Page 1 of 1
Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2011 2:36 pm
by Kraken(rpgworld)
All the moments associated with the emotions should be as small as possible and linked to game mechanics or game stats.
The master is not in any case should not dictate emotions.
The official RL product says that if the player is scared and he good roleplay horror - horror checks not needed.
Otherwise, if a player is not scared and did not roleplay horror, using horror cheks and speak to the player who is not afraid "in the world of horror, and you're afraid" - the same as saying legless "you in the world of dance and dance with joy".
Usually, this is what psychologists call "frustration" and to put it simply - completely spoiled the mood.
Re: Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2011 5:21 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
The purpose of the horror check (or fear or madness) is as an incentive to role-play realistically. In a scene of absolute horror, would a human act like the Terminator and just go about killing everything in sight without pause? Would they be able to function after resolving the situation, or would he need to take a moment to collect himself?
It is up to the DM to determine if the player is doing his part to play the character, or if he is just eating chips and rolling dice. Ravenloft is a setting that is supposed to be spooky, even terrifying. If you, as the DM, feel you are doing your part of creating scary situations, you have the right to encourage players to buy into the fear of your setting by having them roll the checks if their response is not acceptable.
If you think the checks really detract from the game, you don't have to use them. Like everything else in the rulebook, you can use it if you think it is good, or ignore it f you think it is bad. Personally, I think responding to fearful or horrific scenes in a campaign is part of the fun. Explain to your players that unless they are playing the Terminator, they should not act like him.
Re: Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2011 6:07 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Kraken(rpgworld) wrote:The official RL product says that if the player is scared and he good roleplay horror - horror checks not needed.
Otherwise, if a player is not scared and did not roleplay horror, using horror cheks and speak to the player who is not afraid "in the world of horror, and you're afraid" - the same as saying legless "you in the world of dance and dance with joy".
Usually, this is what psychologists call "frustration" and to put it simply - completely spoiled the mood.
It's a design incentive, a goal to keep in mind. If you're "in a world of dance" and you don't set-up any music or joyful situations that's a problem. And if you're setting-up the perfect dance competition with a full 10 on the Kevin Baconometre and the player wants to stand against the wall you should have a quick talk to encourage role-playing or just tell him to man-up and roll a Perform (dance) check.
Re: Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Mon Aug 29, 2011 7:35 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
Indeed.
The horror check is just there to back up the DM. When something turlly horrific occurs, the players suffer the chance of losing control of themselves, just as would a real person in a traumatic event. Remember, few people want to break down emotionally and surrender control of their faculties during a crisis - yet they might do it anyway when they are pushed to their mental limits.
Players who are willing to embrace that kind of a role should be given the latitude to choose how their character reacts. Their mental trauma becomes part of the character and builds the role. That functions as the carrot.
The possibility of forced horror check is the stick in the equation. If the player won't roleplay their character's emotional turmoil, they can attempt to soldier through it, at the risk of completely losing control.
Re: Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Tue Aug 30, 2011 10:07 am
by MichaelTumey
Long ago, back in 2e days, I had a player who was running a paladin - it was very hard to get this player willing to display the horror aspect of the setting. He was a paladin afterall and reminded me of that all the time. He had to roll on the Horror check chart all the time as I couldn't get him to feel the fear. He was eventually killed in a charge against beings far too dangerous for him to do that, which led to a state of ghostdom, that the player could not really deal with. Of all my players, this one was most out of water in Ravenloft, and the Horror check was the only thing 'keeping him real'. Even then it wasn't enough. Ravenloft turns out to be 'not for everyone.'
Re: Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2011 7:41 am
by BedrockBrendan
Kraken(rpgworld) wrote:All the moments associated with the emotions should be as small as possible and linked to game mechanics or game stats.
The master is not in any case should not dictate emotions.
The official RL product says that if the player is scared and he good roleplay horror - horror checks not needed.
Otherwise, if a player is not scared and did not roleplay horror, using horror cheks and speak to the player who is not afraid "in the world of horror, and you're afraid" - the same as saying legless "you in the world of dance and dance with joy".
Usually, this is what psychologists call "frustration" and to put it simply - completely spoiled the mood.
Except a failed horror check can greatly enhance a players experience of the fear by depriving them of the ability to fully defend and control their characters. A little like not being able to move in a scary dream. Horror Checks are the big guns, really more for bizarre and unnatural situations that impact the character for months. Fear Checks are the ones you want for moments where the character is simply affraid.
I find most players handle Horror and Fear checks just fine. There is a small subset of players who bristle, but I don't think those players are a good match for Ravenloft campaigns anyways (as the setting is filled with things that make them bristle in a similar way).
Re: Fail with Horror Checks (plz help)
Posted: Thu Sep 08, 2011 12:05 am
by vipera aspis
Right. Bedrock brings up a good point.
Insert chase scene, with unknown pursuer..
"momentary hiding in the dark woolen layers of winter cloaks in a bedroom closet: your rogue hears the door slowly creak a-jar; while something heavy and sharp can be heard dragging just behind. Holding your breath and peering softly through the folds of musty cloth, pale moonlight shines dimly through the open window, illuminating a hulking figure in the doorway with a limp neck; dragging a rusty headman's axe.."
-possible fear check, given the rogues obvious concealment and momentary control of the situation
"blindly and swiftly ducking into the dark woolen layers of winter cloaks in a bedroom closet: your rogue's blood runs cold as she hears the just-closed door slowly creak a-jar; something heavy can be heard dragging into the room as the door creaks closed. Barely controlling your breath and forcing your eyes open you peer your head from the folds: noticing in the cold moonlight a reveled sleeping figure atop the moldy straw mattress beneath the latched window and a looming, hulking figure; raising a large rusted headman's axe. Eye's wide, seconds turn to hours as the axe sweeps down at a sharp angle into the dreamer's ribcage; cracking the victim wide like a clam and spraying the open closet with..."
-possible horror check, given the rogues only possible concealment, lack of escape route and personal connection with the moment at hand