Page 1 of 2

Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 1:18 pm
by alhoon
Well, I was reading Gaz I again and I noticed that in Forlorn we have something like
Population ~2000, Humans ~6%
OK, that means we have 120 Forfarians. And yet... there is a hamlet with about 350 Forfarians. That alone is about 17% of the population of Forlorn.

OK, I don't really mind about that.
What I find strange is that according to the page there are virtually none Forfarian wizards while that village has a whole clan of wizards with a 9th level matron of the clan and according to S, they're invaluable in the defence of the hamlet.
So... IMO Wizards should be more common than Barbarians in Forlorn.

Oh and another thing. Hazlan has the equivalent of a Patriarch of the Lawgiver, presiding over 4 Archbishops, that they preside over several bishops, that preside over many weird administrator-priests that preside even more priests. :?
Ehh... Hazlan has a few dozen thousand people. Every 150-250 Hazlani there's a Banite priest?
Not to mention their Patriarch is... 15th lvl. :?

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 1:24 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Well, technically that human village is in Hazlan, so it probably isn't being counted among the population-figures for Forlorn. The 6% of its residents that are humans are probably a combination of druids, fugitives from other domains, and perhaps captives of the goblyns.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 2:35 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:Well, I was reading Gaz I again and I noticed that in Forlorn we have something like
Population ~2000, Humans ~6%
OK, that means we have 120 Forfarians. And yet... there is a hamlet with about 350 Forfarians. That alone is about 17% of the population of Forlorn.
Rotipher answered that handily: the hamlet isn't actually in Forlorn.
What I find strange is that according to the page there are virtually none Forfarian wizards while that village has a whole clan of wizards with a 9th level matron of the clan and according to S, they're invaluable in the defence of the hamlet.
So... IMO Wizards should be more common than Barbarians in Forlorn.
Again, that's not in the domain. That's in the hamlet in Hazlan next door.
Oh and another thing. Hazlan has the equivalent of a Patriarch of the Lawgiver, presiding over 4 Archbishops, that they preside over several bishops, that preside over many weird administrator-priests that preside even more priests. :?
Ehh... Hazlan has a few dozen thousand people. Every 150-250 Hazlani there's a Banite priest?
Not to mention their Patriarch is... 15th lvl. :?
Now THAT's a problem. Really it's a continuation of a problem we've seen everywhere in RL, namely the discrepancies between the sizes, populations, and demographic situations.

We all have different ways of reconciling those numbers. I prefer to make the Core the size of Europe, and expand the populations to fit. You have previously stated that you prefer to keep the Core the size of Switzerland, and get rid of the opera houses in Dementlieu. Sounds like you need to do the same thing here: the majority of those priests are "opera houses" that don't fit in your version of RL.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 2:55 pm
by alhoon
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Rotipher answered that handily: the hamlet isn't actually in Forlorn.
Yeah, but I thought they were the pop of Forlorn, but OK. That's the reason I like the frat. I make a very specific Ravenloft lore question and someone answers with a nice answer and corrects me within what was it? 6 mins this time?

Still... Wizards were outlawed in Forlorn in 688 BC that they settled that place. You know, cast spell => Hazlik feels it => Hazlik grows very angry => 14th lvl darklord immortal invoker wipes you out of existance.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote: You have previously stated that you prefer to keep the Core the size of Switzerland, and get rid of the opera houses in Dementlieu. Sounds like you need to do the same thing here: the majority of those priests are "opera houses" that don't fit in your version of RL.
:?
Nooooope, I've said that the very tiny and not really suitable for me Core in Canon is the size of Switzerland with 485K people. I don't use that. I don't think many people do. I have a core twice the size of Greece with ~2 million people.

As I said, a few tens of thousands. I think I have Hazlan with 75-80K people. Still not enough for so many layers.
I think I'll get rid of the insanely high level patriach of 15th lvl and move everyone up a step.
I.e. Divine fist > Archbishop (Nova Vaasa, Hazlan about 7th-8th lvl or something) > Bishops > administrators > priests.
Yeap, that works. Problem solved. :)

PS. Still, now that I read the gaz again and check those NPCs I totally get what you were talking about. There's a smackload of high level NPCs. It's not just the Darklords, it's practically everyone with a position.
It seems that Ravenloft canon is oriented towards mid-low levels (4th-10th) PCs or something. So for a village to exist when threatened by a "menace" of CR7 or something, it needs a few 5th lvls.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 5:44 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:Still... Wizards were outlawed in Forlorn in 688 BC that they settled that place. You know, cast spell => Hazlik feels it => Hazlik grows very angry => 14th lvl darklord immortal invoker wipes you out of existance.
Good point! That bears investigating.
Nooooope, I've said that the very tiny and not really suitable for me Core in Canon is the size of Switzerland with 485K people. I don't use that. I don't think many people do. I have a core twice the size of Greece with ~2 million people.
Ah, my mistake.
As I said, a few tens of thousands. I think I have Hazlan with 75-80K people. Still not enough for so many layers.
I think I'll get rid of the insanely high level patriach of 15th lvl and move everyone up a step.
I.e. Divine fist > Archbishop (Nova Vaasa, Hazlan about 7th-8th lvl or something) > Bishops > administrators > priests.
Yeap, that works. Problem solved. :)
Good work. You'd be a good partner for my Mistipedia scale project, to create a simple set of scales that DM's can use for whichever way they want to reconcile the discrepancies. Interested?
PS. Still, now that I read the gaz again and check those NPCs I totally get what you were talking about. There's a smackload of high level NPCs. It's not just the Darklords, it's practically everyone with a position.
Yup.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 6:25 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:Still... Wizards were outlawed in Forlorn in 688 BC that they settled that place. You know, cast spell => Hazlik feels it => Hazlik grows very angry => 14th lvl darklord immortal invoker wipes you out of existance.
Good point! That bears investigating.
Possibly the ApMortens used to live in Immol, and only emigrated to Forfarmax to join their ethnic fellows when Hazlik discontinued the ban on others' wizardry. It might explain the uneasy relations between that family and the rest of the village, if they're recent arrivals whom the long-term residents are still getting used to.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 6:27 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Possibly the ApMortens used to live in Immol, and only emigrated to Forfarmax to join their ethnic fellows when Hazlik discontinued the ban on others' wizardry.
That sounds good to me.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 3:01 am
by alhoon
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Possibly the ApMortens used to live in Immol, and only emigrated to Forfarmax to join their ethnic fellows when Hazlik discontinued the ban on others' wizardry. It might explain the uneasy relations between that family and the rest of the village, if they're recent arrivals whom the long-term residents are still getting used to.
That sounds the only possible solution to me, although I would make "being wizards" more important factor in the uneasy relations than "arrived here just 15 years ago".

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 2:44 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Possibly the ApMortens used to live in Immol, and only emigrated to Forfarmax to join their ethnic fellows when Hazlik discontinued the ban on others' wizardry. It might explain the uneasy relations between that family and the rest of the village, if they're recent arrivals whom the long-term residents are still getting used to.
That sounds the only possible solution to me, although I would make "being wizards" more important factor in the uneasy relations than "arrived here just 15 years ago".
Well, Lucy ApMorten in the original CF boxed set was a necromancer, and the subtext on this family suggests these follow in her footsteps. Another reason, the residents may resent the help the ApMortens provide them with, because the ApMortens won't let them forget it.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 7:34 am
by alhoon
They're open practicers of necromancy?
what happened to Pitchfork mobs?

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Wed Jan 11, 2012 5:27 pm
by nothri
Personally, I always have and always will assume that hamlet is located in Barovia, because it is the only explanation that makes any sense at all given the timeline. There was no Hazlan at the time the village would have comfortably been founded, and I see no way for the villagers to have survived any significant length of time within the borders of Forlorn without being wiped out by or turned into goblyns. You could say the village population was transported into the domain later, except the village culture is so closely tied to the history of Castle Forfarmax that this makes little sense in and of itself. Honestly, why the Gaz felt the need to shoehorn it into Hazlan when Barovia is a perfectly good realm to use is beyond me.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 5:12 pm
by alhoon
Well, the explanation that they arrived just 80 years ago and settled there is as good as any. Of course, the nice family of necromancers would have to wait to step there till Hazlik lifted the ban on magic.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 5:14 pm
by Garudos Celestar
alhoon wrote:They're open practicers of necromancy?
what happened to Pitchfork mobs?
Considering that Lucy's living alone in Tristenoira's basement up until she's killed by our friendly neighborhood darklord, it might be safe to assume that her particular arcane interests are not considered "mainstream" or "admirable," even by members of her own lineage.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 12:05 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:They're open practicers of necromancy?
what happened to Pitchfork mobs?
I said subtext--subtext! It's not openly stated, and I would guess neither are they. The narrator just makes the comment that the villagers find them a little "unsavory," although she finds them "entirely agreeable." Note the subtext there: the person who likes hanging out with them is the person who vivisects wolfweres for fun and spent the last half a decade sending her ghoulified daughter around the Necropolis as a scrying focus. If S is not a necromancer, she at least leans that way, and this plus Lucy ApMorten's profession makes me read that word "unsavory" as having a starkly morbid tinge to it. IMC they're not openly necromancers, they just keep up on the obituaries, hang around in graveyards without acting like they're mourning, perk up when anyone mentions death, and generally act like Gomez Addams.

I may be reading too much into this, but I file S's remark of "entirely agreeable" under "Your approval fills me with shame." :azalin:

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 1:04 am
by alhoon
I always thought S was a generalist wizard. All schools. Sure, she may have a few more necromantic spells in the repertoire and perhaps even skill focus, but I doupt she has given up 2 schools. I believe the Apmortens may have a couple of true specialist necromancers in their midsts throughout the years but more or less, I think they too, are generalists.