Ravenloft System Pros/Cons
Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2012 10:46 pm
I want to run Ravenloft this Spring but there are a lot of systems to choose from. There's two main editions to Ravenloft (2nd and 3rd), a handy 4th edition conversion, and I'm sure other hacks floating around the 'net.
I'd like everyone's thoughts on the various systems (I'll compile them in this first post).
Dungeons and Dragons Rule Sets
2nd Edition
Pro:
Pro:
Pro:
Burning Wheel
Pro:
Pro:
Pro:
World of Darkness
Pro:
Pro:
GURPS
Pro:
I'd like everyone's thoughts on the various systems (I'll compile them in this first post).
Dungeons and Dragons Rule Sets
2nd Edition
Pro:
- Tons of published material, including many modules
- More dangerous combat than 3rd or 4th. Simple combat system - elegant in it's simplicity.
- Simplest classes, easiest character creation. Differing class complexity - Wizard becomes very powerful, complicated. (Note, Wizards advance slower) (Post #160152)
- Ravenloft books are fairly common.
- Awkward percentile thief skills.
- Jury rigged proficiency system.
- Maximum class levels based on race.
Pro:
- Core rules available online at http://www.d20srd.org (Post #160127)
- Very compatible with Pathfinder (use http://www.d20pfsrd.com) (Post #160127)
- Outstandingly written fluff in White Wolf books.
- More streamlined and intuitive d20 mechanic that ties skills and combat together.
- A plethora of d20 material to tap into for ideas outside Ravenloft.
- Most of the FoS material is 3rd/3.5, including fan adventures.
- Derpy skill progression.
- Feat creep if you include extra supplements, otherwise there is only one optimal selection of feats for most classes. (Note, Pathfinder provides more options for feat paths) (Post #160142)
- White Wolf rules were not always the best. (Example, missing/vague rules in d20 Masque of the Red Death) (use http://www.d20pfsrd.com) (Post #160127)
- No modules, few prewritten adventures.
- Combat system optimized with miniatures. (Post #160846)
Pro:
- Similar system to 3rd, monsters can be reworked without too much effort.
- Classes balanced with each other.
- Convenient conversion documents on the FoS.
- Combat focus, did they ever release those social combat rules?
- Combat system optimized with miniatures. (Post #160846)
- No true Ravenloft material, just a few scattered articles and tid bits. Official Ravenloft Campaign Setting shelved.
Burning Wheel
Pro:
- Sweet social combat rules.
- Very deadly combat system.
- Current rules designed for High Fantasy.
- No conversion guide that I'm aware of.
Pro:
- Dion has a conversion. (Post #160888)
- Includes non-combat classes: Courtier and Artisan. Very easy to convert your own classes. (Post #160888)
- Eastern theme may require reskinning for Core domains.
Pro:
- Class based model.
- Gritty, realistic combat. Itemized magic system.
- Madness mechanics.
- No conversion.
- 3rd edition is very difficult to reskin due to board game element (cards, special dice, etc).
World of Darkness
Pro:
- Generic horror you can apply templates to.
- Points based character generation. (Post #160139)
- Plethora of horror material (Including various Rome and Dark Age supplements).
- Dion made a conversion in the past. (Post #160126)
- Simple but breakable combat system. Better in NWoD.
- Freeform magic system.
Pro:
- Simple percentile game system with special advancement rules. Almost all actions skill based.
- Harsh combat rules. Itemized magic system.
- Focused on horror, detailed madness and mental effects. (Post #160139)
- Cthulhu Dark Ages supplement available.
- No conversion available.
GURPS
Pro:
- Universal system, supports GM tinkering
- By default, supports harsh combat, skill-based spells, points-buy and PC customization. All can be tweaked to some degree. GMs and PCs can easily work together to develop a character's profession without having to worry about balance in house rules.
- huge flexibility in designing monsters, npcs, etc.
- supplement books are highly respected and their literature research is useful even for non-GURPS systems. (Specifically recommended: Horror, Mysteries, Low-tech, Social Engineering, Thaumatology.)
- GURPS conversion by HuManBing (Post #160141)
- Universal system, so the GM will have to familiarize players with the system and then familiarize them with his personal tweaks to it.
- GM has a lot of work to do, to pare away the rules that have no place in his campaign. Understanding of probabilities helps a lot too.
- More suitable for players who are more accustomed to customizing their characters, rather than following preset progression paths.