Page 1 of 5
Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Fri Mar 02, 2012 9:48 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
In the PF rules, undead show up as extra-evil when using the proper detection spells. How would you treat this when using moral alignment detection in RL? Do they detect as extra chaotic? Is there a chance that they might work normally, like with fiends?
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Fri Mar 02, 2012 10:07 pm
by MichaelTumey
The setting rules take precedent over the system rules. Ravenloft, like many settings have unique specific rules and mechanics set apart from any edition of D&D past and present. Pathfinder provides lots of tools and mechanics to do neat things, haunts for instance. Use Pathfinder rules for almost all mechanics, except for those specific rules unique to the setting. I do that with Kaidan, but still call it a setting for Pathfinder.
Use the moral alignment mechanic for 'extra chaotic', or as with fiends, as best appropriate for Ravenloft.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Fri Mar 02, 2012 11:38 pm
by alhoon
Undead aren't extra chaotic though! So I would say "according to the setting, no it doesn't work"
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 1:44 am
by ewancummins
In RAW Ravenloft, paladins detect chaos, not evil. Chaos is not the same as evil in the AD&D/3E /PF nine point alignment system.
I would rule that CE (and also CN or CG)undead do not detect as 'extra chaotic.'
The restrictions on his detection abilities are there for the same reason several cleric (and a few wizrobe) divination spells are modified; so that the players have to work a bit harder to discover who/what/where the baddies really are.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 11:22 am
by Nathan of the FoS
If I'm going for simplicity, I say "Paladins do not get extra undead-sensing powers in Ravenloft; the DPs cover for 'em (the undead that is)." If I'm going for atmosphere, I might try to get some kind of extra information that doesn't have a chaotic valence...an oily aura, a faint whiff of rot, etc.--perhaps requiring a Perception check to get or interpret.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 11:58 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Intelligent undead in Ravenloft get a will save to avoid magical detection, don't they? I'd say that would apply here too.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 12:00 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
*sigh* I guess I knew that. Oh well.
I guess my real problem is with the replacement of detect evil with detect chaos. I've never seen that ability used in my games to any sort of useful end.
How about any of you? How do paladins in your games use detect (evil) chaos to accomplish their missions?
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 1:29 pm
by Zilfer
and curiously should my paladin of Kelemvor (god of death) ever wander the mists, he has his Detect Evil replaced with Detect Undead because it makes more sense for the god he serves.... would that also switch to Detect Chaos in Ravenloft? o.O'
I doubt he'll ever go there but it'd be nice to know.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 4:02 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I'd say if he's already switched DE for DU, he'd keep DU. (with it's Will save limitation imposed due to being in Ravenloft). It wouldn't switch to DC if it's not currently DE. Make sense?
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 7:19 pm
by HuManBing
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:I guess my real problem is with the replacement of detect evil with detect chaos. I've never seen that ability used in my games to any sort of useful end.
The more I think about this, the more I see your point, Deepshadow. It really doesn't "click" much with the idea of a divine knight to be able to detect chaos.
One way of working around this, if you don't mind bending the rules for the sake of flavor, is to allow paladins to detect mindless undead specifically. This is not quite the same as detecting evil per se, as it's not a violation of the alignment-masking rule.
The alignment-masking rule is there to prevent PCs from throwing a quick spell down and short-circuiting some good detective-work driven plots. You could quite convincingly maintain that plot protection for living evil people (who you can't detect that way) and also by carving out an exception for self-willed undead (so PCs hanging around a Kargat infiltrator can't blow his cover that way).
I'd say the plot requirements to protect self-willed undead and evil NPCs are significantly different from those for mindless undead (which function much more as disposable mooks or swordfodder).
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 7:45 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Also detect chaos just isn't really useful.... ever? (Except maybe when crafting a Mystick Cage?)
Ooh... you're chaotic! so... you're Skeletor or Robin Hood. This helps me how?
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 7:48 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
An alternative that better fits the setting might be to give paladins a "Detect Curse" ability, in which they can sense when a being is under a contagious or Curse check- or spell-imposed curse. That doesn't necessarily give the game away about who the bad guys are -- plenty of innocent folk in Ravenloft are undeservedly cursed -- but it's still information that'd be useful under some circumstances, such as figuring out if someone who's ill needs medicine or a Remove Curse spell, or if a lycanthrope is natural or afflicted.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 8:25 pm
by Jester of the FoS
I'm thinking of giving paladins the ability to detect environmental evil as an always-on ability. They can just sense sinkholes of evil, and places of corruption. Kinda a "this place is strong with the Dark Side" sixth sense.
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sat Mar 03, 2012 11:54 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Jester of the FoS wrote:I'm thinking of giving paladins the ability to detect environmental evil as an always-on ability. They can just sense sinkholes of evil, and places of corruption. Kinda a "this place is strong with the Dark Side" sixth sense.
That would be more thematically proper and doesn't violate the RAW. Of course there aren't really rules for positive ethereal resonance so blackguards would need a case-by-case ruling on whether or not they detect the "good" equivalent of Sinkholes of Evil (detecting
consecrated and
hallowed places with their
Detect (Good) Law ability fits).
Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?
Posted: Sun Mar 04, 2012 2:04 am
by alhoon
Zilfer wrote:and curiously should my paladin of Kelemvor (god of death) ever wander the mists, he has his Detect Evil replaced with Detect Undead because it makes more sense for the god he serves.... would that also switch to Detect Chaos in Ravenloft? o.O'
I doubt he'll ever go there but it'd be nice to know.
That could be a partial solution. As others said Detect chaos is next to meaningless, although it would show disposition to not honor deals.
Having DEvil replaced by Detect Undead or detect Shapechangers or detect fey or detect magic users or whatever the character and the DM pick for the paladin seems more sensible.