Morality as delusion
Posted: Tue Mar 22, 2011 1:15 am
In my so-called real life (what is "real"?), I have a M.A in philosophy and I'm working on my dissertation. I deal mainly with issues of morality, religion and their relations. During my studies, an interesting insight occurred to me.
Morality, in whatever form you take it, has two general purposes: make people happy, and help them manifest their humanity. Recognizing that, it shouldn't be too difficult to distinguish right and wrong, good and evil, at least in general lines; almost everyone agrees that murder, torture and oppression are morally evil, while compassion, empathy and mercifulness are morally good. Of course, there are many disagreements over the details of those principles, but their core is non-controversial.
But all of the above is true, only if we believe we can grasp the reality of the world, and see what brings happiness and what causes misery in the long term. We can see, for example, that democracy brings more happiness to its subjects than tyranny; therefore we have a moral reason to prefer it. But what if we don't see the whole picture? What if there are other dimensions or realities, of which we are unaware, and which would have told us a whole different story had we known them?
This is where religion steps in. Religion tells us about heavens and hells, souls and afterlife, sins and divine commands. It teaches us that our world is not the whole picture; what seems to be pleasurable here, might lead to torment in the next world, while terrible bodily suffering may be the pathway of the soul to Heaven. What is favorable by humans, might actually be offensive for God, and vice versa. Thus, religious faith actually nullifies the reliability of our moral sense; for accurate moral judgment requires knowledge of the facts and the results of every action, but religion has it that we simply can't know all the relevant facts and results – not by ourselves, at any rate. The truth may always be the exact opposite of what our human moral sense tells us. This is the metaphysical background for such things like crusades, inquisition, Jyhad etc. (Note that I'm only making a philosophical point, not criticizing any actual faith or religious behavior.)
This realization that esoteric knowledge can radically change our moral views, and consequently our behavior, can inspire many adventures, in which what seems to be most evil is actually a great good, and vice versa. This should lead the characters to conflicts between their deeply ingrained moral intuitions, and the new understanding they have acquired. Here are several examples:
- A kingdom ruled by a most tyrannical theocracy – something like G'Henna/Nidala/Pharazia meets Orwell's 1984. The whole population is constantly brainwashed by the priesthood, and the Inquisition mercilessly roots out any sign for heresy or deviant thoughts. The PCs are likely to sympathize with the rebellious liberation movement, and struggle to overthrow this oppressive regime and grant everyone freedom and human rights. But what if the priests are right? What if the truth is that the realm is in a constant threat of invasion by the legions of Hell, and the only thing which can hold them at bay is the power of the god(s) – which must be fortified by every ounce of mortal faith if it is to prevail? Every sin and heresy might tip the balance in favor of Hell, and the overthrowing of the church will only plunge the world into eternal damnation.
- A series of gruesome murders and mutilations is taking place, and the PCs are called to investigate. It seems to be the work of an unnatural killer, apparently a demon; in truth, the killer is an angel from Heaven, sent to punish the sinners (perhaps in the Seven movie fashion). The PCs might feel that some sins are not so severe to justify such terrible punishments – but can wretched mortals question the justice of the Almighty Creator? (Note that the conflict is more acute in context of a monotheistic world, not of the typical polytheistic D&D world, where gods are not the highest authority in topics of morals.)
[This theme is thoroughly explored in the game Spite: The Second Book of Pandemonium, where the PCs fight angels who look and behave like Lovecraftian horrors – but which are servants of Heaven nevertheless. I found this book greatly inspiring (though it doesn't deal explicitly with any philosophy or theology); it is downloadable in Drivethrurpg.com for 2$ only, and its player section is downloadable for free, along with Dread: The First Book of Pandemonium and some other products!]
- Alternatively, some poor and miserable folk are found dead – all with a look of bliss on their faces. An angel has come to deliver them from the misery of this world into the eternal bliss of Heaven. By revealing her true, heavenly beautiful shape and singing, she evokes such a feeling of longing and love that makes people's hearts burst in their chests, and their souls are drawn through her into the gates of Heaven. Will the PCs try to stop this kind of apparently merciful activity? Or will their help it?
(I once read a story about a zombie plague, in which the zombies have actually achieved such a state of transcendence and spiritual harmony that they wanted to share it with the rest of humanity – by driving their teeth into the humans' brains... It was in one of the All Flesh Must be Eaten anthologies.)
- One ethnical group, gender or race, apparently completely normal, is actually a plague upon the world. All women/elves/Vistani etc. are in fact the creation of some archdevil or demon prince, who uses them as a tool to corrupt mankind and manipulate them in obscure ways. The members of this group are not aware to their role in the scheme, but some other forces might know it, and understand that only by the complete elimination of this group can the world be saved. Could the Dukkar be the deliverer of Ravenloft after all?
- What if physical relationships – in all forms – are actually a honey-trap which unavoidably corrupts human's souls, and only by perfect celibacy can one escape Hell and reach Heaven? Or the opposite might be true – only by breaking the taboos concerning those issues can the human mind be released from its limitations and ascend to some higher state of consciousness?
I think those examples are enough to show that practically every moral atrocity – murder, torture, even genocide – may theoretically be the right thing to do, given some metaphysical or unearthly conditions. While of course I'm not endorsing any kind of such actions in real life, I think the introduction of those concepts into a game can be a most intriguing challenge for roleplayers, especially in Ravenloft, where themes of good and evil are central. How will the Dark Powers treat those kinds of behavior? Could they have some kind of esoteric moral knowledge, according to which the Darklords are actually paragons of virtue? Perhaps everything we conceive as good and evil is quite the opposite, and we are all prisoners of some demiurge who deludes us all (Kult), and only the DPs know the truth and try leading humanity toward it? Ravenloft might actually not be a prison, but a pocket of freedom in the cosmic net of deceit which is the multiverse…
Just some thoughts. It's good to be a philosopher!
Morality, in whatever form you take it, has two general purposes: make people happy, and help them manifest their humanity. Recognizing that, it shouldn't be too difficult to distinguish right and wrong, good and evil, at least in general lines; almost everyone agrees that murder, torture and oppression are morally evil, while compassion, empathy and mercifulness are morally good. Of course, there are many disagreements over the details of those principles, but their core is non-controversial.
But all of the above is true, only if we believe we can grasp the reality of the world, and see what brings happiness and what causes misery in the long term. We can see, for example, that democracy brings more happiness to its subjects than tyranny; therefore we have a moral reason to prefer it. But what if we don't see the whole picture? What if there are other dimensions or realities, of which we are unaware, and which would have told us a whole different story had we known them?
This is where religion steps in. Religion tells us about heavens and hells, souls and afterlife, sins and divine commands. It teaches us that our world is not the whole picture; what seems to be pleasurable here, might lead to torment in the next world, while terrible bodily suffering may be the pathway of the soul to Heaven. What is favorable by humans, might actually be offensive for God, and vice versa. Thus, religious faith actually nullifies the reliability of our moral sense; for accurate moral judgment requires knowledge of the facts and the results of every action, but religion has it that we simply can't know all the relevant facts and results – not by ourselves, at any rate. The truth may always be the exact opposite of what our human moral sense tells us. This is the metaphysical background for such things like crusades, inquisition, Jyhad etc. (Note that I'm only making a philosophical point, not criticizing any actual faith or religious behavior.)
This realization that esoteric knowledge can radically change our moral views, and consequently our behavior, can inspire many adventures, in which what seems to be most evil is actually a great good, and vice versa. This should lead the characters to conflicts between their deeply ingrained moral intuitions, and the new understanding they have acquired. Here are several examples:
- A kingdom ruled by a most tyrannical theocracy – something like G'Henna/Nidala/Pharazia meets Orwell's 1984. The whole population is constantly brainwashed by the priesthood, and the Inquisition mercilessly roots out any sign for heresy or deviant thoughts. The PCs are likely to sympathize with the rebellious liberation movement, and struggle to overthrow this oppressive regime and grant everyone freedom and human rights. But what if the priests are right? What if the truth is that the realm is in a constant threat of invasion by the legions of Hell, and the only thing which can hold them at bay is the power of the god(s) – which must be fortified by every ounce of mortal faith if it is to prevail? Every sin and heresy might tip the balance in favor of Hell, and the overthrowing of the church will only plunge the world into eternal damnation.
- A series of gruesome murders and mutilations is taking place, and the PCs are called to investigate. It seems to be the work of an unnatural killer, apparently a demon; in truth, the killer is an angel from Heaven, sent to punish the sinners (perhaps in the Seven movie fashion). The PCs might feel that some sins are not so severe to justify such terrible punishments – but can wretched mortals question the justice of the Almighty Creator? (Note that the conflict is more acute in context of a monotheistic world, not of the typical polytheistic D&D world, where gods are not the highest authority in topics of morals.)
[This theme is thoroughly explored in the game Spite: The Second Book of Pandemonium, where the PCs fight angels who look and behave like Lovecraftian horrors – but which are servants of Heaven nevertheless. I found this book greatly inspiring (though it doesn't deal explicitly with any philosophy or theology); it is downloadable in Drivethrurpg.com for 2$ only, and its player section is downloadable for free, along with Dread: The First Book of Pandemonium and some other products!]
- Alternatively, some poor and miserable folk are found dead – all with a look of bliss on their faces. An angel has come to deliver them from the misery of this world into the eternal bliss of Heaven. By revealing her true, heavenly beautiful shape and singing, she evokes such a feeling of longing and love that makes people's hearts burst in their chests, and their souls are drawn through her into the gates of Heaven. Will the PCs try to stop this kind of apparently merciful activity? Or will their help it?
(I once read a story about a zombie plague, in which the zombies have actually achieved such a state of transcendence and spiritual harmony that they wanted to share it with the rest of humanity – by driving their teeth into the humans' brains... It was in one of the All Flesh Must be Eaten anthologies.)
- One ethnical group, gender or race, apparently completely normal, is actually a plague upon the world. All women/elves/Vistani etc. are in fact the creation of some archdevil or demon prince, who uses them as a tool to corrupt mankind and manipulate them in obscure ways. The members of this group are not aware to their role in the scheme, but some other forces might know it, and understand that only by the complete elimination of this group can the world be saved. Could the Dukkar be the deliverer of Ravenloft after all?
- What if physical relationships – in all forms – are actually a honey-trap which unavoidably corrupts human's souls, and only by perfect celibacy can one escape Hell and reach Heaven? Or the opposite might be true – only by breaking the taboos concerning those issues can the human mind be released from its limitations and ascend to some higher state of consciousness?
I think those examples are enough to show that practically every moral atrocity – murder, torture, even genocide – may theoretically be the right thing to do, given some metaphysical or unearthly conditions. While of course I'm not endorsing any kind of such actions in real life, I think the introduction of those concepts into a game can be a most intriguing challenge for roleplayers, especially in Ravenloft, where themes of good and evil are central. How will the Dark Powers treat those kinds of behavior? Could they have some kind of esoteric moral knowledge, according to which the Darklords are actually paragons of virtue? Perhaps everything we conceive as good and evil is quite the opposite, and we are all prisoners of some demiurge who deludes us all (Kult), and only the DPs know the truth and try leading humanity toward it? Ravenloft might actually not be a prison, but a pocket of freedom in the cosmic net of deceit which is the multiverse…
Just some thoughts. It's good to be a philosopher!