Page 1 of 1
Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2011 10:16 am
by Joël of the FoS
I have a player looking to take this PrC.
Anyone had a player in his game using it? Good or bad in a game?
Joël
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2011 2:34 pm
by alhoon
As most PrC, it's a bit too specialized for my tastes. I've used an NPC HotD once and it was... OK. Aside from mechanics though, it gives good opportunities for RP so it helps.
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2011 6:58 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Refresh my memory, where is it from?
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2011 7:44 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
3.0 is from Defenders of the Faith, 3.5 version is in Complete Warrior.
I used it for a while on a DMPC before switching their class/PrCs and had pretty good experiences. Like alhoon says it's specialized (a "nemesis-based" PrC) but that just makes it more fun for role-play! One of the things I had to consider was their innate detect undead ability which normally has no saving throw. In Ravenloft the DC for a Will save is 10 + class level + Wis modifier, with undead darklords getting +4 to the save. Their Final Death ability is another issue I had to work around. It's not exactly fitting that any undead they slay by melee weapon or spell is permanently destroyed in Ravenloft. So instead I ruled that certain powerful undead were utterly immune (darklords, high-magnitude ghosts and ancients, old and older vampires, and liches of any level) while lesser undead who might return required a Will save (same DC as for detect undead), with failure meaning they were destroyed and success meaning they could still return unless their method required a save or check itself.
Some of their spells, like death ward, require powers checks if we go by the RAW. Death ward is properly an abjuration spell and manipulates positive energy to form a shield of sorts, so I house-ruled it never required a powers check (life ward, which manipulates negative energy, does). Then there are spells in various Ravenloft supplements (VRA being the most notable) that offer spells that would fit with the PrC where they deal with fighting the undead. I didn't have a problem adding more spells to the class list, but that's up to the individual DM.
All in all I didn't have many problems with it even when a player picked it up. I'd already looked at how the abilities would work (or wouldn't work) and things went pretty smoothly. The only real problem is if the campaign is very undead-heavy or not featuring enough undead. Too many and the HotD often stole the spotlight and too little didn't give the player a chance to stand out.
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2011 7:05 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Thank you for yout thoughts. It's for a player that will be something like C1/F4/HuD2 (his lycanthrope PC went for a rampage and that had him ... terminated)
High Priest Mikhal wrote: One of the things I had to consider was their innate detect undead ability which normally has no saving throw. In Ravenloft the DC for a Will save is 10 + class level + Wis modifier, with undead darklords getting +4 to the save.
That
at will ability bugs me a little. Could be a pain in the butt for RL DMs, no? I'm considering limiting it to a number of times per day (like their charisma bonus).
Their Final Death ability is another issue I had to work around. It's not exactly fitting that any undead they slay by melee weapon or spell is permanently destroyed in Ravenloft. So instead I ruled that certain powerful undead were utterly immune (darklords, high-magnitude ghosts and ancients, old and older vampires, and liches of any level)
Indeed, that's cool. I think that all undead with greater HD than his level are allowed a save?
Then there are spells in various Ravenloft supplements (VRA being the most notable) that offer spells that would fit with the PrC where they deal with fighting the undead. I didn't have a problem adding more spells to the class list, but that's up to the individual DM.
Good idea, I'll look at the list.
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2011 7:52 pm
by alhoon
I don't remember that "true death" thing. Does it really destroyes undead that return?
IMO, it could be changed to "the undead you slay cannot be re-animated". Like HoD slays zombie. Zombie lord cannot reanimate it the next round. Actually I think that's what "can never rise again" means, not that a lich is severed from the phylactery or a vampire doesn't become mist. It says "undead slain" Ghosts, vampires, some restless etc aren't really slain, they just drop, disappear or other otherwise disabled.
As for detect undead at will down to charisma bonus is a bit hard, since D.U has a save now. I would think 3 times/day + cha bonus would be OK.
As of Undead light campaigns: Yeap, it's a trade-off. They still can fight properly though so they're not useless. Just... less useful.
Undead heavy campaigns: I don't think he would take the spotlight actually. Detect undead is useful, but not in combat. Smite undead for a +3hr, +5 damage in 5th lvl 2/day isn't terrible either. The +wisdom (+2 to +3) to saves vs undead is good but ...
let's face it: cleric or paladin levels would be better for exactly the same thing. I.e. a 7th lvl cleric/3rd lvl HoD is worse vs undead than a 10th lvl cleric. A cl1/F4/HoD2 is also worse than Cl3/F4 too.

Effectively you traded 2nd lvl spells like bull's strength for 1 smite per day.
All in all, it's a decent class if you want to play against undead but it's not as overpowered as the cleric is. So I would recommend it. It also gives opportunities for RP and the player + the others on the table will propably have fun.
Joel: What is the hr requirement for HoD? Isn't it 5? If so, a cl1/F4 couldn't be a HoD.
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2011 2:46 pm
by Joël of the FoS
alhoon wrote: Joel: What is the hr requirement for HoD? Isn't it 5? If so, a cl1/F4 couldn't be a HoD.
Bab of +5 indeed, and the final player choice (we rolled his stats this morning) will be Pal5/HoD2.
We'll se how it goes
Joël
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2011 6:54 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Joël of the FoS wrote:High Priest Mikhal wrote: One of the things I had to consider was their innate detect undead ability which normally has no saving throw. In Ravenloft the DC for a Will save is 10 + class level + Wis modifier, with undead darklords getting +4 to the save.
That
at will ability bugs me a little. Could be a pain in the butt for RL DMs, no? I'm considering limiting it to a number of times per day (like their charisma bonus).
No more so than a paladin's
detect chaos ability. Granted rolling an individual Will save for each undead in a mass (and I used some) is a nightmare, averaging the Will save for undead not meant as unique worked well for me. Lower level HotD often faced the aggravation of their ability being misleading at best. As they went up in level the ability became more reliable thanks to a higher DC. A fitting reward for sticking to such a narrow path IMHO.
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Sun Sep 25, 2011 7:07 pm
by Galeros
High Priest Mikhal wrote:A fitting reward for sticking to such a narrow path IMHO.
It may be a narrow path, but playing one in Ravenloft widens it a bit, do you not think so?

Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 11:48 am
by High Priest Mikhal
Galeros wrote:High Priest Mikhal wrote:A fitting reward for sticking to such a narrow path IMHO.
It may be a narrow path, but playing one in Ravenloft widens it a bit, do you not think so?

Actually, no. Ravenloft is more than just the undead. Yes, they're more powerful and in some domains more prevalent. But there's the caveat: they're only as prevalent as the DM wants.
Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 12:11 pm
by Galeros
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Galeros wrote:High Priest Mikhal wrote:A fitting reward for sticking to such a narrow path IMHO.
It may be a narrow path, but playing one in Ravenloft widens it a bit, do you not think so?

Actually, no. Ravenloft is more than just the undead. Yes, they're more powerful and in some domains more prevalent. But there's the caveat: they're only as prevalent as the DM wants.
Well, fine then.

Re: Hunter of the Dead PrC
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2011 5:34 pm
by alhoon
Well, Ravenloft without undead is bread without bread.
