = 420. Oooops too low. Let's go for "market" price/50 = 840 XP. Better. :)
I am not married to the idea of a dexterous flesh golem in Ravenloft. Adam, thanks to the genius of Mordenheim, can be the exception that proves the rule. That being said, I was trying to follow the numbers as given when they weren't demonstrably wrong. But if we are going to put things right, addressing the dexterity matter is on the table. What do others think?

The XP matter has frustrated me for a couple days during which I established that, to the best of my knowledge, there are no official guidelines for calculating the XP of a golem. I looked at existing constructs, especially golems, and went from there. I have a spreadsheet with the HD, CR, XP, cost, and market price for 16 constructs and 30 golems. Ultimately, the golem information is relevent and probably more consistent.

What I found is, at least, interesting. With the exception of the brass golem which simply confuses me and the sand golem which seems to be simply wrong, everything else is captured by a pair of formulae:

Market Price: XP * 25gp + special ingredient cost

Cost: XP / 2 x 25gp + special ingredient cost + reusables cost

(For example the MM Clay Golem:

1540 XP / 2 x 25 gp + 1,500 gp "miraculous clay" + 750 gp reusable stuff = 21,500 gp cost

1540 XP 2 x 25 gp + 1,500 gp "miraculous clay" = 40,000 gp cost)

Ususually the special ingredient costs, if any, are given and the reusable costs, if any, are given, especially as the source material get more recent. Sometimes they must be derived to make the given XP, cost, and market price square, but they do always come out as perfectly reasonable numbers for the golems and usually perfectly reasonable numbers for the constructs. So there is at least a smattering of consistency at Wizards.

So the 1640 XP, 21,000 gp cost, 500 gp reusables, and 41,000 gp are correct to the degree that they obey the formulae in use.

Equally, I think that they fit reasonably within the spread of existing golem XP/prices.

But none of that is to say that those existing prices are fair and balanced, or even well thought up to begin with. And honestly, I don't have an opinion on that either way. One interesting opinion voiced on the matter, however, suggested that golems were grossly overpriced so that players wouldn't have them. But of course if NPC's can have whatever they want, why bother writing up wealth rules for them? Honestly, I have no idea what to do in this respect. What do others think?

As for the the CR, I have no talent for challenge ratings but have tried to educate myself in the last couple of days.

I figured yanking off the intelligence score should be good for a subtraction of at least 1 from the existing CR 11.

I looked at the SRD and tried to figure out the CR that would result from an improvement of the 7 CR, 9HD MM golem to 12HD and then with added features from the Ravenloft flesh golem. As I recall, that was good for 2 or 3 CR.

Then I did it again using the stuff from the Challenging Challenge Ratings document. That document tries, supposedly, to create parity and in doing so alters CR across much of the board. For example, the MM flesh golem goes from CR 7 to CR 11 and the clould giant goes from CR 11 to CR 19. I have no idea whether this ultimately yields greater parity or not. I was interested, however, in the change in CR from the 9th level MM flesh golem to a 12th level one and from a 12th level one to a Ravenloft 12th level one. And that coughed up an increase of 3 CR.

Hence, CR 10 kept coming up and I went with it. So there is method in the madness, but the method could well be wrong. And I consider myself the least well placed to say. What do others think?

I don't have a strong opinion either way on the spells. They are straight from the MM flesh golem, although limited wish is pretty standard stuff. Well, thinking about it, something to do with electricity has to be used. And opening it up to clerics makes sense . . . or does it . . . .

As for the caster level, I do actually think it is silly to have caster levels for golems, or magic items, below the level required to cast the spells used in their making. Yet this is what Wizards does, at least some of the time, particularly for "low end" golems. I picked the caster level by arbitrarily increasing it by one over the level required for a MM 9 HD, CR 7 flesh golem. I actually took this matter up with Rotipher in respect to the skeletal golem the other day and she disagrees with me. The case, however, seems particularly egregious in Ravenloft once a wish, even if limited, gets involved. I would be infavour of simply trashing the caster level. What do others think?

I am not trying to reinvent the wheel here, but I would be in favour of standardising in the direction of something that is accessible and easy. As I recall, Pathfinder has not, sadly, fiddled with CR's. And indeed they seem to have dropped XP for golem making.

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2011 8:15 am
by alhoon
Clay golems cost 21K now? Gee... it seems 3.5 fixed the golem construction prices then.
EDIT: Checked them. It seems Clay golem is a bit cheap for my tastes (and it's usability and powr) and Iron golem a bit too expensive but they seem far better priced than in 3rd.

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2011 9:21 am
by cure
Your mention of 50 gp just solved the pricing of the sand golem. It is the one golem and construct I have found that doesn't fit the formulae given above. Instead it use these:

Market Price: XP * 50 gp + special ingredient cost

Cost: XP / 2 x 50 gp + special ingredient cost + reusables cost

Hence:

920 XP / 2 x 50 gp + 4,000 gp special sand = 27,000 gp cost

920 XP x 50 gp + 4,000 gp special sand = 50,000 gp market price

Unfortunately 920 XP, places the 18 HD, CR 12, huge monstrocity at the same level as a 7 HD, CR 8, medium Thayan golem. And 50,000 gp put it at the same leve as a large 12 HD, CR 10 brain golem. So it is an error.

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2011 9:42 pm
by Joël of the FoS
(keeps an eye on cure, thinks he might be building an errata golem from all this new obsession on the topic)

;)

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 8:48 am
by HuManBing
An "errata golem", you say?

Is that when the creator wasn't being careful enough and accidentally created a golem without intending to?

Basically, an unwanted golem.

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 12:56 pm
by cure
A mist golem might be closer to a true errata golem.

Re: Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (magically animated)

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 10:09 pm
by cure
A second and better kick at the can follows. Indeed, there is both the magically created and the dark desire created flesh golems, all based on a far sounder foundation and informed by criticism offered above. Please take a look and see if it can be improved further.

- - -

The base flesh golem in the Land of Mists, denoted hereafter as the eldritch flesh golem, is animated by magic spells, without the assistance of the Dark Powers. It differs from the SRD flesh golem in three respects: it may be recovered from its beserk state; it has a minimal form of the regeneration extraordinary ability; and the conditions of its animation have been revised to be more gothic.

Eldritch Flesh Golem

9d10+30 (79 hp)

Initiative: -1

Speed: 30ft

AC 18 (-1 size, -1 Dex, +10 natural), touch 8, flat-footed 18

Base Attack/Grapple: +6/+15

Attack: Slam +10 (2d8+5)

Full Attack: 2 Slam: +10 (2d8+5)

Space/Reach 10 ft./ 10 ft.

Special Attacks: beserk

Special Qualities: Construct traits, low-light vision, darkvision 60 ft, damage reduction 5/adamantine, regeneration, immunity to magic.

Fort +3 / Ref +2 / Will +3

Str 21, Dex 9, Con Ø, Int Ø, Wis 11, Cha 1

OR: 7

Skills: none

(Note that an eldritch flesh golem suffers a -4 penalty on Hide checks due to size.)

(As a mindless creature, an eldritch flesh golem rarely, if ever, makes use of skills impacted by its outcast rating.)

Feats: none

Challenge Rating: 7

Alignment: Neutral


Combat
Berserk (Ex): see DD/DDr

Magical Immunity (Ex): see SRD

Regeneration (Ex): The creature regenerates all types of damage but at the very slow rate of 1 hit point per hour. The creature cannot regrow a lost body part, but it can reattach one by holding it in place for at least an hour. Should the creature be damaged to the point of having a negative number of hit points, it is reduced to a state of inanimacy and ceases to regenerate. Its repair remains possible by an individual with the craft construct feat, at a cost of 50 gp per hit point of damage repaired and at a rate of 20 hit points of damage repaired per day. Once it has not less than 0 hit poits, a jolt of electricity with the strength to do at least 48 points of damage reanimates it and it begins once more to regenerate any damage that it has suffered.


Creation
Minimum of six donor bodies, each furnishing one of the following: brain, torso (including head), limb (4).

Either subzero conditions, or the gentle repose spell, or some other means of preserving body parts.

Craft Construct Feat

DC 13 Craft (leatherworking) check or DC 13 Heal check for the assemblage of the body.

10,750 gp of which 500 gp is for fitting out a workshop with appropriate tools and 500 gp is for electrical equipment. The workshop, tools, and electrical equipment may be reused and reduce the cost of making subsequent flesh golems by 1000 gp. The cost of the electrical equipment is waved given access to a spell that can apply directly to the body an electrical shock in the required strength (see below). The construction of the body itself consumes 200 gp. The market price for the creature would be 20,000 gp.

CL 8th

Spells: bull’s strength, bone seizure, soul anchor

XP 800

A jolt of electricity with the strength to do at least 48 points of damage.

- - -

The dread flesh golem is animated with the assistance of the Dark Powers. Although the dread flesh golem differs vastly from the eldritch flesh golem in its capacities and in its creation, the eldritch flesh golem serves as the base creature from which the dread flesh golem is derived by the application of the dread golem template.

Dread Flesh Golem
9d10+30 (79 hp)

Initiative: +1

Speed: 30ft

AC 24 (-1 size, +1 Dex, +14 natural), 10 touch , 23 flat-footed

Base Attack/Grapple: +6/+15

Attack: Slam +10 (3d8+5)

Full Attack: 2 Slam: +10 (3d8+5)

Space/Reach 10 ft./ 10 ft.

Special Attacks: beserk

Special Qualities: Construct traits, low-light vision, darkvision 60 ft, damage reduction 5/adamantine, regeneration, immunity to magic.

Fort +3 / Ref +4 / Will +3

Str 21, Dex 13, Con Ø, Int 9, Wis 11, Cha 5

OR: 7

Skills: Bluff -10, Climb +5, Diplomacy -10, Gather Information -10, Hide +0, Intimidate +4, Jump +6, Listen +2, Move Silently +2, Perform -10, Spot +2, Swim +5

(9 Skill Points (2 + Int mod per HD (SRD))

(Class Skills: Climb, Hide, Jump, Listen, Move Silently, Spot, Swim)

(A dread flesh golem suffers a -4 penalty on its Hide checks due to size.)

Feats: Improved Natural Attack, Power Attack, Cleave, Great Cleave

(4 feats (Feats equal to 1 + 1 per 3 Hit Dice (SRD))

(Note that other feats may be substituted according either to the taste of the dread golem's maker or to the twist that the Dark Powers wish to apply to that taste.)

Challenge Rating: 8

Alignment: Chaotic Evil (usually)

Salient Powers
A dread flesh golem has 1d4-1 salient powers. See RSC or the RLPH.

Zeitgebers
A dread flesh golem typically has at least one zeitgeber. See RSC or the RLPH.


Combat
Berserk (Ex): see DD/DDr

Magical Immunity (Ex): see SRD

Regeneration (Ex): The creature regenerates all types of damage but at the very slow rate of 1 hit point per hour. The creature cannot regrow a lost body part, but it can reattach one by holding it in place for at least an hour. Should the creature be damaged to the point of having a negative number of hit points, it is reduced to a state of inanimacy and ceases to regenerate. Its repair remains possible by either its maker or by an individual with the craft construct feat, at a cost of 50 gp per hit point of damage repaired and at a rate of 20 hit points of damage repaired per day. Once it has not less than 0 hit poits, a jolt of electricity with the strength to do at least 8 points of damage reanimates it and it begins once more to regenerate any damage that it has suffered. Note that a construct with the salient power of regeneration receives benefits and acquires disadvantages that supercede those described here. Or in other term, the salient power of regeneration 5 replaces rather than stacks with the power of regeneration described here.


Creation
Minimum of six donor bodies, each furnishing one of the following: brain, torso (including head), limb (4).

Subzero conditions, the gentle repose spell, or other means of preserving body parts.

DC 13 Craft (leatherworking) check or DC 13 Heal check for the assemblage of the body.

500 gp is for fitting out a workshop with appropriate tools. This cost is waved for a surgeon, a veterinarian, a mortician, a taxidermist, a leatherworker, or the like, with access to his or her own existing facility and tools.

500 gp is for electrical equipment.

Note that the workshop, tools, and electrical equipment may be reused and reduce the cost of making subsequent dread flesh golems by 1000 gp.

200 gp is for the construction of the body itself.

A jolt of electricity with the strength to do at least 8 points of damage.

The blessing of the Dark Powers.


Creation Option
Certain characteristics of a Dread Flesh Golem are dependent upon those of the NPC whose brain it was given.

To determine the creature's intelligence score take that of the deceased NPC and apply a -1d2 penalty.

Any penalties applied to the NPC's intelligence, wisdom or charisma scores resulting from failed madness checks also apply to the creature and are permanent. Should an ability score of 0 or less result, the creature cannot be successfully animated using the given brain. A healthier brain must be substituted and electricity must be reapplied. Any madness conditions under which the NPC was labouring at the time of his or her death are assumed by the creature and are permanent. An NPC who was, for example, delusional results in a creature that is delusional.

- - -

BEHIND THE CURTAIN
Rather than trying to work backwards from a troubled golem in DD and DDr, this time I built the creature from ground up, being guided by the DD and DDr, but using the SRD, the Dread Golem Template (RSC & RLPH), the Dread Golem Template update in Gaz II, and criticism offered above.

Given that Adam is not a 12 HD dread flesh golem, but rather a 10 HD dread flesh golem, there was little point of trying to save the 12 HD version, and instead I took the SRD 9 HD version, concluding that Adam was improved by 1 HD by Mordenheim's genius. Adam would also have an elite array of ability scores or some such ability score upgrade over other dread flesh golems.

The eldritch flesh golem, which is to say the magically created flesh golem, is not a particularly dexterous creature.

The more dexterous and more charismatic creature that we are familiar with is generated with the dread flesh golem template that adds +4 dex and +4 cha, in addition to adding a 9 intelligence score.


- - -

Thoughts? Improvements? Criticism?

Re: Proposed Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (dread & non-dread)

Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2011 5:23 pm
by alhoon
The dread flesh golem seems OK, but although it seems the average damage is OK, I think the 3d8 is too much for a slam. How about str to 22 and 2d8 +9 damage (almost same damage, less dice)? Remember that when the creature doesn't have another attack, slam gets x1.5 str bonus.

As for CR, it seems quite good. A stone giant has as much and he's as much trouble.

Re: Proposed Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (dread & non-dread)

Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2011 7:43 pm
by cure
alhoon wrote:The dread flesh golem seems OK, but although it seems the average damage is OK, I think the 3d8 is too much for a slam. How about str to 22 and 2d8 +9 damage (almost same damage, less dice)? Remember that when the creature doesn't have another attack, slam gets x1.5 str bonus.

As for CR, it seems quite good. A stone giant has as much and he's as much trouble.
The 3d8, as opposed to the 2d8, comes from the Improved Natural Attack feat. Not every dread flesh golem is going to be optimised by it maker and/or the Dark Powers for fighting, but given four feats it is both a legitimate and conceivable choice, even if a limit was placed on how many of the feats may be combat feats. I don't see how it can be reasonably ruled out. Nor does it have to be ruled out since other feats may be freely substituted for it according to taste.

(When picking feats how does one pick representative ones? The Spring Attack series would yield a lithe creature quite like Adam, but not everyone wants a golem like that. And I am not sure that a golem with a whole bunch of perception feats fits the bill either. So I went with feats that underline its frightful power beyond that even of its sheer strength. This creature, once it realises it combat prowess, would wade though a enraged mob with terrifying ease, the great cleave feat incombination with the improved natural attack feat effectively affording it 4 atttacks per round.)

I am less than certain how to apply the x1.5 str bonus to monsters. These golems have two slam attacks given a full round. Both slams are made at the creature's full attack score, right? The second slam attack is not a secondary attack, right? So the x1.5 strength applies to all their slam attacks, right? With the consequence that for the eldritch flesh golem the numbers should be 2d8+7 for damage and for the dread flesh golem 3d8+7 for damage? But if so, the SRD has failed to make the same adjustment to the statistics that it gives to the flesh golem.

Re: Proposed Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (dread & non-dread)

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 4:49 pm
by cure
alhoon wrote:Remember that when the creature doesn't have another attack, slam gets x1.5 str bonus.
From the SRD:

"If the creature uses a two-handed weapon or has a single natural weapon, it adds 1½ times its Strength bonus to the damage. If it has more than a single attack then it adds its Strength bonus to damage rolls for the primary attack and ½ its Strength bonus to all secondary attacks. "

The above is not especially clear as written, but looking at a few examples in the SRD such as the Aboleth, the golem neither gets a 1 1/2 damage bonus on either or both of its slam attacks, nor does it get only 1/2 damage on the second of its slam attacks. It has no secondary form of attack, hence no 1/2 damage bonus, but has more than a single attack, hence no 1 1/2 damaage bonus. I am willing to be persuaded otherwise, but this squares with the numbers in the SRD for multiple creatures.

Re: Proposed Ravenloft Flesh Golem Stats (dread & non-dread)

Posted: Sun Mar 13, 2011 12:42 am
by cure
"A creature must have a Constitution score to have the regeneration ability."

So fast healing will have to be substituted.