Anyway, while waiting for Mummy: The Curse, I became interested in Ravenloft again. I like the classics when it comes to D&D after all, especially after I grew disillusioned with 4E. I like the fluff, but the rules?...meh.
So, being the WoD-werehound that I am, I came back here with a new appreciation of the monstrous perspective on things...or more accurately, a more balanced and nuanced one than what I had.
That still doesn't mean I don't enjoy shredding some of the more...difficult...assumptions that made gothic horror what it is. That, and I like moral ambiguity, it makes horror so much more effective when you yourself have power.
So, this here's a thread where we throw ideas at each other about how the monsters may occupy a shade of grey.
I'll start:
PCs are hired to look into a xenophobic coastal town where some of the villagers look like fish if you look closely. Eventually, they overstay their welcome, and the cult of the Dark Messenger Nizeroth attacks in an attempt to drive them off. Naturally, the PCs come back, swords a-ready...
...and discover that the philanthropist high priest acts the same way he does behind doors as he does in public.
See, Nizeroth is ultimately a god of knowledge and inspiration. An amoral god, but this is moral ambivalence, not uncaring. The Cult is both meant to seek out its messages and, more importantly, restrict its use to those who would use it for good-Nizeroth does not care what people do with its insights, only that they are found and used. There is nothing about those lessons that disturb the moral and spiritual order, either-they are simply secrets of the sciences and the arcane, nothing whatsoever causes a powers check unless that's what you use it for.
And wasn't the employer insistent on recovering the Cult's notes...?
Re: Moral Ambiguity Among Monsters
Posted: Fri Dec 28, 2012 6:46 pm
by Jimsolo
I ran a plot with a hag who made love potions. The twist came from the fact that her love potions really did work. Rather than make you fall in love with the first person you saw, it showed you the person who would love you, heart and soul, and then enchanted you to love them. However, with her reputation as an herbalist, when member of the couples she set up would die, the other one would come to her, distraught, begging for a way to end their pain. She would happily give them a draught that would kill them, quickly and painlessly. Then, of course, she ate them. The townsfolk knew this, but came to her even so, since the relationships she set up with her potions forged the truest love they had ever seen. They had come to rely on her so much that they couldn't fathom how their children were supposed to find real love without her. My PCs chose to kill her. (Well, one of them chose to kill her, really, the rest of them were kind of ambivalent about it. And the group was really conflicted about it, they argued for longer than the subsequent combat took.
That the kind of thing you were looking for?
Re: Moral Ambiguity Among Monsters
Posted: Fri Dec 28, 2012 8:49 pm
by Leliel
Jimsolo wrote:I ran a plot with a hag who made love potions. The twist came from the fact that her love potions really did work. Rather than make you fall in love with the first person you saw, it showed you the person who would love you, heart and soul, and then enchanted you to love them. However, with her reputation as an herbalist, when member of the couples she set up would die, the other one would come to her, distraught, begging for a way to end their pain. She would happily give them a draught that would kill them, quickly and painlessly. Then, of course, she ate them. The townsfolk knew this, but came to her even so, since the relationships she set up with her potions forged the truest love they had ever seen. They had come to rely on her so much that they couldn't fathom how their children were supposed to find real love without her. My PCs chose to kill her. (Well, one of them chose to kill her, really, the rest of them were kind of ambivalent about it. And the group was really conflicted about it, they argued for longer than the subsequent combat took.
That the kind of thing you were looking for?
Yeah. That sort of thing.
Re: Moral Ambiguity Among Monsters
Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2012 1:01 am
by Leliel
Oh, just found something else:
The Black Monster, from the obscure Legend of Dragoon for the PSone.
VIEW CONTENT:
For the first part of the game, it seems like he's the big bad, an immortal demon who massacres villages to get at the reincarnation of a god, the Moon Child, who is supposed to herald a new, perfect life form which will lead the world to bliss. This would result in the death of the Monster, so he naturally voices his protest through destruction.
Then, we discover that a) the Black Monster is actually a she, b) she's one of the first party members you got, and c) the "perfect life form" is actually the progenitor of the homicidal Virages you've fought as bosses all game, and the Moon Child is actually the reincarnation of a God of Destruction.
Suddenly seems like the Monster has the right idea, doesn't it? In fact, the game's plot is caused by her screwing up and killing the wrong infant before the true Moon Child's power blossomed to make her an unknowing living nuke.
Besides the fact that Rose is hitting the gothic fashion choices pretty hard (she's the Dragoon of Darkness), she's a prime candidate for a sympathetic Ravenloft antagonist to showcase how unfair the Dark Powers can really be-a desperate woman twisted into a dragon-like monster because she was forced to resort to repeated mass murder to save the planet (the Moon Child subconsciously inspires an urge to protect him or her). Was what she did evil? Yes, she could have avoided killing innocent people to get at the Moon Child. Was what she did utterly necessary when one removes that component? Hell yeah-do you want to be dead at the hands of an evil god? Elena Faith-Hold would probably understand (shortly before getting ganked, because Rose isn't a delusional tyrant and could see the comparison).
So, say we introduce ambiguity to her story and hint that the True Moon Child Prophecy might be a big lie-the Child is simply a sorcerer with a natural tendency to be good, and is fated to midwife a naturally good-natured race. There, instant hook.
Re: Moral Ambiguity Among Monsters
Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2012 4:26 am
by Jimsolo
That particular plot just seems overly convoluted, but maybe I'm not getting a clear sense of it, not having played it.
I don't know, I'm less a fan of the "the monster turns out to be the good guy" plots. Those seem a little wishy-washy to me. I prefer "the victims turn out to be just as evil as the antagonist" plots. Not "your quest-giver betrays you" plots, since those are done to death, but just enough of a twist that the PCs have to decide if the people they are helping are even worth it, or if they should just leave and let the bastards rot.
Deadlands was really good about that. Frequently in those adventures, you would realize that the monster got that way by being horribly wronged somehow, and had returned from the grave (or been magically warped) to seek vengeance. In a lot of those games, I would find myself wondering if there was some way we could, after killing the bad guy, find a way to sneak a bullet into the back of the person who gave us the adventure, since a lot of times they had it coming.
Re: Moral Ambiguity Among Monsters
Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2012 9:27 am
by Leliel
Jimsolo wrote:That particular plot just seems overly convoluted, but maybe I'm not getting a clear sense of it, not having played it.
I don't know, I'm less a fan of the "the monster turns out to be the good guy" plots. Those seem a little wishy-washy to me. I prefer "the victims turn out to be just as evil as the antagonist" plots. Not "your quest-giver betrays you" plots, since those are done to death, but just enough of a twist that the PCs have to decide if the people they are helping are even worth it, or if they should just leave and let the bastards rot.
Deadlands was really good about that. Frequently in those adventures, you would realize that the monster got that way by being horribly wronged somehow, and had returned from the grave (or been magically warped) to seek vengeance. In a lot of those games, I would find myself wondering if there was some way we could, after killing the bad guy, find a way to sneak a bullet into the back of the person who gave us the adventure, since a lot of times they had it coming.
Actually, I agree with you on this.
I was actually using that as an example of a starting point. In my games, the inspired character would always be an antagonist, and quite insane from everything he's done, but the question of the prophecy would make it all a bit more ambiguous.
Similarly with the cult from the first example. That's actually a lot more like the "monster turns out to be good" thing, but I was actually thinking the Daedra cults from the Elder Scrolls-they may be nice, but a lot of other sects sure as hell aren't. And they're still massively elitist about who has the right to knowledge.
Re: Moral Ambiguity Among Monsters
Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2012 11:50 am
by HuManBing
Not technically a monster, but Vlad Drakov in my campaign has one important redeeming quality: he's the only neighboring darklord to Darkon who knows Azalin's true nature.
So his hopeless wars of attrition against Darkon suddenly take on a much more poignant tone, as you realize that for all his faults (brutality, sadism, Luddite refusal to use gunpowder and magic) he does have a somewhat noble end goal - he's genuinely trying to rid the Demiplane of its most manipulative darklord, who rules a populace by guile through its most profound deception. His wars against neighboring domains are less a point of vainglory than they are a genuine attempt to replace the indifferent fops and nobles with new regimes who will help him overthrow Azalin's blasphemous reign of lies.