Page 1 of 1

Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 9:24 am
by cure
I thought that I might get some insight into Ravenloft flesh golem stats by looking at Adam. The stats given in the Ravenloft 3ed & 3.5ed monster manual are troubled.

So far this has yielded a curious puzzle, a question, and a pair of errata.

First, Adam has 14 HD with 4 of these being attributable to 4 levels of fighter. That implies that the base Ravenloft flesh golem has 10 HD. But the base Ravenloft flesh golem according to the Ravenloft monster manuals has 12 HD and the generic flesh golem according to the SRD has 9 HD. Thoughts on where 10 HD comes from and its significance, if any, for flesh golems in Ravenloft?

Second, it is stated that Adam can't run. Neither the Ravenloft monster manuals nor the SRD mention that golems cannot run, although I have seen this suggested before here and there. Curiously, the Dread Golem template from the RLPHB states that dread golems, of which Adam is one, can run, regardless of lack in this respect of the base construct. So, can or cannot golems run? And, in any case, isn't Gaz II wrong on Adam? Or is RLPHB wrong?

Third, Adam is missing the +30 hit points that flesh golems of his size receive according to the Ravenloft errata, and himself should be errata to 107 hp (14 HD * 5.5 +30).

Fourth, Adam is miss three to five feats. He should, using Savage Species, have 5 feats from HD/Lvls and 3 from being a fighter. Alternatively, he should, using the updated Dread Golem template in Gaz II p. 120, have 2 feats from HD, 3 from being a fighter, and perhaps 1 or 2 more for advancing 4 levels in a class. (PS Should Savage Species trump Gaz II in respects to feats as the former is 3.5ed the latter is 3ed?)

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 8:14 pm
by Catman Jim
The stats from GAZ II, page 154 says "can run", not "can't run". It further states that Adam is "swift and nimble".

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 9:42 pm
by cure
Opps.

The question, however, remains still in play. For explicitly noting that Adam can run and having the template specify that dread constructs can run, implies that constructs, or at least some constructs, cannot run. Where does that appear in canon?

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 10:44 pm
by Catman Jim
Sounds like a Edition legacy: 1st Edition AD&D Monster Manual and 2nd Edition Monstrous Compendium give flesh golems a Movement of 8, and states "moves with a stiff gait, as if it is not in complete control of it's body parts". 3rd Edition states the same, and lists a movement of 30. 4th Edition has Movement 6 (+2 on Rampage), and the qualifier "can't shift".
Van Richten's Guide to the Created gave Flesh Golems a movement of 12, and gives high dexterity, with the comment that they could be "as fast or faster than the most dexterous of my companions".
Denizens of Dread gives them a Movement of 30, and states that they are "not known for their swiftness or efficiency in battle".

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2011 4:07 am
by Mangrum
cure wrote:For explicitly noting that Adam can run and having the template specify that dread constructs can run, implies that constructs, or at least some constructs, cannot run. Where does that appear in canon?
The 3.0 Monster Manual.

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2011 7:14 am
by Catman Jim
Mangrum wrote:The 3.0 Monster Manual.
OK, I see it now, page 108 in the 3.0 MM, "can't run", it was changed in the 3.5 version.

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2011 7:55 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
And since Gaz II was a 3.0 product (I think III or IV was the first Gaz to switch to 3.5, IIRC) it makes sense. Thanks for settling it, Mangrum.

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2011 6:01 pm
by Mangrum
Gaz IV was the first entry in the series published as 3.5. It's not, really, but there's marketing for ya. Gaz V was the first (and only) entry that was written by authors who got to see the 3.5 rules before writing the book.

In 3.0, particularly early on, the rules and intended design philosophy were quite clear that creatures without Constitution scores couldn't do (or subject to) anything that required Con checks, which included running.

Re: Adam, can he run (and other stats issues)?

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2011 8:07 pm
by cure
Thanx John for the clarifications. In particular, I entered the edition information for the Gazetteers into the Mistipedia as I have often tried to reconstruct that via the publication dates, but now we have the definitive answer.