Page 1 of 1

Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 7:33 am
by alhoon
Drinnik Shoehorn wrote:If I get to run my Whistling Fiend campaign I have planned in 4th Ed, I plan to make the following changes to the system. Do people have any other suggestions?

1) Action points now take a healing surge to use.

2) During a 5 minute rest, PCs can choose to either spend healing surges to heal OR renew their encounter powers, not both.

It takes away some of the heroicness, but still makes the players a cut above the rest of the populace.

Actually... I disagree with both to be sincere. Action points are a fundemantal part of the game. Time and again I have found the need to use just one more action in a battle. Paying 8 hp for that (my char is 3rd lvl wizard with a dragon familiar) or so is too harsh.
Not to mention that it's mighty unfair since the fighter gets more healing surges and doesn't use them to heal others.

Forcing the chars to choose to either fall unconsiouss in the next battle or use only two of their weak (and boring through use) at-will powers makes the game ... less. It doesn't take away from the heroicness, it wreaks the game. Also it takes a step back from believability. "OK, we take a second 5 minute rest after the first one, so we can do both. Ehh? Why not? Why do we have to fight something to catch our breath? OK fine. The mage will use his daily to summon something and we will fight that so we can heal later. Or we would take a detour and go hunting rats" :P
What this would accomplish IMO is that you would have characters reluctant to use their encounter powers so when a char has two, he would use just 1 so he could heal in the rest. Using one instead of two per encounters = character more wounded than other wise. Not to mention that once he's out of per encounters he would start getting even more wounded.
I doupt any char would prefer having 2 per encounter powers back instead of healing, unless only superficially wounded.
So in effect you turn per encounter powers to weak daily powers. Not good.
For a 7th lvl char that faces 5 encounters in a day = 12-15/encounter powers used. Your system would turn that to 4-5/encounter powers used. :?


If I may ask:
What exactly are you trying to accomplish? So I could provide other suggestions that wouldn't take a cut out of the (already limited by 4th edition) things the PCs can do?

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 10:04 am
by Jester of the FoS
I think it's an attempt to reduce the power level of PCs and the sheer amount of magic and power they can bring to bear against an opponent.


For my house rules for Ravenloft, I'd use Essentials classes and reflavour things to seem less magic. The paladin isn't striking with a glowing sword powered by the light of the heavens, he's just hitting it with his sword that seems a little more polished than normal swords while he somehow seems cleaner.
Small changes in presentation like that make all the difference.

I might still double monster damage and halve hit points for more fast encounters and fewer big, tactical set piece fights.

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 10:52 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
I'm currently running a 4E Forgotten Realms campaign (with a story that's basically a ripoff of Stargate SG-1 Season 10), but before that I actually ran a full 4E Ravenloft campaign with my friends. Here are the tweaks I made for that:

- Instead of characters getting the full gamut of powers, I give them the "2-2-2-2 option:" two at-wills, two encounters, two dailies and two utilities, regardless of level. The dailies they possess have a recharge of 6 while the encounters have a recharge of 5-6. This ensure that (first) they don't waste precious time choosing what powers to use and (second) they could actually focus on their own storylines than what powers to choose next time they level up.

- I did away with the current alignment system and replaced it with something much closer to what Ravenloft could be. First, I ripped off the entire "Roads" system of Vampire: Dark Ages and tweaked it so each character instead has one road (Kings, Sins, Beast, Humanity, Heaven).

- In that vein, I revised the healing surge mechanic entirely. Instead, I gave them the Virtue/Vice system which I ripped off of the New World of Darkness. They don't get surges; instead, if they perform their Vice properly, they regain hp as if they had spent a healing surge. If they performed their Virtue properly, then they regain all their lost hp.

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 11:23 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote: I might still double monster damage and halve hit points for more fast encounters and fewer big, tactical set piece fights.
I have made a lot of work on that.
Double monster damage = 150% xp worth.
Half HP for monsters = 70% Xp worth.

A monster with x2 damage and 1/2 HP = +10% XP. I.e a 5th lvl monster would be worth about 220XP.
In game you find out that unless the PCs have too many HP, double damage is more dangerous than that because the monster will chack out a good percentage of the PCs' HP.

So I suggest you consider those Double Damage, 1/2 HP monsters as 1 level more... and add a couple of minions (unchanged) in the end to even things out.
I.e for an encounter worth 1000 XP use 4 lvl 5th monsters +2 lvl 5th minions. If you go by hard numbers that's an encounter of 980 XP (with my rules above) but 2 minions aren't actually worth 100 XP if anyone has area attacks and 4 5th lvl monsters are worth more than 880 XP.

PS. Minions. Either leave them as they are in the book, or if you double their damage, they're +50% XP = +2 lvls.

To make your life easier: Don't double damage. Halve the PC's hp. :wink:

Dion:
That sounds like an interesting system... but it's not 4E. :)
I don't think anyone uses the 4E alignment system.
Also dailies recharging at 6 is a bit... OMGpowerful, isn't it? I mean what did you find out in the game?
A char with 2 rechargable x5-6, and 2 dailies rechargable x6 would hardly ever use at will powers.

PS. What about healing powers? Like lay on hands etc? How you used them?

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2011 9:48 am
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote: I might still double monster damage and halve hit points for more fast encounters and fewer big, tactical set piece fights.
I have made a lot of work on that.
Double monster damage = 150% xp worth.
Half HP for monsters = 70% Xp worth.

A monster with x2 damage and 1/2 HP = +10% XP. I.e a 5th lvl monster would be worth about 220XP.
In game you find out that unless the PCs have too many HP, double damage is more dangerous than that because the monster will chack out a good percentage of the PCs' HP.

So I suggest you consider those Double Damage, 1/2 HP monsters as 1 level more... and add a couple of minions (unchanged) in the end to even things out.
I.e for an encounter worth 1000 XP use 4 lvl 5th monsters +2 lvl 5th minions. If you go by hard numbers that's an encounter of 980 XP (with my rules above) but 2 minions aren't actually worth 100 XP if anyone has area attacks and 4 5th lvl monsters are worth more than 880 XP.

PS. Minions. Either leave them as they are in the book, or if you double their damage, they're +50% XP = +2 lvls.

To make your life easier: Don't double damage. Halve the PC's hp. :wink:
It goes back to thisargument, made a couple days back. One point made, is that with nothing carrying over from fight to fight except death, the only way to frighten a PC is by by killing them.

Halving their hp is less optimal because it changes things on their end, so you cannot ever run a standard fight. For big boss fights, 4e is excellent. Halving hp and doubling damage just makes mook fights easier while still adding danger. And it also only changes things for one participant (the DM) rather than everyone.

And really, xp seems to only matter for balancing encounters. If all the PCs level together as a group, which is the rule in 4e, then there's no reason to track xp. Just arbitrarily level characters up when it fits the story.

Still, I'd probably have less of a damage spike for MM3 and later monsters, which already have a significant damage increase. They already have a chance of being a little extra deadly.
alhoon wrote:Dion:
That sounds like an interesting system... but it's not 4E. :)
If Gamma World is 4e, then Dion's system is 4e.
Given how much people have changed and tweaked and house ruled 3e over the years while still technically being 3e, Dion's changes seem minor.
alhoon wrote:Also dailies recharging at 6 is a bit... OMGpowerful, isn't it? I mean what did you find out in the game?
Well, if combat only lasts 5 rounds (which is what it was designed to do) then even using a power on round 1 means you might not have it recharged. Assuming a short rest only grants a free roll it just means you get to use a daily every encounter and a half.
Hrm, might just be easier to tie them to milestones...
alhoon wrote:A char with 2 rechargable x5-6, and 2 dailies rechargable x6 would hardly ever use at will powers.
Opposed to a level 10 character that has 3 encounter powers and 3 dailies, so if they only have three encounters each day they never have to break-out an At-will until round 4 when the fight is just clean-up.

Okay, other options I might consider:
1) I'd probably implement some kind of wound system. Such systems tend to make boss fights harder, as the heroes are not at their prime as injuries accrue. But that makes sense in Ravenloft and encourages people to play smarter and not risk stupid injuries.
2) The inherent enhancement bonuses form DMG2 and Dark Sun. But I'd make these stack with magic weapons, so someone with a +1 sword is still rewarded for having a magic item.
3) Essentials only. The martial characters in that seem a little less magical, which is nice. Plus Heroes of Shadow looks interesting.

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2011 9:50 am
by Drinnik Shoehorn
My changes are basically to make the game grittier, but still have heroes fighting the darkness. Yeah, 4th Ed isn't ideal for Ravenloft, and I do think 3.5 is more suited, but my group are fairly anti-3rd edition and all it's iterations. We seem to have skipped it entirely. So I've got to modify 4th Edition. As for taking two 5 minute rests, simply put, I wouldn't let them as a DM.

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2011 3:43 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Well, if combat only lasts 5 rounds (which is what it was designed to do) ...

Opposed to a level 10 character that has 3 encounter powers and 3 dailies, so if they only have three encounters each day they never have to break-out an At-will until round 4 when the fight is just clean-up.
:?

IIRC combat was designed to take 10 rounds. Also, I use 1/2 HP for monsters in my games and my DM does so too.
In the game I'm player, where we started 2nd lvl and progressed to 3rd lvl, there was hardly a fight that was 5 rounds while most were 7-8 rounds. With 1/2 HP
In the game I'm DM, where the PCs are 12th lvl, there's been ages that we have seen any fight (even easy ones) that was less than 10 rounds.
We play about 8-10 hours/week or so.
Drinnik Shoehorn wrote: As for taking two 5 minute rests, simply put, I wouldn't let them as a DM.
Yeap. But it's taking a step back from believability IMO. And still looks too harsh if you ask me. Your game, your rules buddy. :)
Jester of the FoS wrote: 1) I'd probably implement some kind of wound system. Such systems tend to make boss fights harder, as the heroes are not at their prime as injuries accrue. But that makes sense in Ravenloft and encourages people to play smarter and not risk stupid injuries.

3) Essentials only. The martial characters in that seem a little less magical, which is nice. Plus Heroes of Shadow looks interesting.
Very interesting! Can I hear a bit more about those things? What do you think of about wounds and what do you mean by "essentials only"?
What about Heroes of Shadow? Should I go buy the book? PS. That means, if it's out for 2 months already, since it takes quite some time to arrive here.

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2011 4:14 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Well, if combat only lasts 5 rounds (which is what it was designed to do) ...

Opposed to a level 10 character that has 3 encounter powers and 3 dailies, so if they only have three encounters each day they never have to break-out an At-will until round 4 when the fight is just clean-up.
:?

IIRC combat was designed to take 10 rounds..
The Players Strategy Guide suggests seven rounds.

Re: Changes to 4E for Ravenloft

Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2011 9:28 am
by alhoon
From my experience, it's not so. The players guide is wrong. After lvl 7th-8th or so, battles take usually more than 7 rounds, unless you have a lot of mages and area attacks.
A 5th lvl elite soldier monster (i.e. hard to hit) would have close to 130 hp and AC around 22.
2 such monsters +2-3 5th lvl minions would be a nice encounter for 4 5th lvl chars. You think 4 5th lvl chars would deal 130hp to each elite in 7 rounds? With monster powers that throw the PCs prone or marking them so they can't move etc? With the crappy 2d8+6 damage or something the PCs would be handling out with their per encounters, if they land a hit? :)

You know, one of the reasons I loved your idea with the rechargable powers is that the PCs would never actually run out of c00l things to do, and also speed up combat.

But even so, 4 such battles = 28 rounds of combat = you use each daily on average of 4 times if it recharges on 6. That means you use 8 daily powers in 4 encounters. Well, actually you may be right. Rechargable dailies at 6 would tend to shorten battles.

Anyway, I suggest this: 2 per-encounter powers rechargable at 8-10 of 1d10. 1 daily power at the start of the battle. After they use it, they may pick that again or another from their list for the next time it recharges. And it recharges on 10 of 1d10.
Jester of the FoS wrote: Halving hp and doubling damage just makes mook fights easier while still adding danger.

And really, xp seems to only matter for balancing encounters.

Still, I'd probably have less of a damage spike for MM3 and later monsters, which already have a significant damage increase.
Yeap. XP is mainly for balancing encounters.
My point though was that a monster with half hp and double damage is more dangerous than the normal monster itself.