Page 1 of 1

A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 1:20 pm
by The Wolfman
I posted this question to the SJ Games forum and while I received several interesting replies, none of them really answered my question.

I'm starting up a new RL game and I want to use cut scenes, which I have never used; nor have I ever been in a game that used them. If you guys use them, how do you use them? How do you introduce them? I imagine you don't say "and now for a cut scene!"

Also, there appears to be some confusion as to what exactly I mean by "cut scene." I was under the impression that it meant that the GM describes a scene that the PCs wouldn't be privy to, but help to set the scene or provide tension or foreshadowing. However, several people (including one of friends with whom I game each week) has described cut scenes as "the GM gives the players a scenario and some disposable characters, and then has them act out a scene."

In the main plot of the first game, I decided to have a crazed worshiper or Erlin (hence my earlier post) attempting to make a bone golem as a servitor and warrior, to show his respect and (twisted) love for his god. Hey he's crazy, OK? The PCs will be working on discovering his plot and stopping him (he's been digging up the graves of people who died in various horrible ways--I'm ignoring the bit about the bones having to have come from animated skeletons--and thus leaving a trail to his lair, plus, he'll eventually turn to murder). They won't actually have to destroy the animated golem (unless they ignore the plot for a month or two) because while I'm not looking for a TPK on the first adventure.

The cut scene I had in mind was a wonderful image I had of the worshiper slicing his arm and using his own blood to paint eldritch symbols on the bones. While I can describe the blood-symbols on the bones and the unpleasant-looking and probably infected cuts on his arms, I think it would be much more effective to tell the PCs about it (without, of course, revealing who the figure is).

So...what sort of cut scenes have you guys used, and how have you used them?

(BTW, if anyone has any critiques of my adventure idea, feel free to give 'em)

Thanks!

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 5:43 pm
by Jack of Tears
There are a few different types of cut scenes one can use when rping, and all of them have a place in the game if the GM wishes. I have made extensive use of the cutscene style you are suggesting and typically I find the best way to do it is take a moment of pause, hold up a finger or the like to let people know they should not speak, and then go into the description ... when you are done, just leap into the next scene and make it clear - through speech, a motion, whatever - that you are now returning them to their regularly scheduled game.

If you intend to open the adventure with the scene, just let everyone get ready, motion then to silence and do it. If you want to intersperse the game with more such scenes, make it clear, (through demonstration the first time or two you do it) that you have a certain signal to indicate the Players should stop and listen. Very likely, the first or second time you do this, one of the players will ask, "did we see this? Did we dream this?" and you simply answer, "no, that's happening elsewhere" or something to that effect.

You might, also, preface a cutscene with a phrase like, "elsewhere", "meanwhile" or "in the next room".

I once made dramatic use of cutscenes right up to the point the PCs burst in on the Villain in action - I'd run a room or an encounter, then I'd hold up my hand to indicate a "stop" and describe what was happening in the mad scientist's lab ... I'd then snap my finger, point at the players and pick up again where I'd left them off ... rinse and repeat; speeding up the frequency of cuts as they got nearer and nearer their destination. (and the villain got closer and closer to finishing his task) I think the "snap-point" action worked very well to punctuate the end of each scene and build up a sense of urgency as they moved.

I don't know if any of that was helpful ...

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 5:56 pm
by steveflam
I use cut scenes as well, but it has nothing to do with the current scene. I have two or one up thus far in my game for my pc's
to see and assimulate. Cut scenes are ok;)

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Sun Jul 03, 2011 9:53 pm
by ewancummins
I have made occasional use of cut scenes. IMO, these should be used sparingly- too much and the game seems like fanfic.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 7:24 am
by Jack of Tears
ewancummins wrote:I have made occasional use of cut scenes. IMO, these should be used sparingly- too much and the game seems like fanfic.
That's kind of an odd statement, considering all games are basically fanfiction. I do get what you're saying, though, if a GM spends too much time on Cutscenes he's basically telling a story, rather than running a game. I should think most GMs are aware enough to tell the difference, however.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 11:03 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
here's a previous thread on the topic:
http://fraternityofshadows.com/forum/vi ... f=1&t=7255

I won't duplicate my answer here, but it's in that thread.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 11:24 am
by Jack of Tears
Joël of the FoS wrote: Same topic, another question. How do you justify these in game? I usually say they "all have the same dream", or the same vision.

Joël
Pulled this question from the other thread. In answer: I just do them. Cutscenes are used to good effect in other forms of media, why not interactive storytelling as well? To me it seems less eloquent and a bit cheesier to say "everyone has this dream" ... I'd rather just drop the scene in when appropriate and leave players with the understanding that this is a scene happening elsewhere.

Mind you, I haven't used this nearly so often in Ravenloft as I did in my Star Wars campaign - which, as a setting, is significantly more cinematic.

Still, this is a great way to give players an insight into something that revealing won't ruin the game.

If I were to use it as a means to reveal a Darklord's background - as is suggested a couple times in the other thread - I would probably break the scene into pieces that I opened each session, or each stretch of the adventure, with. (though in Ravenloft I tend to like the "mystery and uncertainty" aspect a great deal, so don't let go of my secrets very easily)

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 4:40 pm
by Hazgarn
I'm starting out a game with a group of all beginners (not that I'm exactly seasoned, but the players are all new to both Ravenloft and DnD, so...). I haven't begun things yet, but the first session is going to be a "prologue" to the rest of campaign as a whole, with the characters running throw-aways with more or less identical stats to their PCs. The purpose of the prologue is to give the players a chance to get the hang of the setting and the system before putting the characters they like at risk. It's set on a ship traveling through the Mists, with an NPC similar to Gibbs from Pirates of the Carribbean who can spout out bits of lore connected to the encounters, and the setting.

Naturally, the throwaways eventually come to a bad end, and the players should be able to discover their fate in the first "real" session. I plan on using the "same dream" explanation, because I feel that it works for a foreboding start to a campaign.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:09 pm
by Jack of Tears
Hazgarn wrote: Naturally, the throwaways eventually come to a bad end, and the players should be able to discover their fate in the first "real" session. I plan on using the "same dream" explanation, because I feel that it works for a foreboding start to a campaign.
Works even better if, when they find their "throw aways" dead on a beach, or whatnot, they realize they are identical to the PCs themselves. This creates a foreboding dread, a sense of "from whence did these come and what does it portend for us?". You could take that subtle bit of "teaching them the ropes" and spin it into an entire side story that follows them along the course of their adventures. What happens when they go into a town where one of them apparently already has a reputation; or another town where an old woman with one blind eye follows them and accusingly proclaims to one character - "You are dead, the stones foretold it, I saw it in the eyes of a dying cat ... you are dead and floating ... still floating!".

Perhaps they go into a certain playhouse and discover the production at hand is a faithful retelling of the fates of their "throw aways" ... (in fact, the play might be called "The Discarded")

You needn't, and even shouldn't, make that the central focus of the story ... just drop things like that in from time to time to make the characters, (and players) wonder what in the grey mists is going on!?

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 10:45 pm
by Germaine
I have long made extensive use of cut scenes in my games-particularly my Ravenloft campaigns- mostly through the meanwhile/elsewhere method. I find that it helps clarify background, plot, and character, effectively foreshadows future events, and helps establish the Hitchcockian idea of suspense- ii.e. the bomb you know is under the table, as opposed to just a sudden explosion. By the way, Wolfman, I think you have the right idea about foregoing the animated skeletons- though I think I would make it a "golem of obsession" as per VRGttC. You're also right about the TPK. When I ran Circle of Darkness with a decent-sized party of fairly high-level characters, the bone golem therein proved...unexpectedly challenging to them.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Tue Jul 05, 2011 9:07 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Never did comment on your campaign specifically:
a) I think this is a perfect use for a cut scene
b) If you do want to have them fight the golem, but with less TPK risk, perhaps try the "Skeletal Golem" from our Nocturnal Sea Gaz.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Tue Jul 05, 2011 5:17 pm
by The Wolfman
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Never did comment on your campaign specifically:
a) I think this is a perfect use for a cut scene
b) If you do want to have them fight the golem, but with less TPK risk, perhaps try the "Skeletal Golem" from our Nocturnal Sea Gaz.
Thanks!

I checked out the skeletal golem--I haven't gotten that far in the Gazetteer yet--and it definitely has some possibilities. I like the four arms. That'll definitely freak my players out.

It may come to the golem being completed, if they spend too much time on the subplot. I did the subplot specifically to get the interest in two of the players: it involves a breath-sucking water faery and those two PCs are from Tepest and really enjoy playing anti-faery superstitious yokels. As this is the first adventure, those two have drifted in from the Mists along the shore of Lake Zorovich, I thought a good way to get them to head to the town would be to help the dead/dying man they find on the beach.

This may take their attention away from the grave robbing for a while...although the first (known) grave-robbing is of a martyred priest of the Morninglord, dug up from the Vallaki temple's cemetary, and one of the PCs is a priestess of that religion. So I really don't know how it'll go.

As long as they don't try to burn the town down again. My PCs have definitely mastered the "kill it with fire" aspect of horror gaming.

Re: A Question of Cut Scenes

Posted: Wed Jul 06, 2011 3:11 pm
by alhoon
I would agree that cutscenes should be used sparingly. Sometimes I use cutscenes as cutscenes but other times I just use them as dreams or visions by the PCs. You see, not all players like cutscenes. Some feel it detracts them from playing their character to suddenly listen to what X guy is doing in his home.