Page 1 of 1
Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 8:22 am
by Drinnik Shoehorn
My players aren't really the type to make Powers Checks, fortunately, but the fact that it might come up has been playing on my mind. But do I go for the 6 step as laid out in Realm of Terror and the RCS, or the 13 step as in Domains of Dread? I can see benefits for both; 6 steps is quicker, but 13 makes it seem more appropriate because it does allow PCs an "out" with the length of time before damnation.
What do people think I should use, 6 or 13? What do other people use?
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 1:10 pm
by Terminusvitae
I vote for six, myself, but I've always felt that damnation should be swift and inevitable.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 2:38 pm
by alhoon
I also vote for 6, although I think damnation shouldn't be swift and inevitable.
I think 6 steps, especially the ones laid in the book are a good, as long as it should, and logical path. 13 steps feel too many IMO.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 8:20 pm
by ewancummins
I go with six as a general rule.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Fri May 04, 2012 12:32 pm
by starfalconkd
I also prefer to use six. But I think each successive check should require a more awful transgression.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Fri May 04, 2012 7:34 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Six here as well. The old thirteen steps seemed awfully complicated for a mechanic that is supposed to be swift and easy to fall into.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Sat May 05, 2012 9:23 pm
by Terminusvitae
Maybe the thirteen steps originators had Ravenloft confused with Alcoholics Anonymous.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Sat May 05, 2012 11:42 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Terminusvitae wrote:Maybe the thirteen steps originators had Ravenloft confused with Alcoholics Anonymous.
Obligatory
Bubba J. quote. "AA is for quitters."
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 9:23 am
by Jester of the FoS
Just from a game design perspective, 13 is too much. If your game runs from 1-15, bordering on the extremes of high level, your players have to fail a Powers Check almost every level. Note that that's not "make" a check, but fail a check. Given average checks have a 10% chance of failure, that's a possible 130 checks needed to move from nobody to darklord.
There's just too many to progress along the path of darkness any meaningful distance, unless your players are running horrible monsters or twisted anti-heroes. And if your campaign is shorter, with 13 steps your players could be twisted sadists and they'd still likely not fall all the way before the end of the campaign.
Thirteen steps is also a lot of additional mechanics to make. If they fail there needs to be some boon/curse, preferably created for the character. Six is much more manageable and makes each step count.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 10:27 am
by Five
I think you guys just summed it all up fairly nicely. Six steps would be for those who would like a shorter, more ruthless road to character (PC) corruption/damnation, thirteen steps would be for those who prefer a more gradual, shall we say seductive path.
Also, how many actions are there in an average level? One hundred and thirty checks isn't really a whole lot (within fifteen character levels), unless the players are aware of the checklist and are dodging the pitchfork. I've always thought it best to exclude the Powers Checks from player knowledge, if and where possible. If not, then subtitle the list.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 12:11 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Five wrote:Also, how many actions are there in an average level? One hundred and thirty checks isn't really a whole lot (within fifteen character levels), unless the players are aware of the checklist and are dodging the pitchfork. I've always thought it best to exclude the Powers Checks from player knowledge, if and where possible. If not, then subtitle the list.
Well, it's somewhere around 8-10 actions per level, but that would be at the high 10% range. Murders and the like. It doubles if the characters are doing lesser crimes.
I like to level every 2-3 sessions, but for a slower pace Ravenloft game it might be 3-5 sessions between levelling up. At an average of 4 that's two murders per game session or four lesser crimes.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 9:12 am
by Garudos Celestar
I suppose if any of your characters like to cast Necromancy spells they could reasonably fail checks on a regular basis. If you really want to force them down the path of darkness, hand them a powers-check-inherent item like Maleffluent or the Fang of the Nosferatu.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 11:27 am
by ewancummins
Why would the DM wish to 'force them down the path of darkness'? Just curious. I don't see the appeal, but YMMV.
Re: Powers Checks; 6 steps or 13?
Posted: Tue May 08, 2012 5:35 am
by Five
Technically, there are only six steps in the thirteen step Powers Check. Or I should say, six failed checks until the probability (95% chance) that the PC becomes an NPC. That said, the list is the same. The only real differences are the three variants of freedom from the DPs (zero fails) and the four additional fails/steps from a PC becoming an NPC and that same character becoming a Darklord. Which could lead to an interesting campaign villian (one with startling familiarity) that just keeps on morphing badass. Just script the changes yourself for appropriate PC challenge.