Page 1 of 1

The size of rivers

Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 11:32 am
by Strahdsbuddy
Judging by the city maps from the Black box, I was trying to determine the size--or more correctly the width of major rivers. Judging by the Pont-a-Museau map, the Musarde is about 2000 feet wide before it enters the city, which is pretty substantial. We all know the Musarde is a big river. I always thought the Arden was also a big river, but it is only about 65 feet wide when it enters Mordentshire and empties into Arden bay. I would say that the portion of the Arden that enters the village is actually a tightly controlled stream resulting from a dam which is located off-map, one that probably protects the tiny village from being filled with water against the cliffs that surround it.

I guess I am pointing out that the Musarde is navigable from its source to the estuary in Lamordia. The Arden has multiple tributaries that would indicate it getting larger, yet it is only a trickle at its terminus. I have not thought much about the other rivers yet, but the Vuchar is certainly wide and was navigable right up until the Grim Harvest.

What does everyone else think about this?

Re: The size of rivers

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 2:30 pm
by MichaelTumey
Well, as a member of the 'River Police' at the Cartographers' Guild - an unofficial, though recognized title given to those CG members who politely point out when some start-up cartographer has messed up the geology with a river - like splitting downstream, going from sea to sea. Of all the geologic structures put into a map. Rivers are those that are most commonly screwed up in one way or another.

Big rivers like the Nile, Mississippi, Yellow, etc can be a mile wide or more especially near the mouth. I know that what some people call a river in the western US, midwesterners would call a creek or even a ditch - rivers in Texas (except for the Rio Grande) are barely more than ditches. The Rio Grande, except during the rainy season, is a small river. About the size of the Fox River near my home that flows into the Illinois River, a tributary of the Mississippi is about 100 - 150' for most of length. The fox river is only 50' across.

So river widths vary from as little as 10' wide to miles wide. And whether its called a river or creek depends on which region you are from. In areas where rivers can get big, all other waterways that are small are not considered rivers, per se - though geologically they are all considered rivers.

Re: The size of rivers

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 3:02 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Thanks, Michael. My main question is of navigability. The Musarde has always had a sense of being a "Big" river, so I have no problem with it approaching 1/2 mile in width through Richemulot. I figure you could sail from Hazlan to Lamordia on the Musarde, even switching directions around Lake Kriegvolgel and heading into Darkon (For a fee).

The Arden also has a lot of fingers reaching inland. Places like Sithicus, Verbrek, Valachan and Mordent would all be connected by this river, which would be a main artery through what is otherwise pretty rugged country. My main issue with the Arden is its representation on the map of Mordentshire, where it is little more than a trickle that passes under a covered bridge before emptying into Arden Bay. Using the fishing boats from the map for scale, it isn't even wide enough for a rowboat. This makes me think the Arden-proper empties into the Sea of Sorrows north of the village, and the creek represented on the town map is diverted from a dammed portion of the river.

I think the Arden, Musarde and Vuchar should all be large and navigable, while a river like the Ivlis would probably be full of cataracts and less navigable before spilling into Nova Vaasa. Nova Vaasa's rivers, particularly the Dnar, Borchava, and Ivlis, may be calm on the plateau, but might drop quickly into the Nocturnal Sea, depending on your interpretation of the quick elevation change at the coast.

Non-canon, I believe the absolute widest river is the Orchid in Kungthrom Sound (Navigaccio) which is 150 miles long and a mile wide. The Gonde in Nzari (USS 2003) is also described as being a mile wide. I really have no problem with large rivers, particularly the Musarde, which I always considered a natural boundary, like the Mississippi.

Re: The size of rivers

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 4:52 pm
by MichaelTumey
For navigability, matters of depth, and speed of the water is the only major concern with even a 30' wide river. If the navigable channel is deep enough, and not flowing too strongly/swiftly and don't have too many curves, a 30' wide river is plenty navigable. I know of some rivers out west, that might be 60' across, but 3/4 of the year are hardly more than a foot deep, sometimes less. So width of a river is not the only variable regarding navigability. I would say a slow moving river at least 50' wide most likely falls in the navigable class - though bigger is better.

Re: The size of rivers

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 6:41 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
The little trickle of water that passes through Mordentshire is probably a millrace: a stream diverted off the main river to act as a power source. Follow it upstream off the edge of the town map, and you'd probably find a granary with attached mill, and perhaps a sawmill or textile mill as well.

I've always assumed that all the rivers shown on the main continental maps are navigable, because there aren't nearly enough of them shown for the cartographers to have included every little stream. It's logical that mapmakers would only bother to show the ones that offer a possible route for riverboat traffic, and omit those you'd need a rubber raft or canoe to get through.

Re: The size of rivers

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 6:59 pm
by MichaelTumey
On large regional maps or world maps, in reality it would be impossible to see any river that isn't a mile wide. So placing them is only for reference that a river exists - like a label. From a satellite, rivers are essentially invisible in any world view photo. There are literally thousands of rivers, streams and creeks, canals, waterfeeds, etc. that might never show up on a map. I generally map regionals or smaller, down to encounter scale where you can show every waterway that exists or that will be usable in game. It depends on the scale of the map, the needs of the terrain for the game itself.