Page 1 of 1

Phylacteries

Posted: Sat Oct 01, 2011 11:55 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
This is a question I've had for years but just never put much thought into until dug out my copy of Slayers Next Complete Series and watched as Halcyform began dying when his pledge stone with a monster was shattered. Namely, what happens if a creature's phylactery (celestial, fiend, lich) is destroyed but the creature still has a physical form? Does their life force transfer to their physical form, rendering them vulnerable to final death by direct assault? Or do they simply die?

I've always assumed it was the former. But I'd like to get some opinions from other Ravenloft fans.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 12:17 am
by Ryan Naylor
The former. The phylactery isn't the life force itself, its just somewhere for the life force to go when it's forced out of its current home in the body.

Of course, the latter provides a good image for the climax of an adventure, so...

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 7:48 am
by alhoon
Ryan Naylor wrote:The former. The phylactery isn't the life force itself, its just somewhere for the life force to go when it's forced out of its current home in the body.

Of course, the latter provides a good image for the climax of an adventure, so...

Exactly that. When I've asked Azalin in the late SotK forums, I got the answer that a lich can create another phylactery when the first one dies.

But really... isn't it cool to combine some trickery and defeat the less powerful minions to get rid of the monster?

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 9:02 am
by HuManBing
There is a LOT of variance on this in the DnD "canon" so my simple answer is: it's up to the GM.

Ravenloft Realm of Terror 2nd Ed. specifically says if Azalin's phylactery is destroyed, he is still unharmed but is instantly aware of its destruction. He is then vulnerable to being permanently slain if his corporeal body is then destroyed.

Another Ravenloft adventure, Roots of Evil, specifically says if Azalin's phylactery is destroyed, it instantly kills Azalin's corporeal form as well.

I don't have the DnD core books anymore, but I believe a similar confusion exists over whether a lich can reconstruct a phylactery once it's been destroyed. The general impression I'd gotten was "no" - a phylactery is specifically a one-off artifact to give the lich's life force someplace to recover, and if it's ever lost, the lich is either immediately destroyed, or is forever bound to its current corporeal shell.

You can adjust any of this to fit your campaign's difficulty level, though. The three possibilities as I see them are:

1. Destruction of the phylactery outright kills the lich. (This campaign would be very heavy on the sleuthing and "locate item" style of play, as it's much easier to destroy an inanimate soulbox than to duke it out with a lich toe-to-toe.)
2. Destroying the phylactery forever traps the lich in its mortal shell, allowing it to be permanently killed. (This campaign is a balance between sleuthing and fighting, although destroying the phylactery first then means the momentum lies with the PCs, as they can then marshal their forces for a final strike against the lich in combat.)
3. Destroying the phylactery temporarily traps the lich in its mortal shell, but it can reconstruct a new phylactery, given time. (This campaign favors the lich even more, but also means the PCs can be certain the lich will be dropping whatever plans it has elsewhere and immediately reforging its phylactery. Oddly enough, this option may make the lich much more predictable than option 2., because in 2. the lich has nothing left to lose and can afford to be unpredictable. If the lich can reconstruct its phylactery, the rational and strategically sound choice would be to do so at the earliest possible opportunity. Canny PCs can thus "deactivate" a lich's schemes and machinations for a while by destroying its phylactery and forcing it to reforge it.)

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 3:18 pm
by alhoon
HuManBing wrote:I don't have the DnD core books anymore, but I believe a similar confusion exists over whether a lich can reconstruct a phylactery once it's been destroyed. The general impression I'd gotten was "no" - a phylactery is specifically a one-off artifact to give the lich's life force someplace to recover, and if it's ever lost, the lich is either immediately destroyed, or is forever bound to its current corporeal shell.
Actually, there is nowhere in the rules any definition that a lich can have a single phylactery for its whole unlife.
Also, since Demiliches have 2-6 in order to become demiliches, I would say we have reasons to believe that liches can make more.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 9:13 pm
by HuManBing
alhoon wrote:Actually, there is nowhere in the rules any definition that a lich can have a single phylactery for its whole unlife.
I don't have the books anymore, so I can't confirm this. My recollection has been that there were explicit but inconsistent statements to the effect that a lich may only have one phylactery, and if it's ever destroyed, the lich is out of luck. I can well imagine it's left open, with nothing more than a heavy implication that the limit is one.
Also, since Demiliches have 2-6 in order to become demiliches, I would say we have reasons to believe that liches can make more.
I have never heard of this interpretation in any edition of DnD. Source?


Finally, please remember that my stance is very clear. Canon is irrelevant - the GM's campaign is supreme. If the GM needs to houserule something for greater enjoyment of their roleplaying group, they have ultimate authority.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Sun Oct 02, 2011 9:17 pm
by steveflam
I have always thought that if the phylactery is destroyed, the Lich is now vulnerable to be able to be destroyed. As Azalin is made aware of his phylactery being destroyed I would presume that a Lich would have the same knowledge. Like HmB says it is up to the GM really.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Mon Oct 03, 2011 10:12 am
by alhoon
Really, it's usually cooler to get rid of the monster destroying the phylactery.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Mon Oct 03, 2011 12:25 pm
by HuManBing
alhoon wrote:since Demiliches have 2-6 in order to become demiliches, I would say we have reasons to believe that liches can make more.
Do you have a source on this statement, alhoon?

It's a cool idea - it's just one that I'd literally never heard of before in all my DnD gaming days.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Mon Oct 03, 2011 4:11 pm
by alhoon
Check demiliches in the epic handbook.

And personally, I find it a bad idea. When I used a demilich, it had one phylactery. Oh, and unlike the liches I usually use... once the Phylactery went BOOOOOM, the demilich died.

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Mon Oct 03, 2011 9:49 pm
by HuManBing
alhoon wrote:Check demiliches in the epic handbook.
Hmm! Interesting!

Here's a quote from the 3rd Ed. d20 SRD:
Liches have phylacteries that allow them to reappear 1d10 days after their apparent death, as do demiliches. Demiliches also have eight soul gems, each of which acts like a phylactery in its own right. If all the soul gems, as well as the demilich’s phylactery, are not destroyed after a demilich is downed, the demilich reappears 1d10 days after its apparent death.
Excellent find, alhoon!

This brings up an intriguing possibility. You know how VR's Guide to the Lich brings up Power Rituals, and leaves their actual effect vague? VR just says "Liches love to perform these but nobody knows why". (Later Dicefreaks templates also work these into their mechanics, giving any lich a significant boost in powers with each successful power ritual.)

Well, what if the power ritual was performed as part of an eight-step process that led to eventual conversion into a demilich? Maybe the lich needs to master high-level magicks for each stage, and also must sacrifice a very large amount of victims' life forces or the like. Each time the lich performs the ritual, it emerges with a load of new powers, and more subtly, a new soul gem that acts like a phylactery.

These are less versatile than a standard lich's phylactery, because they must be physically worked into the lich's body and therefore cannot be hidden away. (Which also means if the lich is corporeally destroyed before it becomes a demilich, at the very least it will have to gather up the soul gems again - this may mean running around to buy them from merchants if the PCs have already sold them off as dungeon loot. At worst, the soul gems would be destroyed, forcing it to start all over again.)

If you were thinking of running the Grim Harvest series of adventures, you might be able to work these into the plot somehow. Azalin is spending a lot of time gathering sacrificial life essence in the Glass Daggers...

Re: Phylacteries

Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2011 6:51 am
by alhoon
I think we're all aware what happens when you try to short-circuit the procedure... ;)
HuManBing wrote: Which also means if the lich is corporeally destroyed before it becomes a demilich, at the very least it will have to gather up the soul gems again - this may mean running around to buy them from merchants if the PCs have already sold them off as dungeon loot.
:lol: :lol: :lol:
"Come here good sir, take a look at this very precious gem. The men that sold it to me swore it hails from a powerful and ancient evil that they tamed! Look, if you see the gem in shadow you could think you see some radiance from it's depth. It's perfectly safe of course, but it makes a good story, doesn't it? Oh yes, there was another one! A rich silk merchant bought it to adorn his ring. He believes the story and thinks that it would bring him lack, health and prosperity."