Page 1 of 3

I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Fri Dec 07, 2012 1:29 pm
by brilliantlight
Rokushima Táiyoo had no real development as far as I know so I gave it some background, gave some background to the darklord along with some minor powers, gave a description for all four remaining sons and the islands they rule in Mistipedia. If you have any comments or any ideas look at it and do so.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 12:54 pm
by brilliantlight
What do you people think of the dark lord and his sons? I admit that the islands are a bit underdeveloped any ideas on them? Any plot hooks you can think of?

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 2:30 pm
by MichaelTumey
Got a link to where this is at, so I can check it out and possibly offer my own suggestions?

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 3:12 pm
by brilliantlight
MichaelTumey wrote:Got a link to where this is at, so I can check it out and possibly offer my own suggestions?
Here you go.http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/wiki ... %C3%A1iyoo

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 3:53 pm
by MichaelTumey
Well I'll explore as best I can, I see some of the links are 'broken' or linked to pages not yet created. Other than checking the linked sources, I lack any resource material of my own to compare canon elements. I could possibly create non-canon plot hooks and such.

One point of interest, the Japanese word 'ran', though defined as 'rebellion, uprising or revolt' according to Wikpedia is actually in error as it really means 'family uprising'. Often in Japanese noble houses, intra-clan feuds - between sons lead to all out war, this is the real definition of 'ran', and seems most fitting for the political activities of Rokushima-Taiyoo.

Akira Kurasawa's movie Ran is a depiction of this, and I think great inspiration to the family conflict of this domain. Ran, the movie, is actually a Japanese portrayal of Shakespeare's King Lear: the father dividing his kingdom between his 3 sons leading to all out war. It's very fitting to the concept at hand.

While we're looking a definitions 'Rokushima' seems to be a misnomer, as 'roku' means 'the number six" and 'shima' means 'island' - being that there are only four main governed islands, 'roku' as 'six' has no place in the meaning (though I suppose it's really some designers idea of a Japanese sounding word, more than using it for its actual meaning.) L5R's setting of 'Rokugan' follows the same misnomer (one of my many complaints of that setting relating to a lack of cultural accuracy.)

I'll do my best not to mix too many ideas for my Kaidan (Japanese horror) setting, especially regarding samurai and other specific aspects of the setting, since I don't rely on Oriental Adventures as source material, preferring my far more culturally accurate Kaidan setting and supplements. One thought, in my Way of the Samurai supplement for Kaidan, I've got a samurai clan stat block and clan creation mechanics which are also posted to d20pfsrd.com under variant rules, Creating a Samuri Clan.

I think it's worth checking out as a means to more fully develop each island ruler's immediate house, as well as any predominant samurai houses beneath those. Similarly, I've got a yakuza stat block and creation mechanic, if any think there is a possible need for a yakuza gang or syndicate to operate from within Rokushima-Taiyoo, with a similar page on d20pfsrd.com - located at Creating a Yakuza Gang.

While these are 3PP mechanics designed for use for Pathfinder RPG, and for use in the Kaidan setting, they were developed to be generic enough to work in any Asian (Japanese) based fantasy setting for D&D/d20/PF, and not just for use in Kaidan only. The reviewers for all these products plainly state, that the rules fit any high or low fantasy Asian setting, not just the one labeled on the products cover.

When I develop settings, I like to create vast networks of various factions for political upheaval, feuds, alliances and the relationships between all such organizations to make a setting 'come alive'. With this in mind, I see it as necessary to more fully develop each feudal house and it's major subordinates, as well as religious, guild-based and yakuza gangs to build plot hook ideas. The tools I posted above could well help develop this for setting editor/contributors.

Thoughts?

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 3:57 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
MichaelTumey wrote:
While we're looking a definitions 'Rokushima' seems to be a misnomer, as 'roku' means 'the number six" and 'shima' means 'island' - being that there are only four main governed islands, 'roku' as 'six' has no place in the meaning (though I suppose it's really some designers idea of a Japanese sounding word, more than using it for its actual meaning.) L5R's setting of 'Rokugan' follows the same misnomer (one of my many complaints of that setting relating to a lack of cultural accuracy.)
It's not an error or misnomer. There were originally six islands, each ruled by one of the darklord's sons. Two of the sons died (killed by their brothers) and the islands sunk beneath the waves after their deaths.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:05 pm
by MichaelTumey
Bluebomber4evr wrote:
MichaelTumey wrote:
While we're looking a definitions 'Rokushima' seems to be a misnomer, as 'roku' means 'the number six" and 'shima' means 'island' - being that there are only four main governed islands, 'roku' as 'six' has no place in the meaning (though I suppose it's really some designers idea of a Japanese sounding word, more than using it for its actual meaning.) L5R's setting of 'Rokugan' follows the same misnomer (one of my many complaints of that setting relating to a lack of cultural accuracy.)
It's not an error or misnomer. There were originally six islands, each ruled by one of the darklord's sons. Two of the sons died (killed by their brothers) and the islands sunk beneath the waves after their deaths.
Thanks for clearing that up. :) I say again, I don't have any source material on-hand for Canon Ravenloft elements, most scattered in various boxes of old RPG stuff of mine, and I know I have nothing on Rokushima-Taiyoo. So I can only extrapolate from other material - hence my understanding of Japanese word meanings, but not necessarily how it directly applies to the domain. My mistake calling it a misnomer.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:06 pm
by brothersale
I didn't really like your take on the domain for several reasons, the main ones are as follows:
The darklord does not come off as anything but a pawn of the Ice devil Chillus [horrible name, and why didn't you use an Oni instead, at least as it would be more in keeping with cultural background], and as a result a bit unworthy of becoming a darklord IMO.
And you have far to many demons and devils running around in the background of characters. In Ravenloft these critters are supposed to be rare, and extremely dangerous, not something that you run into very often.
Also from what you have written on the Islands of the Domain, it doesn't come off as very oriental but very much Westernised.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:10 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
brothersale wrote:I didn't really like your take on the domain for several reason, the main ones are as follows:
The darklord does not come off as anything but a pawn of the Ice devil Chillus [horrible name, and why didn't you use an Oni instead, at least as it would be more in keeping with cultural background], and as a result a bit unworthy of becoming a darklord IMO.
And you have far to many demons and devils running around in the background of characters. In Ravenloft these critters are supposed to be rare, and extremely dangerous, not something that you run into very often.
Also from what you have written on the Islands of the Domain, it doesn't come off as very oriental but very much Westernised.
I agree, it seems to basically ignore everything that's been written canonically about the domain, including the names of Shinpi Haki's sons from the Ravenloft DMG. :|

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:13 pm
by MichaelTumey
Agreed, with Brothersale - I'd chuck all devil/demon references in favor of oni, all the way. There's only a limited amount of oni provided in PF Bestiary 3, though they could easily be referenced as source material in using them. Kaidan potentially has dozens of oni specimins as well as akusa, which are demon like beings more severe than oni, like lords of Hell from the plane of Jigoku (the Hell of Kaidan and Shinto sources.) You could use oni and akusa dominance through contact between power brokers of Rokushima-Taiyoo, and not have to require oni and akusa to be running around the domain - just their influences on it.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:19 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
Also, this:
First it took worshipers of Venus from a world where she is well known and they started a sex cult dedicated to her.
C'mon, man. I'm hardly a prude, but this seems inappropriate. :|

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:23 pm
by brilliantlight
There were all of TWO fiends and only one of them is actually in RL the succubus. There is almost no canon information on the islands to contradict. I admit I missed the name in the DMG.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:27 pm
by brilliantlight
Bluebomber4evr wrote:Also, this:
First it took worshipers of Venus from a world where she is well known and they started a sex cult dedicated to her.
C'mon, man. I'm hardly a prude, but this seems inappropriate. :|
Read about the Temple of Aphrodite at Corinth. It was basically a giant brothel. Sex cults were fairly common in the ancient world. It isn't like I gave a lurid description or anything.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:37 pm
by MichaelTumey
brilliantlight wrote:
Bluebomber4evr wrote:Read about the Temple of Aphrodite at Corinth. It was basically a giant brothel. Sex cults were fairly common in the ancient world. It isn't like I gave a lurid description or anything.
While Japan definitely has a reputation for deviant sexual aspects to their culture, really the prevalence of brothels in feudal Japan is derived from the equally European concept that men require sexual release, as part of healthy living, it's not ever been a 'cult' of sex, at least not before 20th century. Brothels for the lessers and courtesans for the more affluent (and kabuki actors for the alternative lifestyle persons) is a part of normal society, and not any exclusive 'cult of sex' per se.

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Posted: Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:38 pm
by brothersale
Venus - Western Culture
Temple of Aphrodite at Corinth - Western Culture
Succubus - Western Culture
Rokushima Táiyoo - Based on Oriental Culture

do you see the problem with your thinking here?