Page 1 of 1
Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 6:49 am
by alhoon
So, as we all know very well, tech in the demiplane is at many places similar to the tech of up to 17th century. Martira Bay even has some Frigates to patrol the seas.
I was thinking, what about cannons? There is a lot to be discussed about them. I just regret I didn't do an article for the technology QtR about them.
In the CL8 we have use of Culverins and Bombards. Those IIRC used to fire stones.
Because of Ravenloft's size and available means and materials, I would say that Culverins would be on the smaller scale of the historical ones, weighting 1500-2000kg and use cannoballs of 8-16 lbs along with 6-12 lbs of gunpowder/shot.
As far as game rules for culverins, I choose to go more simple than realistic:
I would say that gamewise, aiming a culverin would need the feat firearms. It would require 1 minute to load by 3 men and about 3 rounds to take aim (which can happen as the gun loads). It would have range increment of 400' and couldn't fire on anything closer than 200'.
It would create a line attack of 60' long x5' wide at the impact point (some distance to land and then ricochet, bounce, break) dealing 5d8x2 damage on anyone in the path. The reflex DC to avoid the damage would be 20 -1/range increment.
To start the line attack at a certain point, the gun opperator would need a knowledge(siege weapons) roll with a DC of 20. The gun opperator can take 10 on this roll unless under threat.
Missing by up to 5, the attack starts in a random point 1d4x10' away from the intentended target point (x number of range increments, i.e. 1200'-1600' = x4). Missing by more than 5 means the attack starts x2 the above error.
Firing without taking the 3 rounds to aim means the target point is considered the same as with the previous shot but the knowledge(siege) roll is considered to have failed.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 1:29 pm
by ewancummins
Cannon and similiar large gunpowder weapons are definitely part of my Ravenloft, although I don't think they've yet turned up in actual play.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 6:44 pm
by alhoon
Any rules or suggestions about my rules then Ewan?
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:43 pm
by ewancummins
alhoon wrote:Any rules or suggestions about my rules then Ewan?
They look pretty good.
I'd use profession: artillerist instead of knowledge: siege, though.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:45 pm
by alhoon
Yeaaaah, when I suggested that a couple of years ago, my players wanted to kill me. And since there's a knowledge about siege weapons... why not expand it to arty too?
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 7:33 am
by starfalconkd
Here's a link to the Pathfinder rules on siege weapons. Under firearms they make mention that Culverins larger than hand held size are considered cannons.
http://www.d20pfsrd.com/gamemastering/siege-engines
And here's the firearms rules in general.
http://www.d20pfsrd.com/equipment---final/firearms
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 1:40 pm
by alhoon
Not bad rules, but Cannons do waaaay too little damage there. How many hp a 1' thick, 10'x10' masonry wall has? A cannonball of even 12lbs should be able to destroy that in 2-3 successful shots.
Also 6d6 for getting a cannonball in the face is again too little for my games. An ogre shouldn't be able to survive 2 cannonshots, not even one.
Thanks though. Interesting read.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 6:19 am
by starfalconkd
I think they erred on the side of caution with the damages. I think the rules are fairly solid though.
You're welcome.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 7:30 am
by Five
alhoon: Not bad. However, I'd double the minimum damage from 10 to 20 (2d4x10). And if you want a truly lethal weapon then triple the critical. A "firearm" that even dragons would fear...
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 12:34 pm
by alhoon
ehh... you see, that's the deal though: a cannonball could fracture on impact with the ground and sharpnel hit you or hit you in the leg or something. I.e. there's a small chance that you would survive.
As for the critical: It's a ranged attack that has a reflex, it's not a touch attack.
And let's not forget: As Ewan said, the chances that cannon hits will have an actual role in the game are few. If it comes up, then you can use whatever works.
Dragons: Not really. Dragons fly fast and most cannons can't aim high. So, the dragon would be upon the crew (And the gunpowder keg) before the cannon is aimed. Remember with my rules, it takes 3 rounds to aim the cannon.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 12:57 pm
by Five
alhoon wrote:a cannonball could fracture on impact with the ground and sharpnel hit you or hit you in the leg or something. I.e. there's a small chance that you would survive.
As for the critical: It's a ranged attack that has a reflex, it's not a touch attack.
Fragmentation carries modified damage, yeah. Personally, I'd treat cannonballs (under specific conditions that would cause them to frag) as splash damage. Ranged touch attack. Otherwise they cause direct damage, then collateral damage (as it bounces and tears through the area). Max range, line of attack, impact, etc. all should modify this secondary damage...if it's something you even want to include. Up to you.
Dragons: Not really. Dragons fly fast and most cannons can't aim high. So, the dragon would be upon the crew (And the gunpowder keg) before the cannon is aimed. Remember with my rules, it takes 3 rounds to aim the cannon.
Yeah, I only wrote that as a hypothetical threat.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 3:07 pm
by alhoon
Well... I just wanted something kinda simple.
Still, it's an interesting discussion. Care to elaborate a bit more about the "strikes, the fragments" thing? I don't think I'm going to use it since I would go for simplicity but you never know.
PS. Not direct damage could well be low like 2d8 or something. Perhaps change the "direct" attack to 2d8x5 and the "impact/bounce/fragment/earth-in-your-face" attack to 2d8?
Well, that doesn't seem hard to implement. Like line attack/touch attack of 2-3 squares and then impact attack at 10' radius or something?
I prefer the area attack because IMO it's more a "reflex to avoid it" than "avoid touch attack", since it's like very fast but travels a long way. Faster than sound in the beginning.
I.e. it would be "See the cannon flash. Bob and Bill get splattered. Hear the cannon's fire" At 2000'-2500' I think the cannonball would reach like 1/2 a sec before the sound.
Re: Cannons, culverins etc
Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2012 5:06 pm
by Five
Something simple and within your suggested stats, ok.
Cannon fires, travels, impacts. Roll 1d4.
On a 1 the cannonball does 5d8x2 damage to its area of impact. Reflex save to half the damage.
On a 2 the cannonball bounces, dealing 5d8x2 damage to its area of impact plus it hurtles 50 percent of its travel distance along its line of attack, dealing 5d8 damage to anything in its way. Each obstacle it hits reduces the damage by 1d8. Reflex save to half the damage if standing in the AOI, and a Reflex save to avoid the bouncing rock of death.
On a 3 the cannonball fragments on impact, dealing 5d8x2 damage to its area of impact, plus 2d8 frag damage to all adjacent "squares". Reflex save to half the damage in the AOI, and a Reflex save to avoid the fragments.
On a 4 the cannonball craters its area of impact, dealing 5d8x2 damage plus an additional 2d8 of "earth-in-your-face" to all adjacent squares/areas. Reflex save to half the damage (again, if standing in the AOI), and a Reflex save to avoid (hit the dirt, whatever) the flying debris.
Throw in a stunned effect on all of the areas affected by the cannonball regardless of successful saves (except the bounce) if you want to further take the cartoon out of the culverin. Call it concussive damage, or whatever else you want..