Page 1 of 2

Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2011 2:23 pm
by BedrockBrendan
I am just curious how others approach adventure design in Ravenloft. Normally I start with the villain and other major characters, because I find it gives me a foundation solid enough to handle a variety of player actions and reactions. After characters I think about possible broad strokes (i.e. villain asks players to retrieve X from the forest of shadows), and interesting encounters I can work in. I also contemplate the potential conflicts that could arise through player actions.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2011 2:52 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I take more of a macro/sandbox view. I decide what domain I'd like to use, then read everything I can on it in an effort to fully flesh out the setting, then I just turn my players loose. This is easier to do with some domains (Mordent) than with others (Bluetspur) but i find it lets the players feel like they are in control, and that their decisions are driving the campaign. Obviously, I let their reputation determine people's reactions to them. Does the lord in his tower consider them to be troublesome do-gooders, or useful pawns? Do townsfolk look at them as heroes or as glory-seekers that bring unwanted attention to their hamlet? Modules like The Evil Eye are sort of my basis, since there are a lot of things to do, yet not even half of them are central to the story...but they can all send the PCs in varying directions.

That said, I think your method has merit, and it is probably the way most modules are designed. Ravenlot is a place to showcase villains as fleshed out characters, and deciding who you want pulling the strings early is a good idea.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2011 5:17 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I have two methods, which I try to synergize. One is that I periodically get some kind of Ravenloft obsession--doppelgangers, Kartakass, Hazlan, the Fraternity of Shadows--and I spend a lot of time thinking about that thing and fleshing it out. And then, of course, I want to use all of my wonderful new material, so I look for ways to build it into a campaign.

The other is basically "set pieces"--I have an idea for a scene or event that I think would be awesome, and I try to figure out how to put the PCs in that position. I ran a (non-Ravenloft) campaign that started with the PCs being convicted of various crimes and forced to fight in gladiatorial games; they're shoved into the arena together as cannon fodder, they work together and score an unexpected triumph, and thus begins the campaign.

You can see both at work in the "Evening with the Fraternity" campaign; obviously, the obsession there is the Fraternity of Shadows, although doppelgangers also play a role; and there's a longish interaction with Chicken Bone, because I reaaaaaallly wanted to have a "Chicken Bone scene".

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2011 11:14 pm
by BedrockBrendan
Thanks for the feedback.

Strahd'sBuddy: I love sandbox style play. I use it all the time in my modern (mostly mafia) campaigns, and sometimes use it in Ravenloft as well. Normally my style is more of a fusion with Ravenloft. I like to call it character driven. So I plan out all the characters that will likely be involved, and try to keep in mind how they might drive the campaign in broad strokes, but ultimately I prefer to let the players do what they will within that environment. So after the initial planning, its more about how the NPCs and power groups respond to player actions and how the players respond to them.

When you do sandbox in ravenloft Strahdsbuddy, do you still use planned encounters or try to weave any kind of drama out of the player's decisions?

Nathan, I totally get the obsession method. I do that a lot myself I think. Often I'll delve into one of the Van Richten Guides or just get really into a particular kind of monster and see where that takes me. I am a total sucker for golems.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:14 am
by Deewun
For me, it always comes down to characters first. I am VERY involved in character creation with my players, treating that as a separate session. Once we spend a session building characters and weaving them together, then I can move to my next step, theme mapping. I make sure I figure out the thematic elements I want to use that will work with what the characters have. From there, I generally pull out the maps and plot a logical path through the maps to help plan on adventures, sprinkling in modules and adventures and filling in the blanks.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:38 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
My style is like Deewun's. about 75% of my adventures are based on the personal foes, history, or interests of the characters. First thing I did when I got my PCs character backgrounds was come up with a foe for each of them. From there on, adventures often become "what evil scheme is foe X up to this week?"
The real fun will begin when then their foes intertwine and start working together. :)

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:50 am
by Deewun
To give credit where it is due, I did change my style after reading Ron's campaign, as I was impressed with how their backstories were interwoven, as I used to just do modules or just make it all up as I went.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 1:08 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
BedrockBrendan wrote:Thanks for the feedback.


When you do sandbox in ravenloft Strahdsbuddy, do you still use planned encounters or try to weave any kind of drama out of the player's decisions?
Ravenloft is really the perfect setting for sandbox play because of how much detail is available on locations and characters. From a DM perspective, I keep lists and charts on where I can find places and people in my collection (Which is all in pdf format now). For instance, I have a whole Excel spreadsheet (which i use as sortable graph paper) just for NPCs in Mordenshire. It is almost set up like FInal Fantasy: when the PCs walk into building A, they meet shopkeeper B. Where it takes off from video games (and really, this is the strength of PnP role playing) is that they don't just have 3 options for interaction; they are infinite. Because I'm pretty anal retentive and love maps, I will place lairs all over a domain, and encounters within them. It will be adjusted for time of day/year. All that said, I'm not a slave to my tables. If the players are looking for something exciting, I lead them in the right direction to find it. I may make them work for it, but if it moves the game along, then it is a positive.

Another thing about Ravenloft, for me anyway, is that the setting is really NOT set up to achieve Total Party Kills, despite reputation. In this respect, the PCs should be able to walk into the House on Gryphon Hill without getting slaughtered in the first room. Ravenloft shouldn't be built like a series of progressive dungeons, like a video game (What? You went into the Marsh Cave without 3rd level spells? It CAN'T be done!) Fear and Horror are not essentially married to death. You can scare the crap out of PCs in a "High Level" place like Gryphon Hill or Avernus, but the only reason they should get killed is if they are foolish. This adds to the sandbox idea: nowhere is off limits.

Accurate maps in Ravenloft are difficult to come by (and scale has been up for debate since the Black Box) but that doesn't mean that the place isn't sufficiently mapped out. Reading the Gazeteers, you know where to find certain NPCs. It is just like Final Fantasy again: you know where Matoya is, you know where Astos is, you know where the Ice Sword is. Those things are only static because they are programmed to be. Without such restrictions, I can approach the game like this: If my PCs go to the dog fights in Karina, THIS is how I will handle the encounter. I cannot predict what the PCs will do. Maybe they will make an ally of Nathan Timothy! Letting them feel like they are driving the story creates a positive experience. It requires a lot of research, but I've been reading this stuff for 20 years already and I have this fabulous forum as a resource. I feel like I'm prepared!

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 1:58 pm
by BedrockBrendan
Strahdsbuddy wrote: Ravenloft is really the perfect setting for sandbox play because of how much detail is available on locations and characters. From a DM perspective, I keep lists and charts on where I can find places and people in my collection (Which is all in pdf format now). For instance, I have a whole Excel spreadsheet (which i use as sortable graph paper) just for NPCs in Mordenshire. It is almost set up like FInal Fantasy: when the PCs walk into building A, they meet shopkeeper B. Where it takes off from video games (and really, this is the strength of PnP role playing) is that they don't just have 3 options for interaction; they are infinite. Because I'm pretty anal retentive and love maps, I will place lairs all over a domain, and encounters within them. It will be adjusted for time of day/year. All that said, I'm not a slave to my tables. If the players are looking for something exciting, I lead them in the right direction to find it. I may make them work for it, but if it moves the game along, then it is a positive.
Sounds like you've got a solid method down for this. With Ravenloft I tend not to go this far in the sandbox direction (though I must say your campaign sounds like a lot of fun). But this is not too different from what I do in a lot of my modern mafia campaigns (which I find easier to sandbox simply because of the modern setting and because there is no need for me to work the gothic mood into the mix). If I have the right mix of players I may give you method a shot when I have the time.
Another thing about Ravenloft, for me anyway, is that the setting is really NOT set up to achieve Total Party Kills, despite reputation. In this respect, the PCs should be able to walk into the House on Gryphon Hill without getting slaughtered in the first room. Ravenloft shouldn't be built like a series of progressive dungeons, like a video game (What? You went into the Marsh Cave without 3rd level spells? It CAN'T be done!) Fear and Horror are not essentially married to death. You can scare the crap out of PCs in a "High Level" place like Gryphon Hill or Avernus, but the only reason they should get killed is if they are foolish. This adds to the sandbox idea: nowhere is off limits.
I agree that throwing heavy fire power at the party isn't the way to handle Ravenloft. The kind of mood ravenloft requires is more subtle than that. I do however not flinch if a player gets killed in combat (I tend to be a let the dice fall where they may kind of GM). When that happens naturally in the course of an adventure (provided I have been careful to balance encounters and everything), I use it to heighten the mood. I do find occassional unplanned character deaths remind everyone of the stakes. But just setting out to wipe them out, or overun them with powerful adversaries isn't the way to go. On the other hand, I see the merit of your approach and have GMd that way in the past. Ultimately it depends on my players. Every group I've played with has a different take on character death.
Accurate maps in Ravenloft are difficult to come by (and scale has been up for debate since the Black Box) but that doesn't mean that the place isn't sufficiently mapped out. Reading the Gazeteers, you know where to find certain NPCs. It is just like Final Fantasy again: you know where Matoya is, you know where Astos is, you know where the Ice Sword is. Those things are only static because they are programmed to be. Without such restrictions, I can approach the game like this: If my PCs go to the dog fights in Karina, THIS is how I will handle the encounter. I cannot predict what the PCs will do. Maybe they will make an ally of Nathan Timothy! Letting them feel like they are driving the story creates a positive experience. It requires a lot of research, but I've been reading this stuff for 20 years already and I have this fabulous forum as a resource. I feel like I'm prepared!
Right now I am running a 2e campaign, so I have to convert any of the Gazeteer material (I liked some of the stuff in the Gazeteers, but in some cases they felt too white wolf to me. So I've been picking the things I like and leaving out the things I don't). HOwever, I agree between all the 2e and 3e material out there, there is no shortage of information and maps. Have to say, I admire the level of research you put into your campaigns. Like you I've been reading this stuff for 20 years, but even if I am familiar with the domains, the lords, the locations and NPCs, I find I have to re-read for fine details prior to using them.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 4:17 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Hey Brendan,

I also don't specifically try to avoid killing PCs, but what is the point of having a player put a lot of effort into a good backstory just to have a stray arrow from a nameless goblin kill him before he gets the chance to showcase the character? I've been playing with the same group of guys all my life, so we've had our lessons already. Still, if they are intent on staking Strahd and ignore the fact that they are not powerful enough to get past his magical defenses or his minions, what choice have I got?

As far as the Gazeteers go, they are useful regardless of what rules you are using. HMB will back me up that Ravenloft can work well with many different rules, and I'd take that a step further: it works without any rules at all. Fluff is the most useful part of Ravenloft, and it is also the most plentiful. The population of NPCs and dread possibilities and locations in the 5 Gazeteers is so immense as to be useful to any DM, even if you were using Heroes Unlimited rules. Don't let the 3rd edition be the thing that keeps you from mining the most recent books on the setting; they are just too valuable to ignore!

An example of what I meant by letting the players walk into dangerous places occurs in the prelude of I, Strahd. Van Richten walks unchallenged into Castle Ravenloft to do research on its master, but Strahd is aware of him the entire time. He chooses to keep his minions away from the intruder. Conversely, in Knight of the Black Rose, Magda encounters several of Strahd's minions, and even though it is not disclosed what level she is (if any) the terror of the encounters is enough to remind her and the reader that she does not belong there and that escape is the best option. Creatures like ghosts need not be bent on destroying the living; they may just want to chase them from their lair. Subtlety is a good byword in Ravenloft. Going a few sessions without a fight is not necessarily a bad thing IMO

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 5:27 pm
by BedrockBrendan
Strahdsbuddy wrote:Hey Brendan,

I also don't specifically try to avoid killing PCs, but what is the point of having a player put a lot of effort into a good backstory just to have a stray arrow from a nameless goblin kill him before he gets the chance to showcase the character? I've been playing with the same group of guys all my life, so we've had our lessons already. Still, if they are intent on staking Strahd and ignore the fact that they are not powerful enough to get past his magical defenses or his minions, what choice have I got?
I think this is a very individual thing. I've gamed with players who take your position on this, and I GM accordingly. But I've also gamed with players (and I am such a player myself), who really can't get excited or interested if they know they are being protected from random elements like a stray arrow from a nameless goblin. In these cases, I let the dice fall where they may (even if it is a goblin launching an arrow at the party). But just because the attack was seemingly random or an everyday kind of thing, that doesn't mean the aftermath need to be. A player character has died and that is a significant thing. For me personally, I find the real threat of character death keeps the game exciting and heightens the mood. But I do hear what you are saying, and I think your method is great if it brings you and your players more enjoyment.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 5:54 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Who said they KNEW they were being protected?

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 8:45 pm
by BedrockBrendan
Strahdsbuddy wrote:Who said they KNEW they were being protected?
They don't necessarily know. But in my experience if characters only die when they do something foolish, and never as a result of a seemingly random combat event, then I usually grow suspicious. This is one reason I don't use a GM screen. So people know I am not fudging. Again, though I think it comes down to personal taste.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:26 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I should have been more clear. PCs die in my campaigns. In fact, the last time we played it resulted in my first Total Party Kill at the hand (and hoof and tentacle) of Gwydion during the climax of The Shadow Rift. It was a pretty epic ending to a good campaign, and they actually ended up on the losing end of it. Even now, years later, they still say "That tentacle thing coming through the gate was a BADASS!" TPK is like that; it is utter defeat.

What you are talking about, losing one PC during an adventure has value also, but I think it is more effective if it is done right. Mobbed by zombies and getting a string of bad rolls is a little anticlimactic. Falling at the hands of a major villain in the campaign, who then escapes gives the surviving PCs a fire for revenge and can actually lead them down that morally ambiguous road we like to walk in this setting. Event he newly rolled replacement character will have a dog int he fight, since it is tough for a player to separate that knowledge between PCs. In his heart, the player will want to avenge his fallen PC! That's why some stray arrow is a bad way to die.

Shadwborn spoiler
VIEW CONTENT:
An example of this is in the novel Shadowborn where Alexi's female companion is lost to a hoard of ghouls. The way it was written it was so sudden and without any sort of drama that it kinda ruined the whole book for me. I never want my PCs to bite it that way.

Re: Ravenloft Adventures; where do you start?

Posted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 9:03 am
by BedrockBrendan
Strahdsbuddy wrote:I should have been more clear. PCs die in my campaigns. In fact, the last time we played it resulted in my first Total Party Kill at the hand (and hoof and tentacle) of Gwydion during the climax of The Shadow Rift. It was a pretty epic ending to a good campaign, and they actually ended up on the losing end of it. Even now, years later, they still say "That tentacle thing coming through the gate was a BADASS!" TPK is like that; it is utter defeat.

What you are talking about, losing one PC during an adventure has value also, but I think it is more effective if it is done right. Mobbed by zombies and getting a string of bad rolls is a little anticlimactic. Falling at the hands of a major villain in the campaign, who then escapes gives the surviving PCs a fire for revenge and can actually lead them down that morally ambiguous road we like to walk in this setting. Event he newly rolled replacement character will have a dog int he fight, since it is tough for a player to separate that knowledge between PCs. In his heart, the player will want to avenge his fallen PC! That's why some stray arrow is a bad way to die.

Shadwborn spoiler
VIEW CONTENT:
An example of this is in the novel Shadowborn where Alexi's female companion is lost to a hoard of ghouls. The way it was written it was so sudden and without any sort of drama that it kinda ruined the whole book for me. I never want my PCs to bite it that way.
I hear what you are saying, and I am not suggesting you are wrong (it is a matter of taste). But for me (as a player) I don't like it when characters are protected for the sake of story or climax. It just takes the thrill away from me, when I realize rolls are being fudged to save my guy in certain circumstances.

That said, I think you have it right, in that most players don't agree with me. Which is why I say it is really about the mix of players at the table.