Page 1 of 2
Complaints from my player
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 12:09 pm
by Kraken(rpgworld)
Copy-pasted from rusian forum
On this forum was a lot of opinions about Raven from the masters, and more - from the "outsiders and impartial observers." And curiously - almost no one spoke from the perspective of an average player.
I decided to give my little IMHO.
im dislike ravenloft
1. Generation of chars
Here we have to very nice choose - your char is "guest" or "native of RL"?
While playing the "guest", «very friendly» world of Gothic Horrors can please you the following things:
- The Common Language is dead in RL.
All questions answered DM that the domain is taken from the world where The Common Language is dead, and he has never been. To the question "HUH?!? What is this world is?" DM pointedly silent.
All the arguments that the former half of Europe spoke Latin, and now spoke american will be ignored.
-Your coins can not be accepted by local
or even worse - they count them fake
-Transition in The Mists is not safe.
In the computer «Ravenloft: Strahd's Possession» passing through the Good Mists is dangerous for your inventory. With the beginnig transition "Forgotten Realms - Ravenloft" part of the important items is lost. With the in-game transition in the Mists one randomly item in party`s inventory is cursed, and it should be discarded.
-Visitors here do not like a little less than everywhere
While playing the native's get ready to study the Gothic cliches. They already overused in last 300 ages , but 99% DMs rediscovers them again and consider myself very creative (and these methods the original).
While playing the native's get ready for one of these VUS (Very Unexpected Surprises) (probably all)
-Your parents are long dead, but you do not know it. More on the early adventures, they become ghosts or mummies
-Your favorite - the vampire
-Your old friends adventuring – likens, dopelgangers or controlled by an evil mag-item.
-Your children have found a book on black magic and obsessed with FIEND.
Even worst-case scenario - a real baby died, and inconsolable relatives create the artificial. In this scenario, get ready for a hot meeting with clockwork baby and baby real, returning as undead. They will find out "who you like best?", and along with "who will kill more of your relatives?".
-If for you at the tavern came three and say, "thou shalt fourth in the adventurers party?", it is either the robbers or cultists, searching for trustfu travelers.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 2:59 pm
by ewancummins
Hmmmm.....it siounds like the player either :
A) Has a DM who sees Ravenloft as a 'Hellworld'.
B) Just doesn't like horror gaming, esp. Gothic horror.
If A is the problem, the solution is to play in another campaign. My Ravenloft is grim and gritty at times, darkly romantic at others- but it is not a 'Hellworld.' Tastes vary a lot.
As for B- why would you want to play in a Gothic setting if you hate Gothic Horror?
I don't see what the player's argument about Europe and Latin has got to do with Ravenloft. This is not Europe.
That said, I always make sure that the PCs share a language, unless a player specifically wishes to play a PC who has trouble communicating with the party,
If the player is objecting to the lack of a single, worldwide 'Common' language- I say,
quit whining.
Coins not accepted? Hmmm, sounds like a local issue. IMC, foreign coins made of precious metals are
generally accepted across the civilized world, although of course some localities have laws respecting moneychanging and such.
The Mists stealing items? Sure, maybe as a plot device. Randomly? No, I wouldn't do that. Other DMs may feel otherwise.
VUSs? Heh, not all of them, nor all in one game. To me, that would seem way too over the top.
That said, does the player really object to the DM using a
VAMPIRE in play? Geeze. I wouldn't want this player in my campaign. He sounds like someone who just doesn't like Gothic horror.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 6:06 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Agreed with ewan , it sounds like our friend doesn't like horror gaming, and probably is a powergamer who doesn't like his powers messed with. This is actually fine, there is no 'right' way to play rpgs. Still, I have found that the people who enjoy Ravenloft (us) love it, and those that don't have already made up their mind about what they think it is. One bad experience with the special "rules" (which are really guidelines) is usually enough to sour the average ADD-afflicted gamer on the entire setting. Good to know there's ADD in Russia, too.
This does bring up an interesting point, though. Some eager Ravenloft DMs want to get right to the horror. Hitting 1st level characters with heavy-handed restrictions is more than a little frustrating. I think this just reaffirms the fact that Ravenloft requires a talented DM and good role players to work. I'd say we are a niche, but a significant niche. The only setting I've heard discussed ALMOST as much as Ravenloft over the years has been Planescape.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 7:37 pm
by alhoon
I wouldn't call him powergamer, I would call him a player that doesn't like gothic horror/ "gothic" horror.
PS. I liked the cliches mentioned!

They put me into mood for Ravenloft. Undead parents, vampires, cultists&fiendish books, golem babies.
I like those things! Add a couple of restless dead in though.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 8:04 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
alhoon wrote:I wouldn't call him powergamer, I would call him a player that doesn't like gothic horror/ "gothic" horror.
PS. I liked the cliches mentioned!

They put me into mood for Ravenloft. Undead parents, vampires, cultists&fiendish books, golem babies.
I like those things! Add a couple of restless dead in though.
lol yeah alhoon, that must have been the only VRG he didn't have!
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 10:07 am
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I liked the cliches mentioned!

They put me into mood for Ravenloft. Undead parents, vampires, cultists&fiendish books, golem babies.
I like those things! Add a couple of restless dead in though.
It's odd that one set of cliches is singled out and dismissed as overused, when standard D&D tends to default to a quest storyline that's 2500 years old... at least. I object more to the "find the magical MacGuffin" plot than most of the plots he suggested.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 1:04 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:. I object more to the "find the magical MacGuffin" plot than most of the plots he suggested.
I don't object to any of the plots he suggested at all. They seemed good.

Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 2:10 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Yup, it seems like a case of not liking the genre, plus being tainted by the PC game. I'd let the player know that the Mists only steal/curse items when it's good for the story, that Ravenloft in general is based as heavily on gothic horrror stories as regular D&D is on fantasy adventure stories. If he's not willing to play part of that kind of story (and who doesn't love a creepy clockwork baby?) then he shouldn't waste his time with a Ravenloft campaign.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 3:38 pm
by Kraken(rpgworld)
Continue of his RL criticism:
2. Tendency to linear plots.
General problem in all horror games is lack of incentive.
The normal human reaction to fear is trying to hide or escape.
For this reason, a good horror game define the goal for players to escape from the terrible place (resident evil, Silent Hill, Forbidden siren), or to hide from the scary person (clock tower, Forbidden siren).
Unfortunately, in RL all the wrong way round.
Setting offers many tools for the ruthless suppression of attempts to flee or hide.
Old products have been designed in the style of "Weekend with Freddy Krueger, or escape from the World of Horrors."
Later this gamestyle was found to plot-scanty and uninteresting.
And introduced the idea of playing for the natives of RL, under the under the slogan of «it's their own world, because they do not want to run away from it» (according to this logic of « Cuba is native country for Cubans, because they do not want to run away from it»).
This eliminated the problem of «trying to escape the players from the world of horror», but not eliminated the problem of «trying to escape the players from the source of danger».
Therefore, all official adventures is shamelessly linear, and mercilessly punishing not only for attempts to stray from the plot, but also for trying to stand still, not moving through the plot.
IMHO The best solution to this problem proposed game «The Path» (2009 game developed by Tale of Tales)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Path_(video_game)
The reasoning of this game is simple and very logical.
If Little Red Riding Hood would have been exemplary and obedient girl, without turning off the path, and not talking to the wolves - it would have nothing bad would have happened.
Like millions of other girls she would have happily lived to old age, nothing standing out from the gray crowd of other girls like her.
And The Fairy-Tale about her would never have been created.
«The Path» - this is the only one game where you need to voluntarily and consciously to feed the hero to monster, that he entered into The Fairy-Tale.
I think this game really scary and gothic, and I like it.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 4:12 pm
by ewancummins
The Path sounds interesting.
Again, though, I think the player is missing something important. Has he ever read Dracula? The heroes aren't merely hiding or running away all the time- they are HUNTING DRACULA!
Ravenloft is as much about brave monster hunters and cunning investigators as it is about fainting ladies and terrified peasants.
The hero is a man who
confronts horrors.
PCs in Ravenloft are a cut above the masses of weaker NPCs, just as in other worlds. They have extraordinary fighting abilities, magic powers, special skills, etc.
I don't see what the player is on about, unless he simply can't stand some minor restrictions on some few powers/spells, and the fear/horror/madness checks. Part of the appeal of the setting for many of us, I think, is that it 'de-munchkinizes' things a bit, without actually stripping PCs of all their power. Yes, sometimes it's a damn good idea to flee. That's true even in 'regular' D&D.
Maybe his DM is just really, really good at scaring him?
I notice that he continues to refer to 'official' products, but doesn't talk much about his own gaming experiences of Ravenloft. I have never played or run most of the 'official modules. I really don't think it's fair or wise to judge a setting just by modules, though. I thought the original Dragonlance modules were way too linear. I thought the Avatar modules for FR were too linear. Does that mean I think DL and FR suck? No, not at all! Both worlds are very well-developed settings with tons of cool features.
Has this player ever actually played in a Ravenloft campaign? Just one DM? Is he basing everything off his impression of some modules and a video game?
As ever, YMMV
PS- Why Silent Hill? Resident Evil? Those are video games, yes? Isn't that stuff 'survival horror?" It's not Gothic, IMO. I find it curious that he didn't bring up Dracula, Frankenstein, The Castle of Otranto, the House with the Clock in its Walls, etc, etc.
Why video games and not actual Gothic stories?
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 4:51 pm
by Kraken(rpgworld)
Answer
In my childhood i was upset cartoon «Tom and Jerry».
Tom is big and strong, but small Jerry constantly mocks the poor cat, and I felt sorry for Tom.
In «Dracula», The Vampyre is big and strong, but party of commoners hunting on vampire prince (in theory it should be the opposite – Dracula must hunting the party).
I suppose the reason for this - Dracula is actually weaker party, because it abuse his weaknesses.
When watching "Dracula" or "Buffy" I hit the unfairness "Vampire Hunter abuse the weakness of their enemy (garlic, woodstake). Why did the vampire do not abuse the weakness of your enemy(firearm)? "
My thirst for justice was satisfied in «Forbidden siren».
In this game the enemies (Japanese zombie «the shibito») are actively using firearms, and a good shot instantly kills the hero.
And the enemies(«the shibito») are immortal, in the defeat of weapons they do not die and lose consciousness.
Therefore, in this game you have a lot to hide from enemies.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 4:56 pm
by ewancummins
Ah........

Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 5:47 pm
by alhoon
Ehhh...
- Night of the walking dead?
- Many of my adventures have been throughoutly trashed because my players said "Nah, I don't want to go there". I don't often
force them through the mists in the bad place where their only hope is too get out.
- Why can't a character run and hide from the big bad monster? Many Ravenloft adventures I've read over here aren't "kill the bad monster/boss" but "escape before you're chopped!"
- Heroes abusing a monster's weakness?

Ehh... most of the ghost adventures I play and some with mummies are actually about finding the weaknesses of said evil creature. The fight in the end is just for climatic finale.
Some of the examples he gives of what he doesn't like make sense. I also don't like things like being forced to follow the story and not having a choice to
not stray from the path. Ask my sister how many adventures have flied out of the window because she decided to not follow the plot. My other players are usually worse BTW. 2/3 of my adventures with them, end up unplayed because... they don't want to go there.
"The baron offers 2000 gold for brave men and women to go rescue his daughter from the mad wizard I-pawn-you!"
"Really? Gather info, total 22 what I learned about him?"
"Well... he sent the magical monsters he created on the baron's guard that they chopped through them, while he unleashed magical fire that consumed the wagon of her bodyguards along with sir but-I-was-gooood, a knight known for his martial prowess"
"just 2000 gold to go against that?!? I whistle by passing in front of the crier"
In such a case, I
don't have the baron suddenly discover a fortune. If his whole fortune is 2000 gold pieces, including manor, that's it. If the PCs don't take pity on him... the adventure is wasted.
I also dislike hitting loved ones all the time, or places they hold dear. If I give the PCs a manor I may have them defend it from time to time, but it won't be a liability. Also their relatives aren't always in danger nor involved in every bad thing in the world.
HOWEVER: A clockwork baby killing relatives would certainly draw them in. As others said "Who doesn't love clockwork babies?"
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 6:24 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
He has a fair point about Dracula not taking advantage of human weaknesses....unless you count Lucy...and Mina...and Harker...and everyone he kills. The restrictions on the traditional vampire are actually pretty sufficient, particularly the coma-like state during human's natural activity cycle. For these reasons, Dracula actually had to be careful, sort of like a human.
Ewan is right, this player seems to be overlapping his Gothic Horror with his Survival Horror. Even in Resident Evil the player has enough firepower to not have to run from a lot of encounters. Clock Tower is different, obviously (and one of the creepiest games EVER) but it seems like our critic hates the idea of running from anything. I don't like throwing around the word "munchkin" on guys I haven't gamed with, but I have to say the majority of gamers lean that way. Even the good ol Ravenlofties feel that way sometimes.
He seems to be familiar enough with the modules to know how the setting evolved from "Weekend in Hell" to "Not in My Town." I think we all agree this was a positive direction. I'd say his Cuba analogy is a little amusing. Sure SOME people ride boats made of refrigerators to Florida, but I'd say MOST Cubans value their country and their land and their families and their neighbors and their lives enough to want to stay. Sort of like Ravenloft.
I'm not exactly sure how all the fleshing out of the setting in products like Domains of Dread could lead to linear storylines. It almost seems like our friend is determined not to like the setting. I don't know the cure for that.
Re: Complaints from my player
Posted: Fri May 20, 2011 7:14 pm
by ewancummins
Yup.
It sounds as if he expects horror to always be survival horror- but then he doesn't even want to roleplay the running and hiding bits.
I'm not a big fan of the 'hellworld' approach, in any case. It just doesn't work for me.
Again, and always, this is all IMC and YMMV.