Page 1 of 1

4e & Ravenloft; My Own Thoughts

Posted: Mon Mar 14, 2011 4:38 am
by Hell_Born
Having been justly chastised for 4e grognardia, I decided that some penance was due. I don't quite know my own reasonings for it, but I decided to try and put to type my rationale behind why 4e and Ravenloft aren't incompatible.

To begin with, I must note that, whereas many on these boards prefer to focus on Ravenloft as Gothic Horror, I myself prefer to focus on Ravenloft as Gothic Fantasy Horror; the horror is a neccessary ingredient, and the gothic casts its shadow over all, but the fantasy is the base. I think Jester did an excellent job of fitting in the 4e races in his unofficial Ravenloft 4e Player's Guide, but I personally would not strive to "humanize" them so. Among other things, this ensures that players would be more willing to play native PCs, thus continuing the excellent trend of 3e of moving away from "Weekend in Hell" adventurers, rather then sticking with Outlanders in order to ensure that their characters look how they expect them to look.

This does not mean I would not mess with racial backgrounds or even certain personality traits in order to help emphasise the dark, forbidden, mysterious nature of Ravenloft. In fact, two seperate domains may produce the same "race" via very different methods indeed...

Now let's see... my thoughts are never wanting to stay with me...

From the beginning, Ravenloft has been a setting in which Roleplay should always prevail over Rollplay. Of course, Fear, Horror and Madness have always been supported mechanically, but ideally, the player should feel that there is a reason for their character to make those tests in the first place. In Ravenloft, the skill of immersing a party in the story being told is essential to being a good DM; if the players don't feel the horror, then they are more likely to grumble, complain or even outright revolt against the terror checks.

This leads to the irony. 4th Edition D&D also encourages roleplay over rollplay; the rules are simple, straightforward and combat-focused, but that's because combat needs rules; interacting with the world and the people in it is far more something a party should be trying to actively roleplay, not just roll dice and mechanically receive information or not. Yes, the ruleset does make it easily applicable to hack and slashers, but honestly, just about every edition has been the same - D&D began solely as hack and slash, and then evolved into its present state. Anyway, 4e encourages roleplay, Ravenloft needs roleplay... so why the hostility? To be honest, it's because 4e is a system where the base assumption is a Heroic Fantasy world - thus, on the surface, the two appear as compatible as cheese and chalk.

This leads my train of thought to another siding: reflavoring. As I just stated, the default themes of 4e means that, fluffwise, many classes or even individual powers seem utterly wrong for Ravenloft. Well, to me, this is where 4e actually has a hidden advantage. Many complain that 4e powers are all the same; a simple bundle of mechanics with a trace of fluff on top. Me, I choose to see that as a strength. The underlying mechanics are balanced and stable... which means I can change the fluff in any way I want to make it more in-character, for both my PC and the setting, and the Rules Lawyer hasn't got a leg to stand on if they want to complain about it. Take, for example, a Paladin; many have complained about the Holy Strike power, and this is understandable. Its default fluff causes the blade to ignite in a radiant beam of holy light, a visible symbol of the Paladin's faith and the favor placed in him/her by the divine. Obviously, this is too overt for Ravenloft, so my suggestion is simple: muffle it. Perhaps a faint, candle-like glow briefly is cast when the weapon bites into flesh, perhaps a pattern in the vague shape of the outline of a holy symbol can be seen on the blade, whatever it happens, it's a blink-and-you'll-miss-it affair.

Truthfully, I think that, in the right circumstances, refluffing in the right way can actually add to the mood. How? Well, take the above example and apply it to an Outlander PC; the player knows what to expect from the Player's Handbook, they are confident in the manifestation of their character's holy might. Instead, when the DM describes how their radiant energy fails to manifest strongly, taking much strain and concentration to be at all visible, the sensation that the power is somehow being blocked and held back, then they have a reason to worry, they have a reason to fear: that power they trusted so much... it can't be trusted. Nothing has been changed mechanically, but that simple bit of redescription is aimed to invoke paranoia, suspicion and a fear of weakness... in other words, perfect Ravenloft mood.

The simple durability of the combat rules also have their good sides. For starters... Ravenloft has always traditionally tried to make its monsters unique. Salient powers have been its attempts to handle this in the last two editions. In 4e, it's very easy to make up new combat-related powers and slot them into your monsters for further customization.

Which brings us to the other boon: monster statblocks only apply for direct combat. They only matter when the monster is toe-to-toe with your PCs and they're trying to kill each other. Outside of combat, it can do whatever you want it to do. You want a vampire lord to be able to regenerate perfectly after a lost encounter unless the killers anoint its skull with three tears taken from a virgin widow? That's fine and dandy. You want ghouls that can, by devouring the brains of living people, assume their identities and then revert to their true form while the PCs are trapped in a banquet hall outnumbered by ravenous undead flesh eaters? Go for it.

If it doesn't directly relate to the capabilities of the monster in battle, you can load your monsters up with whatever nasty tricks, vile gifts and dark surprises you can think of. Jacqueline Renier's "take on dire rat form when confronted with true love" curse is a non-combat feature; it would be part of her background and persona, but not her statblock.

Hmm... let me see, what else was there? Nothing I can recall, but I may return another day when new thoughts come to mind.

Re: 4e & Ravenloft; My Own Thoughts

Posted: Mon Mar 14, 2011 7:12 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Excellent points about reflavoring. I do it in 3e as well. And our own Jester wrote an excellent article on the subject, published in Dragon. Have you seen it?

http://fraternityofshadows.com/forum/vi ... 82#p144782

Re: 4e & Ravenloft; My Own Thoughts

Posted: Mon Mar 14, 2011 1:27 pm
by Hell_Born
Yes, I've seen that article, and I rather liked it to. These thoughts, though, have been tickling around inside my head for a while; I've just never bothered to write them up before.

Re: 4e & Ravenloft; My Own Thoughts

Posted: Mon Mar 14, 2011 4:34 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
As another person that also owes a penance, I will say that Hell_born's and Jester's ideas are pretty great. In fact, I had only scratched the surface of the system, and was going mostly by reports on this forum (i'm not even a member of another gaming forum). I guess I drank a little too much of the kool-aid and formed a hasty opinion. Since I haven't had a gaming group since the early days of 3.5, I haven't seen the point in buying the new edition, and I suppose I took that lofty perch of non-participation to drop pebbles on the whole thing.

I did read the rules as being very WoW-ish, which may actually be by design. As a low-combat DM, I sort of liked a detailed skills list like in 3rd edition, but I can certainly see how that can slow down creature creation. Just glancing at the 3E monster manual, each monster has a Spot ranking; was that entirely necessary?

Overall, an interesting character is more important to me than how much damage he does and always has been. I can see the minimalist's argument that the less restrictions there are, the more role-playing can flourish. I know for a fact that I will buy the next Ravenloft product regardless of edition of publisher. I've been here for 20 years, and the last few without a gaming group. The Mists are my home, and that goes above any ruleset.

Thanks, Hell-born for reminding us that a quick tweak makes everything workable. We've done it since we first started rolling dice!

Re: 4e & Ravenloft; My Own Thoughts

Posted: Mon Mar 14, 2011 5:14 pm
by Hell_Born
To be fair, I do think that sometimes the rules matter. If you want to use Ravenloft solely as a setting for Gothic Horror, if you don't really like the Fantasy elements it includes by default (such as demihuman PC races), then I would honestly recommend a different ruleset then D&D. Because, in all honesty, fantasy is D&D's root; even with all the changes 2nd and 3rd edition imposed, it was still theoretically plausible for a PC to rise to a 15th level Wizard or something.

For DMs who want to run purely Gothic Horror Ravenloft games, I would probably recommend Deadlands as the base ruleset to use. I admit that part of this is because I am not very experienced with other rulesets, but as Deadlands is itself a Horror roleplaying setting, I find it works quite well. It's relatively simple, but has detailed rules, and combat is more realistic, thanks to its basis of hit locations and wound levels - a Maiming wound to the Head or Guts, and you're dead, no matter how experienced you are. You can cut the arcane entirely out of PC hands, or, if you feel like letting them have it, the magic of the Blessed and Hucksters is much more subtle and limited then in D&D - and a lot riskier. In essence, every time a Huckster casts a spell, there's a chance his soul will be ripped out of his body, instantly killing him.

In summary, I would really only recommend D&D of any edition to Ravenloft DMs who want a Gothic Fantasy Horror game, rather then just pure Gothic Horror.

Re: 4e & Ravenloft; My Own Thoughts

Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2011 11:31 am
by Mortavius
To chime in (a little late), I have to agree with you, Hell Born. I am currently running a 4E version of Ravenloft for my group, and they are enjoying it.

I have taken some elements of Jester's 4E work, but some I have left out. For example, although I applaud what he's tried to do with the races, I just can't see Dragonborn in Ravenloft. And to me, anything that changes them to the point where they would be acceptable by people in the Demiplane, ceases to make them Dragonborn anymore.

I've seen the complaints about Holy Strike before, but I've never thought too much of them myself. We don't have any problems when a wizard in Ravenloft throws a ball of fire at his enemies, or a strike of lightning. With the latest incarnations of Ravenloft some serious attention has been given to the religious side of Ravenloft, with the development of the Church of Ezra, the Lawgiver, and Hala. There is no problems when a cleric magically closes a victim's wounds with obvious evidence of divine power. But a holy warrior striking an enemy with a sword that flashes with golden light is too much?

I have a Paladin player in my game, and I describe his sword as glowing brightly when he strikes with it using that attack. But he doesn't always use it, and he doesn't walk around with a glowing sword all the time. As well, I take care to describe the reaction around him when he uses the power. I recently ran Howls in the Night, and when he used the power in the bog to attack some Bog Hounds, I described his sword as glowing, but that the mists all around seemed to be leaching the glow away, like they were stealing the power. Game-mechanic wise there was no change, but it offered some nice flavor to the power.

Anyways, just some thoughts I wanted to add.