Changes to 4E for Ravenloft
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 7:33 am
Drinnik Shoehorn wrote:If I get to run my Whistling Fiend campaign I have planned in 4th Ed, I plan to make the following changes to the system. Do people have any other suggestions?
1) Action points now take a healing surge to use.
2) During a 5 minute rest, PCs can choose to either spend healing surges to heal OR renew their encounter powers, not both.
It takes away some of the heroicness, but still makes the players a cut above the rest of the populace.
Actually... I disagree with both to be sincere. Action points are a fundemantal part of the game. Time and again I have found the need to use just one more action in a battle. Paying 8 hp for that (my char is 3rd lvl wizard with a dragon familiar) or so is too harsh.
Not to mention that it's mighty unfair since the fighter gets more healing surges and doesn't use them to heal others.
Forcing the chars to choose to either fall unconsiouss in the next battle or use only two of their weak (and boring through use) at-will powers makes the game ... less. It doesn't take away from the heroicness, it wreaks the game. Also it takes a step back from believability. "OK, we take a second 5 minute rest after the first one, so we can do both. Ehh? Why not? Why do we have to fight something to catch our breath? OK fine. The mage will use his daily to summon something and we will fight that so we can heal later. Or we would take a detour and go hunting rats"
What this would accomplish IMO is that you would have characters reluctant to use their encounter powers so when a char has two, he would use just 1 so he could heal in the rest. Using one instead of two per encounters = character more wounded than other wise. Not to mention that once he's out of per encounters he would start getting even more wounded.
I doupt any char would prefer having 2 per encounter powers back instead of healing, unless only superficially wounded.
So in effect you turn per encounter powers to weak daily powers. Not good.
For a 7th lvl char that faces 5 encounters in a day = 12-15/encounter powers used. Your system would turn that to 4-5/encounter powers used.
If I may ask:
What exactly are you trying to accomplish? So I could provide other suggestions that wouldn't take a cut out of the (already limited by 4th edition) things the PCs can do?