Page 1 of 1
Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Sat Mar 05, 2011 4:51 pm
by Galeros
Do you think that Deathless (As presented in the Book of Exalted Deeds and the 3.5 Eberron Campaign Setting) have a place in Ravenloft?
I know it has been suggested that the "Ancient Dead" could be Deathless, seeing as how they were powered by positive energy back in 2E.
Would you allow a "White" Necromancer character to use Deathless in place of traditional Undead?
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Sat Mar 05, 2011 8:23 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
In my fanfics, and in yet another project called Van Richten's Guide to Unlife, I explore how the deathless arise in a land so much more closely connected to the Negative Energy Plane and the differences between them and undead on more than a mechanical level. To say that all of the deathless are good and undead evil is both inaccurate and foolish; it goes more toward what brought the creature back and why. Undead refuse death, whether or not they do so willingly, while deathless accept it and actually do die until called back. It's subtle, so much so it can be lost on even the sagest scholars like van Richten, but it's what makes all the difference. Sometimes so-called "undead" are actually deathless beings; they may be good or evil, but they're deathless because their unlives are somehow tied to positive energy, be it spell, will, or something else.
"White" necromancers are actually a prestige class in Champions of Light, but the idea of a necromancer choosing the path to fight the undead is easily done. Though a lot of necromancy spells traffic with negative energy and the undead, reversed forms of the spells are easily done (though some such as animate deat and others may be altered to create temporary deathless instead of being reversed directly). There are also necromancy spells that harm the undead like undeath to death, diminish undead (VRA), and the popular disrupt undead. Sadly a lot of the best spells for combating the undead are divine, not arcane, so a house rule to create arcane versions would be needed.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2011 9:07 am
by cure
As I recall, perhaps incorrectly, Mangrum, in his wish list of a Ravenloft Monster Manual, gives the Deathless a prominent place.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2011 1:19 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
cure wrote:As I recall, perhaps incorrectly, Mangrum, in his wish list of a Ravenloft Monster Manual, gives the Deathless a prominent place.
It's rather sad they didn't. Deathless deserve a more prominent place in D&D as a whole.
Plus maybe we could put the whole "ancients are powered by positive energy" to rest once and for all. Maybe some are, like tomb guardians who chose to die and come back to fulfill their duty when needed. The "sleep" van Richten supposed might not be sleep at all, but their souls going on to the afterlife. Those ancients fueled by negative energy would fit with everything that's been published about malign mummies.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2011 12:18 am
by Drinnik Shoehorn
AFAIR, Mangrum said Ravenloft mummies are the deathless type, that explains VRGt the Ancient Deadand their positive energy powers. I think the whole book is written based on a misprint somewhere and rather than correct it, they spun it out into a cool explanation.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2011 7:17 am
by Joël of the FoS
The positive energy in the first D&D MM for mummies is indeed a Gygaxian typo, which was "fixed" later.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2011 10:59 am
by alhoon
Personally, I hate the Deathless type (unlife that's not bad exactly, not an abomination of life but... well not life either) and I disagree with mummies being positive energy. If that was so, clerics wouldn't be able to turn them but bolster them.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2011 12:59 pm
by Galeros
alhoon wrote:Personally, I hate the Deathless type (unlife that's not bad exactly, not an abomination of life but... well not life either) and I disagree with mummies being positive energy. If that was so, clerics wouldn't be able to turn them but bolster them.
Clerics who can Channel Positive Energy can bolster them I believe.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2011 11:02 pm
by Matthew L. Martin
alhoon wrote:Personally, I hate the Deathless type (unlife that's not bad exactly, not an abomination of life but... well not life either) and I disagree with mummies being positive energy. If that was so, clerics wouldn't be able to turn them but bolster them.
Well, turning/rebuking being based on positive or negative energy came to the game with 3E; back in previous editions, when the Van Richten's Guide was written, it was based on divine power. (After all, Basic's cosmology didn't even
have Positive or Negative Energy planes, but clerics could still turn undead. Of course, BECM didn't have 'gods', either.

)
John Mangrum did have ideas for combining the 'deathless' type with ancient dead, but they would have remained evil, since in Ravenloft, they couldn't have their cake and eat it too . . .
EDIT: Found the public posting of John's ideas.
Were I rewriting the Ravenloft core books now, ancient dead and mummies would both exist -- the former being deathless and the latter undead.
The twist on deathless in Ravenloft is that, in other words, the souls of the deathless are free to move on to their deserved afterlives (presumably in the Upper Planes), returning to their bodies only when needed. In Ravenloft, their souls have nowhere to go, so they merely "slumber" in oblivion.
The ancient dead of Ravenloft aren't inherently evil (unlike the undead) -- they just come by it naturally via their unnatural connection to a mortal existance and the denial of the promised afterlife.
Re: Deathless in Ravenloft
Posted: Tue Mar 08, 2011 11:16 pm
by Deewun
I just finished reading the VRGttAD, and I love the Positive Energy idea. So I think using the Deathless is a great idea, and one I may just steal and use myself.