Page 1 of 1

Praesidii and Bastions of Ezra updated from 2ed

Posted: Thu Nov 24, 2011 12:28 pm
by cure
The Praesidius is described in Mangrum's excellent "ANCHORS OF FAITH" from the Book of Secrets in these terms:

"The Praesidius (if male, Praesidia if female) is the leader of the Church of Ezra as a whole; the Praesidius is often referred to as Ezra’s Champion. There can only be one Praesidius at a time, and the title has been handed down from the Church’s founder, Yakov Dilisnya. Although the ruling has ruffled feathers among the other sects, a new Praesidius must always be drawn from the ranks of the Home Faith, the lawful neutral sect. To qualify for the title, a prospective Praesidius must be able to demonstrate that Ezra will personally watch over and guide him safely through the Mists of Death; thus all holders of this title must have reached 9th level."

Likewise, the bastions are described in these terms:

"Bastions are the leaders of the recognized sects; the title is granted to the founder of a new official sect, who then hands the title to their chosen successor. Since an anchorite must be able to manifest the Shield of Ezra to successfully establish a sect or step in as a successor, all Bastions must be at least 6th level."

The need for changes follows from the different treatment of the Shield of Ezra in 3ed and changes in the anchorite class.

The Shield of Ezra in 3/3.5eds is the domain ability attached to the Mist domain. Hence the change to bastions is self-evident. Rather than having to be an Anrchorite of at leat 6th level, all bastions must simply have the Mist domain. An expert/contemplative could conceivable become a bastion.

The ability to safely navigate the Mists has been considerably changed under 3/3.5 ed. Telelport Without Error through the Mists is the 7th level spell of the Mist Domain. If that were the criteria, a praesidii would have to be at least 13th level divine spell casters with the Mist Domain. The current praesidius is a Cleric 6/Anchorite of Mists 5 however. A member of the Anchorite of the Mists prestige class from the 1st level has the Mist Navigation ability that lessen the chance of mistway drift. At 5th level an Anchorite of the Mist has Dimension Door through the Mists. At 3rd level an Anchorite of the Mists can Turn Mist creatures. And At 7th level he/she enjoys Truce of the Mists which eliminates unprovoked attacks from mist creatures. None of which exactly fit the bill, not being very impressive, not lending themselves to an infalliable test, or both

Thoughts?

Re: Praesidii and Bastions of Ezra updated from 2ed

Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2011 9:25 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
cure wrote:The Shield of Ezra in 3/3.5eds is the domain ability attached to the Mist domain. Hence the change to bastions is self-evident. Rather than having to be an Anrchorite of at leat 6th level, all bastions must simply have the Mist domain. An expert/contemplative could conceivable become a bastion.
Contemplative has 1st level divine spellcasting as a pre-req, so you can't be an expert/contemplative, unless I'm missing something. I suppose it's possible that there are many experts or adepts among the clergy, and that only a few rise to actual cleric (or adept/contemplative). This changes the requirement a little. Rather than rewarding a moderate amount of experience/power/faith, it just weeds out the riff-raff a bit. :)
The ability to safely navigate the Mists has been considerably changed under 3/3.5 ed. ...None of which exactly fit the bill, not being very impressive, not lending themselves to an infalliable test, or both
I agree that none of these provide an infallible test, but neither did the 2e requirement. I don't recall what sort of mist navigation powers 2nd anchorites had, and I don't have time to dig out Domains of Dread, but lots of people have traveled the Mists and returned safely, anchorites or no. The Praesidius test is pretty much a gamble, and a test of bravery/faith. The more of those Anchorite of the Mists powers one has, the better their chances, but they could just be lucky. The key to the test IMHO, is having the guts to attempt it.

Of course, you could just keep the level requirements too. No one knows what level a person is, but there's surely some intangible ranking and prestige system within the church based on years of service, notoriety, great deeds, etc. that can be abstracted by "level".

Re: Praesidii and Bastions of Ezra updated from 2ed

Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 7:35 pm
by cure
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
cure wrote:The Shield of Ezra in 3/3.5eds is the domain ability attached to the Mist domain. Hence the change to bastions is self-evident. Rather than having to be an Anrchorite of at leat 6th level, all bastions must simply have the Mist domain. An expert/contemplative could conceivable become a bastion.
Contemplative has 1st level divine spellcasting as a pre-req, so you can't be an expert/contemplative, unless I'm missing something. I suppose it's possible that there are many experts or adepts among the clergy, and that only a few rise to actual cleric (or adept/contemplative). This changes the requirement a little. Rather than rewarding a moderate amount of experience/power/faith, it just weeds out the riff-raff a bit. :)
Under 3.0 (Defenders of the Faith), the Contemplative class did not require divine spellcasting ability and in fact granted it. Under 3.5 (Complete Divine), the Contemplative class has as a prerequisite the ability to cast 1st level divine spells, which would include clerics, paladins, adepts, rangers and probably a handful of obscure monsters. The prerequisite of Knowledge (religion) 13 is common to both. The change strikes me as regrettable. A doctor of canonical law is going to be an expert not a cleric, and he is not going to train late in life to turn undead and swing a mace. The contempative class was a way of rewarding his devotion with a small but very meaningful slice of the miraculous powers previously reserved for clerics.

Re: Praesidii and Bastions of Ezra updated from 2ed

Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2011 12:25 pm
by cure
In Gaz III, the DM's notes, p. 110, we are told that a candidate for the title of Praesiduis demonstrates that Ezra will will guide him/her safely through the Mists of Death by having a "Mistwalking ability such as the 6th-level spell in the Mist cleric domain of the Mist Stride ability gained by a 5th-level anchorite of the Mists".

The Mist Stride ability is a Supernatural ability to dimension door once per day. Presumably the instantaneous travel is "through the Mists", but manifests no tangible evidence of that. Still, dimension door as a spell is inaccessible to clerics save by the Travel domain. And presumably those in the know would be able to distinguish the manifesting of a supernatural ability from the casting of a spell. So this test yields pretty reliable proof that one is a moderate level anchorite of the Mists. And as such, one might manage to survive an actual jaunt through the Mists of Death.

The 6th-level spell in the Mist domain is Wind Walk. One manifests tangible evidence of becoming mist and clerics do not, absent the Air domain, have access to the Gaseous Form spell. The utility of Wind Walk in the navigating the Mists is not inconsequential. Picking out a creature made of mists in the midst of the Mists is probably quite difficult and doing anything about a creature in gaseous form essentially requires magic. But clerics of every faith able to cast 6th-level spells have Wind Walk on their spell lists. So it is undistinguishing in that respect. It is really only a test of being a cleric able to cast 6th level spells. Still, clerics of other faiths would not be able to manifest the Shield of Ezra.

Re: Praesidii and Bastions of Ezra updated from 2ed

Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2011 4:02 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I wasn't aware of the older version of contemplative, but I see what you were getting at. That kind of character concept is why I like the cloistered cleric from Unearthed Arcana (also in the srd).

Re: Praesidii and Bastions of Ezra updated from 2ed

Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2011 7:03 pm
by cure
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I wasn't aware of the older version of contemplative, but I see what you were getting at. That kind of character concept is why I like the cloistered cleric from Unearthed Arcana (also in the srd).
Yes, cloister cleric largely achieves what I had in mind and in some respects more since the entry requirements are incomparably lower. Tales of Wyre got me thinking seriously about the membership of church clergy. And having done so, I was happy to discover that the church of Ezra is described in the Gaz's as having clergy that is very broadly based in terms of classes (even if all the statted individuals are invariably clerics or anchorities of the Mists).