Page 1 of 2

Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2012 8:18 am
by alhoon
OK, there are some of our favorite baddies in 5th edition playtesting material. Some of them lack a bit of something though, being too generic and D&Dish. They miss a bit of the Ravenloft spark.
So, for those of us interested in 5e, I would like to open a discussion of adding a little variety to the material we have so far.

We have werewolves, vampires, mummies, "ghosts" (they are a very very specific type), flesh golems, liches and a whole lot of fiends.
We lack salient powers for most of those kinds and we lack wererats.
We also lack... curses. :?

So, anyone willing to give a fraternity brother a hand to spice those things up?

Changes don't have to be dramatic IMO.
Example:
Vampire spellcaster: Gets 1 3rd lvl spells, 2 2nd lvl wizard spells each castable 1/day. Also a spooky cantrip like minor illusion to mess with people (noises and all) at will. Avoids flashy evocations.
Vampire warrior: Gets 2d6 martial dice like a fighter, +1 to hit rolls and parry. Comes equipped with a stylish armor+1 and attacks with a sword instead of claws.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Tue Jan 01, 2013 11:44 pm
by Jester of the FoS
I have ideas, but I'm purposely holding off getting my design on until the game is finalized.
But you can really imagine things like fear checks being Intelligence saves, and madness saves being a Charisma save.

Monsters and the like seem really easy to tweak as well. Shouldn't be hard to add curses and the like. And salient powers are just alternate powers, which have been much more common the last couple editions.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2013 4:31 am
by alhoon
I would respectfully disagree with Madness being charisma saves. Also, adding a power in 5th edition seems to change the XP worth a little in most cases.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2013 11:09 am
by Zilfer
Why charisma save being madness? i'm kind of curious as to the reasoning behind that.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2013 11:39 am
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Also, adding a power in 5th edition seems to change the XP worth a little in most cases.
Look at all the customization options already in the Bestiary. I don't see anything about extra xp. Heck, the death knight can gain a 9 lives stealer with no bonus to the PCs.

I can see skeletons and zombies in Ravenloft gaining traits like the giant lizard in the latest package.
Zilfer wrote:Why charisma save being madness? I'm kind of curious as to the reasoning behind that.
Charisma is the sense of self and identity. Madness tends to involve your personal worldview crumbling.
Saving against madness traditionally relates to force of willpower, but Wisdom saves do not equate with that as much, representing wise people and common sense.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2013 1:21 pm
by Zilfer
Ah i see, I saw Charisma as "force of personality" rather than that. Though the saves are being changed in 5e quite a bit.

I figured in my head it doesn't quite match with charisma either because even 'crazy' people can be charismatic. but to each his own :D

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2013 6:04 pm
by alhoon
Well, Lizard's XP does change with abilities. There is IIRC a couple more low level monsters that do change. Monsters aren't done yet though.

About Charisma being sense of self and madness hitting that, I still disagree. Domination should be opposed with charisma saves. Madness isn't your sense of self-identification crumbling in all cases, it's your mind crushing unable to cope with a shock in many saves.

Yeah, Madness from contact an alien mind seems like a charisma save. A madness from an Allip? I would say wisdom since you "Defend" with your willpower which is traditionally more wisdom. Madness from failed horror check? Madness from losing everything you worked for? THat's wisdom IMO.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2013 6:18 pm
by Zilfer
After all if you don't know what you've lost.... sometimes it wouldn't feel like your broken! (Hence the penalty of Wisdom against Madness increasing the DC I believe? Poor Poor monks... xD)

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2013 2:33 am
by HuManBing
Hmm, you might be able to cobble together a general "Mental" attribute by averaging out your Int, Wis, and Cha. Add them up and divide by 3 and you have a derived number to roll against for Madness.

Just like you could similarly deduce a general "Physical" attribute by averaging out Str, Dex, and Con.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2013 5:57 am
by alhoon
Meh, that's ... like a will save and a fort save. It would be easier to make a new attribute named sanity, but I think sanity as well as common sense and intuition it's part of wisdom.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2013 11:58 am
by HuManBing
alhoon wrote:Meh, that's ... like a will save and a fort save.
For context, the GURPS equivalent of a horror or fear check is a direct roll against your Will attribute. So it's definitely workable.
alhoon wrote:It would be easier to make a new attribute named sanity, but I think sanity as well as common sense and intuition it's part of wisdom.
For context, Call of Cthulhu does exactly that - make Sanity a separate attribute. So that's definitely workable too.

Of course, DnD's system has to take the legacy rules of past editions into account, so whether it's palatable is a completely separate question. But definitely workable, if you're willing to take it that way.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2013 4:21 pm
by alhoon
I was talking about 5th edition D&D HMB. :wink:
Yes, using a different rules system (or a quite modified 5th edition system) we could work something out. If it comes to that... I would prefer the Madness saves of 2nd edition.

PS I kinda liked the sanity as attribute in Cthulu, but I can't say I liked the mechanics as far as I remember them. You know what I liked best Sanity-wise? Arkham horror's take on sanity: It counts as different hit point system.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2013 11:17 pm
by Zilfer
I've never played though heard interesting things about them.... :D isn't that a board game?

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2013 11:19 am
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I was talking about 5th edition D&D HMB. :wink:
Yes, using a different rules system (or a quite modified 5th edition system) we could work something out. If it comes to that... I would prefer the Madness saves of 2nd edition.

PS I kinda liked the sanity as attribute in Cthulu, but I can't say I liked the mechanics as far as I remember them. You know what I liked best Sanity-wise? Arkham horror's take on sanity: It counts as different hit point system.
And here's the strength of 5th Edition: the focus on modularity and drop-in design. Why settle for just one version of madness?
There can be one for games that need periodic madness with a single save sending you into insanity. And there could be a variant where you track Sanity with insanity being a regular threat. People can decide how much of a role they want madness to play a part in their game.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2013 4:33 pm
by Leliel
alhoon wrote:I was talking about 5th edition D&D HMB. :wink:
Yes, using a different rules system (or a quite modified 5th edition system) we could work something out. If it comes to that... I would prefer the Madness saves of 2nd edition.

PS I kinda liked the sanity as attribute in Cthulu, but I can't say I liked the mechanics as far as I remember them. You know what I liked best Sanity-wise? Arkham horror's take on sanity: It counts as different hit point system.
You know what I liked? Unknown Armies.

There are many different kinds of stressor, and most people do not react to them the same way. One person might come out of the Far Realm perfectly fine, if a little shaken, but human cruelty might send him to tears.

UA realized that, and realized that system works very well with its brand of humanistic horror.