Page 1 of 2

Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 12:16 am
by The_Confessor
OK, so I'm a few sessions into my latest RL Campaign and reviewing my material. Amongst this is Van Richten's Guide to the Mists. Now, the general opinion I get is that this book was not well received as it gave the Mists a rather definable quality and basically made them "too concrete."

My question lay in this: Is VRGttM considered canon? As a secondary question, just to get things straight from the horse's mouth, what did you guys think of it?

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 1:25 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
From what I recall, it was actually received rather well. Some people didn't like the idea of its existence, but from what I recall, most (including myself) felt that the authors did a pretty good job with a difficult subject, making the mists more interesting, without making them too well explained.

As for its canonicity, it's debatable, but I'd probably call it "potential canon" for the most part, although there is the issue of Salizar, whose existence as one of the fugued contradicts his appearance in Gaz II. This was an oversight, admitted to by Rucht Lilavivat in his author's notes, which would have likely been corrected in the final product.

The "controversial" aspects of it mainly seemed to be:
- the oubliette concept (though the possibility of a darklord-less area in Ravenloft dates back to the Black Box)
- the darkening of the character of the Twins
- the redundancy between the Fuged and the Bogeymen from DT&DL.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 4:50 am
by alhoon
I liked it, but I'm against the existance of Oubliettes. If in a place in Ravenloft you can't find the darklord, that's because he/she/it is hidden, not because he/she/it is nonexistant. Take that Japanese domain for for example, with the darklord being a geist unable to do anything but see his empire collapse, or Har Akir with Ankhepot :ankhtepot: steering in his sleep just rarely or Lamordia with a lone flesh golem brooding hidden far far away.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 6:58 am
by cure
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: - the oubliette concept (though the possibility of a darklord-less area in Ravenloft dates back to the Black Box)
Could you please refresh my memory in respect to the Black Box "oubliette" appearance? Thanx.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 7:00 am
by cure
Some of the issues were "slips of the pen" that would have presumably been caught in editing. For example one of the Twins using vivisection rather than dissection.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 7:35 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Take Sri Raji for for example, with the darklord being a geist unable to do anything
I think you mean Rokushima Taiyoo. It's a valid point, but I just see it as a glimpse into the way the DP's "work". Maybe oubliettes are there in preparation for a darklord that they have their eye on. Or maybe it takes time for a domain to decay after a darklord dies. It's like a glimpse at the set storage department backstage at the "Ravenloft playhouse." YMMV, of course.
Could you please refresh my memory in respect to the Black Box "oubliette" appearance? Thanx.
In the Black Box, the identity of the darklord(s) of the Nightmare Lands wasn't decided/revealed yet, and one of the "theories" listed was that such a chaotic place might not have a darklord. This theory was listed out of character, not in character, so it's not a case of a fallible narrator.

Also, there are small strips of land on the black box map that fall outside of any known domain. These have never been addressed in official text, but have been noticed by fans.

Then of course there's the glaring exception to the darklord rule that the mists themselves have no darklord, nor do mistways (mistways were added later of course, but anyone who travels the Mists spends time outside of the influence of any darklord.)

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 9:42 am
by alhoon
Mists aren't domains, nor paths IMO. They're... the mists.

PS. What's "YMMV"?

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 11:09 am
by Resonant Curse
I don't know how well people on here really received the newer Ravenloft fiction, but you can also look at Malosia from Black Crusade as an example of a domain that (until the end) doesn't have a darklord. So some of the oubliettes might be similar "protodomains."

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 12:25 pm
by The Lesser Evil
alhoon wrote:Mists aren't domains, nor paths IMO. They're... the mists.

PS. What's "YMMV"?
Your Mileage May Vary.

Pocket domains (particularly floating pockets) are another possible example. The Rod of Security technically creates something of a pocket domain that waits for a suitable darklord to appear. The House of Lament really doesn't have a darklord as is, and neither really did the Pre-4e Winding Road.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Tue Feb 01, 2011 12:29 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Mists aren't domains, nor paths IMO. They're... the mists.
Agreed, they aren't domains, but they are a "darklord-less area" in a sense. The question of course is are they truly an "area", or just an amorphous non-space that just feels like you're walking through mist?
PS. What's "YMMV"?
"You're mileage may vary." Not sure if that phrase is an Americanism or not. Basically: "This is my view, but it may or may not work for others."

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Wed Feb 02, 2011 1:39 pm
by Don Fernando
Sorry for the following question, but I've been away for too long, so maybe I'm just stuck in the past :oops: ..... Sri Raji is now ruled by a Geist??

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Wed Feb 02, 2011 1:53 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
No, it's not, that was an error. Rokushima Taiyoo's Darklord is a geist, Sri Raji's is a Rakshasha - or possibly a half-Rakshasa? I'm not sure whether having the father of the Rakshasas god cancels out the fact that his mother was human or not.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Fri Feb 04, 2011 7:43 am
by Don Fernando
Oh glad to hear it. It's been quite a long time since I visited the forum. Thanks for the answer!

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 1:32 am
by Bluebomber4evr
I don't know, I kind of prefer VRG: the Mists' version of Salizarr to the version in Gaz II, personally.

Re: Regarding Van Richten's Guide to the Mists

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 8:52 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Bluebomber4evr wrote:I don't know, I kind of prefer VRG: the Mists' version of Salizarr to the version in Gaz II, personally.
It is quite a bit more developed, though I'm not how well it jibes with his original character. Haven't gone back and read that one in a while. I do like the VRG:tM Salizar, but part of writing for a shared world is making it all work together... It would have been a shame to lose the character entirely, but I'm confident Rucht et al. could've found a way to make it work, either adding to his story to make both aspects work or replacing the source creature with someone else...