Page 1 of 11

Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2012 10:52 am
by Deewun
I recently got a copy of VRGtF, and I am enthralled with the idea of transposition. But I wondered, could the same apply to an angel or other form of outsider being? Perhaps a modron, a being of pure law drawn by the lawful acts of a player? Or even worse, a Slaad drawn to a chaotic player's chaotic character!

I was wondering if there was any material out there that backs this up or kills the idea.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2012 12:20 pm
by MichaelTumey
Ravenloft's transposition mechanics apply to nether planar beings only (evil), though I could see an argument for chaotic creatures. I am definitely sure that angels cannot be transposed, nor modrons. Chaotics maybe, evil definitely, other alignments never.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2012 9:22 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
I have to agree with Mr. Tumey to a point. Transposition is essentially a powers check answered not by the Dark Powers but by a fiend. But since it takes an evil act to attract either, and Ravenloft is not concerned with law and chaos, only fiends do transposition. The fiend ends up trapped--albeit with more mobility than those without reality wrinkles--and the evil mortal ends up in the Lower Planes. So the fiend is also being punished along with the mortal. Drigor rails against his inability to leave Ravenloft, even with a spelljammer ship, in VRGtF and warns that "the great ones" must "beware honey-coated traps" (power rituals).

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 12:30 am
by Jimsolo
"Fiends" as a term typically is only applied to demons, devils, and yugoloths. While I agree that outsiders of other alignments shouldnt be able to transpose, I think applying the transposition rules to evil outsiders who are not traditional fiends would be perfectly in-line with the spirit of the transposition rules.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 1:49 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I dunno, I'm gonna disagree a bit. I haven't read the rules on transposition in a while, and I wouldn't be surprised if they said or implied that only evil outsiders could do it, but I could see the case for letting an Angel do it. If it would make for an interesting story, I say go for it. I'm not really sure what a fiend gets out of willingly becoming trapped in Ravenloft via transpossession. But on the other hand, I could see an Angel selflessly transpossessing a worthy True Innocent, or paladin, or otherwise special hero of Ravenloft, rewarding the mortal with rescue from Ravenloft to the celestial realms, and taking his or her place fighting among the horrors of the Mists. I suppose a fiend might want to skip out on the blood war and become a big fish in Ravenloft's small pond, and send some poor sap into hell for the lulz. But Ravenloft has a reputation among the planes as a black hole with no escape. So, it certainly seems more in-charater for an Angel to willingly enter (as Isolde did) than a fiend.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:03 pm
by Jimsolo
I thought of a caveat to my previous answer: It's clear from the background info presented in the Monster Manuals that some outsiders can become corrupted from their inborn alignments, although rare. Fallen celestials exist, even if they exist in few numbers. If a celestial were to begin to be corrupted, the Dark Powers could take notice of him and spirit him away to Ravenloft via transposition with a mortal of similar mindset, rather than allow the errant outsider to eventually be chastised or destroyed by his superiors. Could be fun.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:27 pm
by alhoon
As far as angels go, I would say that the Ravenloft take on them is that they're paradigms of goodness, not just "very good".
Transposing with someone and invading in his body/mind/soul is wrong, so IMO no angel would do it.
As for Lawful creatures, I don't think it's in their agenda. Why would they do it?

Chaotic neutral creatures? Well, there's no "they wouldn't do that" for chaotic outsiders. Some would I guess. Few though.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:46 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Transposing with someone and invading in his body/mind/soul is wrong, so IMO no angel would do it.
This is a good point. If it's possible, it's probably against the code most angels follow. Though perhaps a rogue angel might see it as a a small sacrifice for the greater good. Again, we're getting into fallen angel territory, but that's Ravenloft for you...

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 2:58 pm
by alhoon
Whatever works for you.
I keep clear of "fallen angels" for Ravenloft, since I see them Ravenloft-wise as perfectly good creatures. No small sacrifices, perfectly good.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 3:54 pm
by Hazgarn
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:Transposing with someone and invading in his body/mind/soul is wrong, so IMO no angel would do it.
This is a good point. If it's possible, it's probably against the code most angels follow. Though perhaps a rogue angel might see it as a a small sacrifice for the greater good. Again, we're getting into fallen angel territory, but that's Ravenloft for you...
Depending on the circumstances, the transposition of a non-evil outsider could conceivably be entered into voluntarily. Kind of like the way the angels in Supernatural required the consent of their vessels...even if they weren't necessarily 100% honest about the consequences. As invasive and probably frightening as it would be, like you said, ultimately the mortal winds up in a good-aligned outer plane while the celestial takes their place in Ravenloft (in who only knows what situation caused the mortal to catch the celestial's attention in the first place...so potentially pretty bad).

It would depend on the mortal's disposition and faith, but surrendering themselves to as a tool for a being of pure good might be something they could get behind. Now, that isn't to say that, regardless of how willing the participant is or their reasons for accepting, the process once begun won't be scarring and horrifying, with the mortal--and, conceivably, the celestial--coming out a little damaged by the experience on other end...

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 5:44 pm
by alhoon
Hmm... for LAWFUL good angels, transposing in the shells of willing monks that have prepared their bodies for just this reason etc. etc. and know exactly what will happen and give their agreement every step of the way, I think it would be possible even with the "perfect angel" in mind.
I don't think a perfectly good creature would use dublicity and deceit. If the mortal is 100% willing to trade-out with an angel for a life in... heaven, then why not?

Campaignwise, I would prefer an order that prepares canditates for that, informs them of what happens etc, headed by an angel that got in that way. At every point the mortal can "opt out" and the angel possessing him would depart. However for this "peaceful symbiosis" before the transportation of the angel in Ravenloft there would be some necessary steps to prepare the mortal soul for heaven and the mortal shell for the angel. I.e. adventures and steps like the transposition.

And of course, the glummy dishonored ex-paladin that opted out near the end of the transposition because he fell in love with a girl and didn't want to lose her. So he said "bye-bye" to the Angel and lost his powers etc. And now, after the girl actually died or something he wants to redeem himself. Or tends an altar to the good powers and just offers healing potions to heroes or something.
Or gives them advice/adventure hooks and offers his protection+2 ring that the angel left with him as a parting gift since angels are good.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 6:02 pm
by Hazgarn
Okay, this is kind of a random question, but the idea just popped into my head, and it could be interesting...

What happens if an outsider is transposing with a mortal, say halfway through the process, when they get summoned into Ravenloft the conventional way?

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 6:26 pm
by MichaelTumey
I don't have the transposition rules in front of me, but whose to say the normal fiends that transpose with a given being on Ravenloft even know that person is in Ravenloft at all. When discussing if a lawful good angel would be using deceit to fool a mortal into any activity or not. How does the angel, fiend, outsider even know the being that is dealt with is in Ravenloft in the first place? I would think the closed Ravenloft borders would hide that in the first place even from them.

In my thinking the fiend has no idea that the transposed being is in Ravenloft at all. Same would be true for any outsider no matter the actual alignment. Once the transposition process is more than halfway through, perhaps only at that time would the outsider realize the truth in what is happening, and by then is completely helpless to the situation until it's over - it's too late to stop it (if it even can stop it at any point in the transposition).

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 7:37 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Hmm... for LAWFUL good angels, transposing in the shells of willing monks that have prepared their bodies for just this reason etc. etc. and know exactly what will happen and give their agreement every step of the way, I think it would be possible even with the "perfect angel" in mind.
I could definitely get behind this. In fact, maybe that's what the monk's "perfect self" ability really means in Ravenloft. ;)


I tend to like raising moral issues rather than solving them IMC. So the question of "is an angel who does this still a perfect angel?" is just the sort of thing I thrive on. I had a similar situation come up in my campaign, in which the Dark Powers basically offered my purely good (True Innocent) character her "reward" in the form of a one-way trip to the heaven of her choice. But she quickly saw that by accepting such a reward, she'd be abandoning her friends and the good work that needs doing in Ravenloft, and by doing so, become unworthy of the reward. So she rejected the "trap" and stayed put. (The answer might have been different if a celestial were to replace her and pick up the fight where she left off.... again, I have no answer, I only raise the question.)

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2012 7:40 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
MichaelTumey wrote:I don't have the transposition rules in front of me, but whose to say the normal fiends that transpose with a given being on Ravenloft even know that person is in Ravenloft at all.
True, but the question I see there is: Does transpossession exist anywhere else? It's a Ravenloft-specific rule. If it doesn't work everywhere else, then no fiend who's ever completed the process has returned to tell the tale. That's a pretty good clue that doing so would trap you somewhere.

On the other hand, yeah, if you want to extend the rule to everywhere, then it makes sense for the transpossessing being (fiend, angel, whatever) to have no idea whether his "target" is in Ravenloft, on Faerun, Oerth, Kaidan, Ustalav, Gothic Earth or wherever.