Page 1 of 1
Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 6:12 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
We all know maps are a big interest of mine and also one of the biggest SNAFUs in the whole setting. In an age of mapping software, I appreciate a visual scale over the "1 inch = 10 miles" idea since I never know what aspect I'm looking at on my screen. That said, the Red Box poster maps have that visual scale, but one of them seems to be way out of whack. SOuragne is given a scale of 1 grid (which was an inch if I remember) is equal to 1 square mile. Whoa! Compared to the Black Box maps, that is some serious shrinkage! Went looking for Souragne maps, NotWD, the Frat's Gazetteer, and the Mordent Cartographical Society all have maps without scales.
So the Red Box would have Souragne about the size of Staunton Bluffs, when it should really be closer to the size of Mordent or maybe Richemulot. Does that sound right?
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 6:21 pm
by steveflam
Strahdsbuddy wrote:We all know maps are a big interest of mine and also one of the biggest SNAFUs in the whole setting. In an age of mapping software, I appreciate a visual scale over the "1 inch = 10 miles" idea since I never know what aspect I'm looking at on my screen. That said, the Red Box poster maps have that visual scale, but one of them seems to be way out of whack. SOuragne is given a scale of 1 grid (which was an inch if I remember) is equal to 1 square mile. Whoa! Compared to the Black Box maps, that is some serious shrinkage! Went looking for Souragne maps, NotWD, the Frat's Gazetteer, and the Mordent Cartographical Society all have maps without scales.
So the Red Box would have Souragne about the size of Staunton Bluffs, when it should really be closer to the size of Mordent or maybe Richemulot. Does that sound right?
Shouldn't the map in any game reflect how much you have each Domain populated? [Did that make sense?] What I mean is every DM is different in their perception of how populated RL is.
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 6:24 pm
by ewancummins
I tripled the usual scale and quintupled the population figures. That gave me a Core roughly comparable to the Thirteen Colonies of 1775, in terms of both area and number of inhabitants.
Not all islands get the same increase, IMC. Like Tarlyn says, it depends to a great extent on the population I want for the island in question.
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 6:27 pm
by steveflam
Like ewan, I find the original RL scaling too small and made mine bigger too

Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 6:33 pm
by ewancummins
tarlyn wrote:Like ewan, I find the original RL scaling too small and made mine bigger too

I find that a larger Core with more people works best for my games. I have plenty of room for wilderness, farmland, small villages not shown on the canon maps, etc. Still, the whole of the Core is not large. By Earth standards, it's a very small continent.
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 6:48 pm
by Galeros
I like a small Core.

Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 7:35 pm
by ewancummins
Galeros wrote:I like a small Core.

I still consider x3 scale to be fairly small. It's just not
tiny.
IMC, the scale increase meshes nicely with the variation in 'cultural level.'
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 8:41 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I knew the size multipliers would chime in here. I absolutely appreciate the choice people make regarding the size of the Core, etc. I've even chimed in on some of the older posts regarding this topic.
I was specifically talking about the two maps, did the scale change from Black Box to Red Box? The canon understanding of scale is what I'm interested in for the map I'm building (see "RL in Minecraft" thread). It seems like the scale did not change much, but if the Red Box is right, then Souragne is only slightly larger than Staunton Bluffs, which it dwarfed on the Black Box map.
As Ewan is famous for saying, YMMV, and I think every one of us takes some liberties with the maps. I think that's why a canon map is so important since it is the starting point for all of us.
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 8:56 pm
by ewancummins
Strahdsbuddy wrote:
As Ewan is famous for saying, YMMV, and I think every one of us takes some liberties with the maps. I think that's why a canon map is so important since it is the starting point for all of us.
There really is no single, coherent, canonical scale for maps of Ravenloft. Too many of the sources conflict, or simply don't give scale. The modules don't always agree on travel times, distances, and so on. I'd suggest you just pick whatever suits you best.
If you really want it 'canonical' I'd go with the Black Box maps and scale- but that's just me.
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 9:04 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I swear by the Black Box, as I think Gomez did when he was running the Mordent Cartographical Society. It is a decent starting point, imo, with a Core about the size of Switzerland, stretching to about the size of Austria with the seas included. It allows your 3x conversion and other people's 10x conversions easily enough. Like Galeros, I prefer a small Core.
One thing this project is teaching me is that even this small Core is going to be a pain to map, and will take a good amount of time to walk across! without access to cars and airplanes, Switzerland is plenty wide!
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Wed May 11, 2011 6:13 am
by BedrockBrendan
I tend to prefer a small core as well. I also like the lower population sizes.
Whoa, big jump!
Posted: Thu Aug 18, 2011 7:06 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
As I continue to bang away at this map of mine, I have decided to not reinvent the wheel and am utilizing as many sources as I can find. As said earlier, the modules sometimes contradict the campaign settings as far as scale goes. Would those comments be a reference to the map in Death Ascendant, which is zoomed in pretty heavily over northern Falkovnia and southern Darkon, yet the scale indicates a distance of 25 MILES; making the entire zoomed in section over 200 miles across, which is about 3/4 the way across all of Darkon. Black Box measurements would make it about 18 miles from Neufurchtenburg to Stangengrad, straight line distance. The DA map makes that distance about 89 miles.
I guess my question is, since we know many of our boardmates have increased the scale, when did the designers decide to do the same thing? My big problem with the DA map is the relatively detailed city maps at scale. As with my Kalidnay complaint, you can't just make a small city 15 miles wide. This is equal to the diameter of New York's Five Burroughs. In other words: huge.
Re: Changing Map Scale...a Ravenloft Favorite!
Posted: Fri Sep 30, 2011 1:02 pm
by Rudolf Weathermay
distances are indeed a "problem". If you read the novel spectre of the black rose the say the distance from the city of Har-Thelen to the most eastern border is about 150 mile. That is almost exactly as mentioned in the red box. Even the distance between Karina and the castle where one of the Malochio's live is the same as you read the evil eye and the red boxed set. If you read the domains of darkness those distances are much smaller.
If you take Keening then most sources claim this place is about 10 miles width. If you take the red boxed set and check this one too you figure out that Keening is about 100 miles there.
Personally I prefer the red box distances, but I don't like the idea to make Keening 100 miles. A solution can be very simple. Once you crossed a border distances can become different. Just like the Jann in Dark Sun who are living in tents which are much bigger on the inside than on the outside.