Page 1 of 2

Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 1:48 am
by cure
Do Vistani in good standing (not darklings & not the static burnt) make Power Checks for their cursing and the like?

Yes, they are NPC, so I realise that the matter is slightly academic.

Still, I can recall no Vistani NPC having been attributed a failed Power Checks.

Perhaps the current Darklord of Sithicus might be an exception, but given what she did to her tribe, she was hardly in good, standing, although I don't recall her formally getting the boot either ...

FWIW, their rituals have always struck me as insulating them from the rules that apply everyone else in the Land of Mist. Indeed, the Carnival masks would be particularly clear example of this.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 6:59 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Vistani are no exception.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 8:31 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Keep in mind that very, very few NPCs in general have been attributed failed powers checks without being darklords. (Off the top of my head, Lord Balfour is the only one I can think of. I'm pretty sure there are a few others, but no more than a handful.) But with with Inza as a darklord (full-vistani, I think, or was she half?), and Gabrielle as darklord (quarter-vistani), I don't see any reason they would be immune.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 7:19 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
The only Vistana who is exempt from powers checks is Madam Eva as described in Gaz. I.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 8:17 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
IIRC, the Wanderers are not true Vistani, but are one of the other gypsy-folk that populate the lands.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 8:47 pm
by A G Thing
I could have sworn the wanderers were part of the Vistani. Still, didn't the tribe leader who cursed Van Richten become the darklord of a domain? I have never read the source material myself but I remember hearing something about it!

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Fri Sep 30, 2011 9:25 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:IIRC, the Wanderers are not true Vistani, but are one of the other gypsy-folk that populate the lands.
Nope, HoL, Gaz IV, and KotBR all agree that they are vistani. (Didn't check SotBR, but since Lowder wrote all of them, I assume he was consistent.) Only Nabon the giant isn't truly vistani, but the work of the Bloody Cobbler bound him mystically to them.
A G Thing wrote:I could have sworn the wanderers were part of the Vistani. Still, didn't the tribe leader who cursed Van Richten become the darklord of a domain? I have never read the source material myself but I remember hearing something about it!
Ah yes, Madame Radanovich, darklord of Bleak House. You are correct.

And I agree, High Priest Mikhail's finding that Madame Eva is specifically called out as immune to the Dark Powers implies that other vistani are not, otherwise they would have the same note.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Fri Sep 30, 2011 12:41 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:And I agree, High Priest Mikhail's finding that Madame Eva is specifically called out as immune to the Dark Powers implies that other vistani are not, otherwise they would have the same note.
A textbook example of "The exception proves the rule"! :lucas:

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 3:30 am
by cure
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Ah yes, Madame Radanovich, darklord of Bleak House. You are correct.

And I agree, High Priest Mikhail's finding that Madame Eva is specifically called out as immune to the Dark Powers implies that other vistani are not, otherwise they would have the same note.
Radanovich was killed by the zombies led by van Richten, n'est-ce pas? She subsequently returned as a spectre I believe, which, in her case, would be dark desire at/post the moment of death. I am not sure that whatever protection the vistani have in life reaches beyond the grave.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 9:23 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
cure wrote:Radanovich was killed by the zombies led by van Richten, n'est-ce pas? She subsequently returned as a spectre I believe, which, in her case, would be dark desire at/post the moment of death. I am not sure that whatever protection the vistani have in life reaches beyond the grave.
What protection do they have in life?

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 11:59 am
by cure
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
cure wrote:Radanovich was killed by the zombies led by van Richten, n'est-ce pas? She subsequently returned as a spectre I believe, which, in her case, would be dark desire at/post the moment of death. I am not sure that whatever protection the vistani have in life reaches beyond the grave.
What protection do they have in life?
Well, that is the question.

So far, it has been established that Madame Eva gets a free pass on Powers Checks. That has been interpreted by some as the acception that proves the rule, but I am not entirely persuaded by that logic.

Pure Vistani with failed Power Checks who are not Darklords seem to be inexistant, whereas there are such for non-Vistani in 3e canon. Has another pure Vistani, particularly a raunie, ever been statted in 3e canon?

The masks warn by the Carnival vistani constitute very potent potection, albeit from other aspects of Ravenloft. And indeed not only from the Twisting, but also from the development of the demonic side of the child of the Gentleman caller who counts as one of their number. The rituals described in to Sleep With Evil seem to go, if my memory serves, at least in this direction.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 4:55 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
cure wrote:Pure Vistani with failed Power Checks who are not Darklords seem to be inexistant, whereas there are such for non-Vistani in 3e canon.
One, as far as I can tell, only Lord Balfour. If anyone knows of another, let me know, but I just did a quick skim and couldn't find anyone else with a full writeup that has failed a powers check but isn't a darklord.
Has another pure Vistani, particularly a raunie, ever been statted in 3e canon?
No raunies, but Alexi, Nikolas, and Piotr of the Wanderers, Inza, and Rosaleen (from Ashington Manor) seem to be the only ones. One of the wanderers is a ranger, and Rosaleen is a sorceror, but none of them get the line of text that Madame Eva has about her spells not being affected by the DPs unless she wants them too.


Considering the facts:
There are at least 2 full vistani darklords (Inza and Radanovich)
There is a grand total of one non-Vistani non-darklord who has failed a powers check (Balfour)
None of the full vistani writeups other than Eva say they are immune to powers checks
None of the full vistani spellcaster writeups other than Eva say their spells are unaffected by the Dark Powers
The Vistani description in Denizens of Darkness/Dread says nothing regarding immunity to Powers Checks.
Madame Eva's description says that no one knows where her spells come from, not even other vistani.

I see no evidence that vistani as a whole are immune to the influence of the Dark Powers. (Of course, if it helps your campaign, feel free to invent it. It's just not supported by canon as far as I can see.) One might as well say that Abbers are immune to Powers Checks because we've never seen an Abber who failed one.
The masks warn by the Carnival vistani constitute very potent potection, albeit from other aspects of Ravenloft. And indeed not only from the Twisting, but also from the development of the demonic side of the child of the Gentleman caller who counts as one of their number. The rituals described in to Sleep With Evil seem to go, if my memory serves, at least in this direction.
I don't recall the rituals in To Sleep With Evil, but as far as the skurra-vera masks, as far as we know, they protect only against The Twisting. The suppresion of demon traits is a "potential canon" thing from what the Kargatane released about their plans. Even if it were true, it seems the masks protect more against extra-planar effects due to outsiders in the demiplane, not the dark powers themselves. The dark powers are not responsible for the Twisting, nor for the demonic heritage of a half-fiend.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 6:19 pm
by alhoon
Eleni of Toyalis has also failed a powers check.

As for Madam Eva: I don't play her as immune to the powers checks and above the Dark Powers. They have trouble to see her, but if she attracts attention she would get what she deserves.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 10:16 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
Actually there's two more canon non-Vistani NPCs who have failed Dark Powers checks but aren't darklords: Rodjan Dilisnya and Louise Renier from Legacy of the Blood.

Re: Do the Vistani make Powers Checks?

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 8:08 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Ah, nice finds, guys. I had a feeling there were a few more, but couldn't find them. OK, so amend my post to 4 non-vistani non-darklords with powers checks. (so far). Still, compared to the vast number of NPCs out there, even some who are clearly villains, it's a drop in the bucket, and hardly surprising that the few vistani we've seen don't have failed powers checks.