Page 1 of 1

Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Sat Dec 08, 2012 12:38 am
by Jimsolo
A companion thread to the Top Five Domains, let's discuss Darklords. Who are your favorites? And why? I felt like I needed to create this list because it is a very different question than that of favorite domain. While the two share common elements sometimes, I wanted to keep them as separate as possible. So let's get the two of mine which are shared out of the way first. Other than that, however, the list is in no particular order.

Strahd von Zarovich -
He came in at the top position in Dragon magazine's "d20 Villains," and he deserves the honor. Combining the perfect amount of tragedy with badassness, Strahd not only makes a great foe for a party of PC's, but also makes a wonderful addition to a story. He's nuanced, complicated, and at the same time remarkably simple. If I had to pick a number one villain from Ravenloft, gun to my head, I would pick Strahd. (Am I the only one who does a Romanian accent with Strahd, by the way?) When it comes to villains who can do suave and deceptive, but still back it up with some insidious spellcasting or just pack a nasty punch, Strahd can fit the bill no matter what you need.

Adam/Dr. Mordenheim - Yes, I'm aware that Adam is technically the Darklord, but the truth is that in many aspects they share the honor. They're certainly equally cursed, and it's impossible to discuss one in-depth in a game context without discussing the other. You have a great dichotomy between the two, and their endless struggle against one another is one of the best stories in Ravenloft. I thought of dozens of different ways to have these two going at it with the PC's in the middle before deciding on the right one, and believe me when I say that the rest are still written down for later use. Either one is also great on their own, although I think they shine best when use together.

Daclaud Heinfroth - Now, I should point out that I wouldn't really use Heinfroth as he is now. But as he was? Specifically, as he was during the time when the Asylum for the Mentally Disturbed was up and running? Gold standard horror. Evil asylums take 'imprisoned' horror, 'no one believes you' horror, 'evil authority figure' horror, 'power of healing perverted' horror, and 'maybe you really are crazy' horror and mix them together. Heinfroth can encourage any one of these, depending on your needs as a DM. As far as I'm concerned, Dominia and the Asylum are still going strong, and I believe that my game world is richer for it.

The Hags - Ryan Naylor sold me on them. When I originally composed this list, there was a different Darklord in this spot. He sums them up far better than I could, so I recommend you check out his Illustrated History of the Core thread. Malicious, petty, co-dependent, and very different from the land around them, the Hags are great support villains, and make good 'boss level' opponents for midway through a campaign metaplot.

Azalin - Again, I just couldn't get away from the obvious choices. Azalin is such a great villain. There is something about a reserved, tactful, super-intelligent spellcaster that I just love. Szass Tam, Gromph Baenre: these are my homeboys. (Richard Lee Byers Szass Tam, by the way, not 4th ed NPC Szass Tam.) His insistence that everything would be so much better if he was absolute monarch is so much more horrific when you realize that he might just be right. Villains that plan for the long term are always my favorite, and who plans longer than a lich?

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Sat Dec 08, 2012 6:09 am
by Germaine
Mine are pretty much: 5. Lord Soth: Not only am I a huge fan of the "Black Rose" books and the first two DL trilogies, but I'm also rather fond of death knights in general. I also love his back story, his (rather subjective) sense of honor, and his selfish/ stubborn/ arrogant refusal to admit that he was ever wrong or flawed. 4. Harkon Lukas: I was never very fond of him until I encountered both suggestions on this board concerning his possible "Hannibal Lecter" potential and the portrayal of him in the (I think) unfairly hated "Death of a Darklord". I love the idea of a likable, charming, cultured, and sarcastic man of repute who's really just the Big Bad Wolf underneath it all. 3. Malken: I greatly enjoy both the whole Jekyll/Hyde concept and the idea of a serial killing crime boss. More importantly, I lean heavily toward the non-canon "Enemy Within" version, which is a perfect example of the road to Hell being paved with good intentions. 2. Morgoroth: I know there isn't much love for the guy, but he has what is, for my money, one of the saddest and sympathetic (maybe even tragic) back stories in the entire setting. 1. Adam/ Mordenheim: Much like Malken, I love the idea of two arch enemies being so closely tied together. I also like Mordenheim's inability to forget/escape/correct the result of his sins or recreate his greatest achievement. To me, though, the greatest selling point is that Adam- much like his inspiration- was a truly tragic figure, but has now, through his own actions, made himself as ugly inside as out and become the monster he was taken for, rather than try to correct the misconception. For the record, D'Honaire, Misroi, and especially Strahd are, for me, very close runners-up, as would be Nathan Timothy if he were still a darklord.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Sat Dec 08, 2012 10:49 am
by Jimsolo
For what it's worth, I liked 'Death of a Darklord.' Harkon Lukas was definitely a close runner up for me. Who is Morgoroth, though? I've never heard of him.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Sat Dec 08, 2012 2:09 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Jimsolo wrote:For what it's worth, I liked 'Death of a Darklord.' Harkon Lukas was definitely a close runner up for me. Who is Morgoroth, though? I've never heard of him.
http://fraternityofshadows.com/wiki/Morgoroth

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Sat Dec 08, 2012 2:56 pm
by Garudos Celestar
Germaine wrote: 2. Morgoroth: I know there isn't much love for the guy, but he has what is, for my money, one of the saddest and sympathetic (maybe even tragic) back stories in the entire setting.
My vote for saddest darklord is Chardath Spulzeer: the sacrifice of Marble is potentially the single most tragic event in any darklord's backstory (I'd even place it above the death of Tristessa's child).

As far as my favorite darklords...

5. Chardath Spulzeer: See above. Granted, he's more interesting in Castle Spulzeer than in The Forgotten Terror, but his backstory has exactly the impact you want in a darklord. Too bad his domain is a bit too far on the bizarre end and has severely limited utility.
4. Strahd von Zarovich: Hey, he's the center of the setting, and I love Christie Golden's portrayal of him in Vampire of the Mists.
3. Jacqueline Renier: Scholar of Decay did a fantastic job of defining her. She has the requisite evil manipulation with a refreshing undercurrent of empathy.
2. Yagno Petrovna: As with my #1 choice, his centerpiece adventure really fleshed out both him and his domain, and he has a unique schtick w/in the setting, an engaging backstory, and a well-tailored set of powers.
1. Gabrielle Aderre: The Evil Eye developed her into one of the truly great characters of the setting.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Sun Dec 09, 2012 3:46 am
by Azimer the Mad
1. Strahd Von Varovich: Because I can channel a sympathetic Dracula who is still evil and in control.

2. Lord Soth: Screw having a darkness blob and a dwarf! In my campaign, Sithicus is Latveria and Soth is Victor Von Doom!

Look at this picture and say some Doctor Doom dialogue, replacing "Doom" with "Soth. Works beautifully!

Image

3. Adam: He's Shelly's Frankenstein. "I ought to be thy Adam; but I am rather the fallen angel." I love having him try to be human and fail.

4. Vlad Drakov. I am such a Vlad the Impaler fanboy. I love his curse; keeps him active.

5.Harkon Lukas. Because I got to run him tonight, and he is FUN.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Mon Dec 10, 2012 11:46 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
As with the domains, ask me again next year and I may give you a different list. :)




5. Dr. Dominiani - nothing says, "welcome to Ravenloft!" like seeing a vampire bite someone in the BACK of the neck and suck out their spinal fluid. Think you know vampires? Think again.
4. Harkon Lukas - the epitome of Affably Evil
3. Ebonbane - the glue that holds the Shadowlands Cluster together. I know a lot of people scoff at the darklord who's a sword, but if you read the Shadowborn novel, he's clearly one seriously bad dude.
2. Strahd, I suppose he had to be up there. I barely use him, but I love reading about him. All the novels he appears in are fantastic.
1. Azalin.
0. Azalin.
-1. Azalin.
-2. Azalin.
-3. Azalin.
....
It's Azalins all the way down. He's such a magnificent bastard. The mover and the shaker of the setting. The rat who knows he's in a cage and will rattle the bars at every opportunity. Add in a great backstory (dude killed his son because he was too benevolent to rule properly. That's cold, real cold), a troop of wonderful lackeys (The Kargat, the Kargatane, the Eternal Order, a passel of vassaliches, undead librarians, butlers, and smiths, several imps, and a DRAGON), and a perfect curse, and he's everything a darklord should be. And he throws a mean party.


Honorable Mention: Elena Faithhold, The Nightmare Man, Gabrielle Aderre, Adam, and Drakov.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Thu Dec 13, 2012 11:31 pm
by Jimsolo
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: 4. Harkon Lukas - the epitome of Affably Evil
I lol'ed. Totally true. And Affably Evil is, of course, my favorite kind of evil.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:3. Ebonbane - the glue that holds the Shadowlands Cluster together. I know a lot of people scoff at the darklord who's a sword, but if you read the Shadowborn novel, he's clearly one seriously bad dude.
I saw Ebonbane mentioned (a couple times, I think) in the 'Top 5 Worst' thread. Did some more research on it, and I have to agree. My only real issue with it not that it's a sword, but that it's a demon. (I try to limit the number of demons in my game, because there is no wiggle room with their morality...) I think it would make for a great driving force behind a haunted house, and I don't think anything is going to make a group of Outlander PCs brown their Underoos quicker than having all their swords attack them. Great stuff.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2012 12:25 am
by vipera aspis
Alright I'll go ahead and throw this out there;


The living brain

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2012 10:55 am
by Zilfer
It's not really a Darklord though is it?^ Though I really want to use it in a game.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2012 3:46 pm
by Jimsolo
The Brain isn't a Darklord, but if it took over Dementlieu I sure wouldn't shed a tear (as long as Dominic was still alive). I wish there was a term for someone who is at Darlord levels of powers and curses, but isn't technically a Darklord. Because the Brain would definitely be tops in that category. (With Dr. Mordenheim coming in a close second.)

I think that the interplay between Dominic and Rudy could make for an awesome game focusing primarily around political intrigue. A whole campaign set in and around Dementlieu, dealing with the struggle between those two, would be awesome. My personal preference for the Brain over D-Money shouldn't be taken as any kind of objective "who's better" assessment. I like the fight better than I like either fighter.

Re: Top 5 Darklords

Posted: Fri Dec 14, 2012 8:50 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Jimsolo wrote:I saw Ebonbane mentioned (a couple times, I think) in the 'Top 5 Worst' thread. Did some more research on it, and I have to agree. My only real issue with it not that it's a sword, but that it's a demon.
Actually it's both a demon (an obyrith lord from the Abyss, but otherwise wholly incorporeal like the loumara; maybe Ebonbane seeded them?) and a sword. The followers of Ebonbane channeled its essence into a magic sword--don't ask me why, I don't know for sure--but this ended up trapping it in a physical form that the Dark Powers could imprison. At this point it's hard to say where one ends and the other begins. Ebonbane as a sword might well be a major artifact by now and require just as much effort to destroy. But why? It's trapped with the Shadowborns, the worst punishment it could endure.

5. Vlad Drakov - Some darklords I just love to hate.
4. Wilfred Godefroy - Another darklord I love to hate.
3. Strahd - Vampires don't rate that high on my list, but Strahd is the cornerstone of Ravenloft. If he's destroyed, the setting is destroyed (figurative and possibly literally if the events of Hyskosa's Hexad and the Grand Conjunction are any indication).
2. Azalin - He's nothing if not tenacious and refuses to quit trying to escape.

And my all time favorite...
1. The Nightmare Court - I've been fascinated with dreams since I was a child and have self-taught myself the art of lucid dreaming (it's not an automatic thing, nor do I have fine control, but I can realize I'm dreaming, see where it goes, and remember when I wake up). No other source can render us blubbering, simpering piles quite like our inner demons. It was a mention of the Dream Spawn in a friend's older brother's massive collection of AD&D books that first started me on what would lead to the Journals and VRGtPsionics here.