Page 1 of 1

Question on power checks

Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 2:28 pm
by Vlad
Having read the power check rules a zillion times in black/red box, DoD and 3ed, I just noticed something I never noticed before (or I did, only the question cam eto me yesterday). Why is it less evil to disobey a tenet of an evil religion than a good one? (assuming the person doing it has the same alignment as the religion. I would assume that it doesn't matter how the alignment of the religion is with regard to disobeying the tenets, etc.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 5:01 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
One would presume that the tenets of an evil religion would be, you know, evil things. By disobeying them, you'd be doing something good, no? That wouldn't seem as powercheck worthy to me.

Wolf God tenet: eat a human once a week.

Andral tenet: thou shalt not eat humans.

Which one is more power-check worthy to disobey.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2011 7:53 pm
by HuManBing
This presumes that the Dark Powers are anthropomorphic and not, say, lyceomorphic.

Because from the viewpoint of a wolf, it's entirely plausible that a dead human is a good human.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 12:01 am
by High Priest Mikhal
Basically what Gonzoron said. Evil religions, regardless of one's own alignment, are still evil. So long as you're not an actual member there's no real penalty powers check wise to breaking their teachings. Politically, socially, and legally it's a whole other ball game if it's a public, powerful religion like the Lawgiver is in Nova Vaasa and Hazlan. Or if a secretive cult sends assassins after you for your "heresy."

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 6:51 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
HuManBing wrote:This presumes that the Dark Powers are anthropomorphic and not, say, lyceomorphic.
The Dark Powers themselves, who knows? But the rules the Dark Powers set for their world are definitely human(oid)-centered.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 7:48 am
by HuManBing
You're also presuming that the Dark Powers are rewarding good and punishing evil.

The canon text states it's entirely possible (ie up to the GM) that they're doing the exact opposite. Are they snatching up all these darklords because they want to "clean up the multiverse", or are they doing it because they love evil playthings?

Or indeed they might just be being completely arbitrary and whimsical about things.


In any case, the original poster's problem appears to slide into the larger categorical problems of morality in a DnD game, where something like "objective evil" actually exists.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 8:59 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
HuManBing wrote:You're also presuming that the Dark Powers are rewarding good and punishing evil.
Whether "failing" a powers check is a reward or punishment or both doesn't enter into the rationale for meriting a check. I agree, giving motive to the Dark Powers is futile, at least in a way that will satisfy everyone. But the constant from the beginning of the setting has been: here is a list of evil acts that will get the interest of the DPs. The more "evil" the act, the higher the chance they will bestow their "gifts" on you. Whether you or I believe in D&D's absolute evil/good doesn't matter as much as what the Dark Powers believe. Why don't know why they believe it, but we do know specifically the types of acts that they reward/punish.

They make a passing nod to cultural relativism in that the "grave robbing" sin only applies in cultures that place a heavy taboo on such things, and even in acknowledging that breaking an evil tenet is still breaking a tenet. But overall, they are more interested in standard D&D evil and less so in standard D&D good, and they are more interested in "good" or "neutral" races falling to evil than naturally evil races doing what comes naturally.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 2:01 pm
by Vlad
HuManBing wrote:You're also presuming that the Dark Powers are rewarding good and punishing evil.

The canon text states it's entirely possible (ie up to the GM) that they're doing the exact opposite. Are they snatching up all these darklords because they want to "clean up the multiverse", or are they doing it because they love evil playthings?

Or indeed they might just be being completely arbitrary and whimsical about things.


In any case, the original poster's problem appears to slide into the larger categorical problems of morality in a DnD game, where something like "objective evil" actually exists.
Well, since failing a power check comes with a curse, whereas the boon could in most cases be received otherwise (magic) as well, it seems a punishment. In that regard, evil characters (priests) are not punished for disobeying the tenets of their faith, whereas good ones are. So it seems they want evil people to stray from their faith, so could they be good? The way they torment their (evil) victims like animals in a cage combined to the fact they put some extra playthings in the form of innocent inhabitants in those cages, I tend to disagree to that... so I'm really puzzled about that tenet-thing..

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 3:14 pm
by Manofevil
We might also take the position that we continue to refer to the Dark PowerS<--PLURAL! implying that there is more than one. So perhaps one Dark Power is triggered by the torment of innocents, another by the violation of an oath, (i.e. the tenets of ones religion), still another by the violation of societal conventions (i.e. abortion-perhaps in one realm, say Dementlieu, the abortion of an unwanted children might be considered preservation of state resources, whereas, in another, maybe Lamordia, the murder of a child is considered one of the lowest, most depraved crimes.) Perhaps these Dark PowerS should be considered as diverse as the different forms of outrage which arise in the various peoples of societies in response to various crimes or actions.

Re: Question on power checks

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2011 9:45 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Whether or not there's several Dark Powers or just one, the canon material shows they "punish" evil with a boon and a curse all in the same package. They don't reward good; not attracting their attention is reward enough. Of course there are exception to every rule: in a culture that practices cannibalism of the dead it may not be a sin to eat the dead if they believed in such and wanted such a fate (VRGttWD). That is the most notable exception. Everything MOE mentioned is relevant in how diverse the morality from culture to culture is and should be treated as well.

The rule that using "evil" acts for good means warrants a halved chance of failure seems to show intent is just as vital. It's still evil and carries the chance of damnation but doesn't invite as much attention from the only true higher power(s) in Ravenloft.