Page 1 of 1
Discussing QtR
Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 6:34 pm
by alhoon
OK, I skimmed through the netbook.
As usual, it seems of exceptional quality that could rival official products on matter of style.
I liked the tar mummy for reasons unknown (OK, I've used similar one) but I think she should have fire vulnerability.
I also liked the whole thing was not that rules-oriented, like the mystery places.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 9:32 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
I really enjoyed the adventure "Feasting with Falcons". I was really neat to see so many long time characters from Ravenloft modules intersecting in one adventure. I'm also a big fan of The Living Brain, so I'm glad to see some of the machinations of his disembodied mind.
I also liked Joel's tar mummy article.
It was nice to see Dave's work with Pathfinder on official Ravenloft characters. I remains to be seen what will become of D&D, but it might be that Pathfinder will be better rules system for Ravenloft.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Mon Oct 31, 2011 10:32 pm
by Galeros
Tar Mummy? Is that like Tarman from Return of the Living Dead?

Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Tue Nov 01, 2011 10:08 am
by Joël of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I liked the tar mummy for reasons unknown (OK, I've used similar one) but I think she should have fire vulnerability.
Well I thought cold was better because it's the only thing making asphalt creak (you should see the roads in Québec). And I figured she was also bloated a bit from water and tar, making her immune to fire.
ScS of the Fraternity wrote:I also liked Joel's tar mummy article.
Thank you!
Galeros wrote:Tar Mummy? Is that like Tarman from Return of the Living Dead?

No she's cleaner
---
While I liked all articles in this issue, a few words on some: David's are really useful (will use these versions on the VR clan in my game), Stephen's are fun to read and I'm always on the look out for a tale to tell during my game, Ron's adventure is quite cool (I loved reading it in his journal, lots of NPC and intrigue), and the others were quite cool to read to!
Joël
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 1:22 am
by Jack the Reaper
As always I was happy to see the new issue, especially that it came out right for my birthday.
I haven't read it all yet, but I must admit I was dissapointed from to see that only 8 articles, by only 6 contributors (one of whom is me), have made it into the book. It seems that the amount of original RL fan creations is dwindling with the years. Maybe when WotC will finally revive the setting, matters will improve.
The adventure "Feasting with Falcons" looks most promising to me, because of all the VIPs it contains. It's always inspiring to see so many RL famous characters together. BTW, I always thought it's pity darklords can't leave their domains; just imagine a feast or a prom which guests are darklords from all over the core!
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 5:08 am
by The Giamarga
ScS of the Fraternity wrote:It was nice to see Dave's work with Pathfinder on official Ravenloft characters. I remains to be seen what will become of D&D, but it might be that Pathfinder will be better rules system for Ravenloft.
I liked that article very much too. Esp. since he based his Van Richten stats on the older QtR article. Apparently PF models quite a few NPCs easily, but that is no wonder with all the options present.
Is QtR open for all kinds of mechanics or only 3.5/PF ? Joel's article was 3.5 but made use of some PF feats iirc. It is kind of confusing.
Pathfinder seems to be the system to go here on the boards, if one considers the PBPs. But what is lost then is of course all the custom RL material from 3E which would have to be converted to PF first somehow before being used. I know Mistfinder attempted that but i'm not sure how far that got...
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 9:00 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
The Giamarga wrote:Is QtR open for all kinds of mechanics or only 3.5/PF ?
As we said in the announcement and call for articles, any edition or ruleset is welcome. (4e, PF, GURPS, etc..) We just didn't get many articles this year, sadly, and none of them outside the 3.5/PF region. Though ScS's articles were nearly mechanic-free, so you can consider them to be whatever system you want, and my adventure (thanks for the compliments, folks) is mostly RP, so I imagine it could be adapted rather easily. Also, the Dread Elemental Domains article is rules-free aside from the darklord stats, IIRC.
Joel's article was 3.5 but made use of some PF feats iirc. It is kind of confusing.
While PF is designed as a self-contained ruleset, it's still "d20", and I know many people (self included) port feats/rules/spells, etc over from PF into their 3.5 games.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 2:20 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I actually thought the size of the book was an advantage. I read the whole thing in one sitting, unlike some of the bigger books which got shuffled off for months. I don't think the interest in the setting has dwindled: we are all still here, we pick up a new poster every few months and the setting has been out of mainstream circulation for years. If anything we are waiting for the twilight fans to outgrow their fad and get into some real vamp stories!
As Ron knows, I'm one of those guys who pulled his article late in the process to perfect it. After reading this QtR, I am glad I did because it would have stuck out while sitting next to these great articles.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 9:20 pm
by A G Thing
I too liked the issue and had many articles to add to it! Just they all needed a lot of work and I have to get them under control first but that involves getting my life in order first. So definitely next year will see at least one but hopefully a typhoon of articles for the next QtR!
Still I really want more info on the Elemental Domains... I like the concepts but I think they need a bit of a follow up to expand on them in the next QtR. Be great to see it!
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Wed Nov 02, 2011 9:28 pm
by Joël of the FoS
The Giamarga wrote: Joel's article was 3.5 but made use of some PF feats iirc. It is kind of confusing.
My article is 3.5, and the feat I took from PF was clearly labelled as being taken in PF (it's the Thoughness feat which is better designed in PF). I don't see what was confusing in it
Indeed, as Ron said, we are opened to all mechanics, as long as the fluff is good.
However, we could add a line in the article title saying which mechanic tool set is used in the article, so people do not have to guess what is being used.
Joël
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 1:48 am
by alhoon
Actually, I haven't realized VR used PF toughness... Anyways. I liked the Foxgroves from those NPCs.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 1:52 am
by Rudolf Weathermay
The QtR is great. I did not read everything, but what I saw was really good. A few years ago I was moderator on a dutch/flemish roleplaying forum and I made a few ravenloft oriented stuff for that site (one adventure I remember and a NPC with plotlines etc). The whole bunch was written in my own language (as was a must on that website), but I can translate it, convert it to 3.5 and make a few small changes to it. If there will be a new QtR I can sent it to you , so if accepted you guys can see it next year.
the adventure is based on mood with only a minimum on combat.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 3:18 pm
by Galeros
A G Thing wrote:Still I really want more info on the Elemental Domains... I like the concepts but I think they need a bit of a follow up to expand on them in the next QtR. Be great to see it!
I will see what I can do.

Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 9:23 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Rudolf Weathermay wrote:If there will be a new QtR I can sent it to you , so if accepted you guys can see it next year.
there will be... same time next year. Never too soon to start working, though.
Re: Discussing QtR
Posted: Thu Nov 03, 2011 9:48 pm
by Joël of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Actually, I haven't realized VR used PF toughness... Anyways. I liked the Foxgroves from those NPCs.
Actually I was saying it's Antunia Papiècu that had the PF Thoughness, not David's Van Richten
---
And yes, there will be another QtR next year, same place

We are not sure of many things, but
that is rock solid.
Joël